Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Hunter vs Eliminator

Posts

Hunter vs Eliminator

#1

Hunter vs Eliminator

Brian McInturff

>I've read a lot of post about the Hunter tools and since John Lucas seems to like them so well I'm thinking about adding a couple to my arsenal.

Now my question: Is there any difference between them and the Eliminator, and are the carbide disk like the ones used in the Munro.

Thanks, Brian

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

#2

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>I bought the Mega Eliminator while at Portland AAW Symposium last fall and I love it. The Mega, with 1" shaft and balanced handle allows you to get way out over the tool rest. Contrary to what some have said about the milled flats on the shaft, the tool is just as round on the bottom as the Hunter and can be rotated easily...you are not at all restricted to the 45 deg. cutter position, but those flats are very helful when cutting deep and blind.

From very aggressive, ribbon throwing, hoggin out material, to very light clean up cuts, it's a sweet tool. I don't know about the Munro, but I suspect that the carbide cutters are very similar for all three tools.

The Eliminators, in each graduated size is a bit spendier, but the length and heavier diameter shaft selection, would (and did) sway me.

Hope this info is helpful...

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

#3

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

john lucas

>Mike Thanks for you input on that tool. I have never owned any of the above tools but did do some research on them. The Eliminator does appear to use the same cutters as the Hunter. I think the shaft is generally thicker. I'm glad to hear that you can easily rotate it to other angles because I like to change cutting angle depending on what I'm doing. Looks like a good choice for many people.

The Rolly Munro is a good tool but the cutter is HSS which is OK but won't hold an edge nearly as long as the Hunter and Eliminator. The only complaints I've heard about the tool is that it can be difficult to adjust the sheild and it clogs easily. On the plus side it's almost impossible to get a catch, at least from the demo I saw that appeared to be the case. Another advantage is the articulated head which allows you to reach into more places on a hollow vessel.

Another tool not mentioned is the Supercut Universal. It has a cutter similar in appearance to the Hunter but it's HSS. It also has an articulated head. It doesn't have the cap that helps eliminate catches but like some of the Hunter and the eliminator it is pre angled to help you get the proper cutting angle.

I'd like to hear any other comments on all of these tools. I think they are interesting and would like to know the differences.

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

#4

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator *LINK*

georgetroy

>"Another tool not mentioned is the Supercut Universal. It has a cutter similar in appearance to the Hunter but it's HSS. It also has an articulated head. It doesn't have the cap that helps eliminate catches but like some of the Hunter and the eliminator it is pre angled to help you get the proper cutting angle". Per John Lucus.

I have had the BCT Supercut tools long before the Hunter & Eliminator were out. I have the 5/8", 1/2" and 3/8. They are great for me with the outriggers to resist torque twist. They are expensive. Like all tools they have limitations, 8" overhang is as deep as you can go. I wish the cutter wheels were carbide, however I can and do sharpen wheels as needed. From Packard Woodworks. I sold my Woodcut, Hamblet & Jerry Glazer tools

http://www.packardwoodworks.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=CTGY&Category_Code=tools-sut


http://groups.msn.com/CreativeWoodturnersII/georgetroy.msnw?action=ShowPhoto&PhotoID=6

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

#5

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

robo hippy

>I have one of the Super Cut tools, and used it a lot on boxes and other end grain turnings. Their cutter can be resharpened with a small mandril that is included. I would put it into my drill, and hold a diamond hone up to it. I really thing that the carbide cutters should be able to do the same thing because they do need diamond to be sharpened. I just hate to throw away something that can be reused.

robo hippy

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

#6

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

john lucas

>I agree. I'm looking at some abrasive wheels that used in the jewelry industry to see if you could use one of those to sharpen a Hunter Tool. Of course with shipping it might cost more than simply replacing the tool.

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

#7

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

Brian McInturff

>Thanks guys for the response. I guess I need to make a trip and try one out. Thanks Again

Re: Hunter vs Eliminator

#8

Why sharpen a Hunter?

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Trying to sharpen one would create a facet or two and change the characteristics of the tool. It looks like they are created with a centerless grinding operation.

I have a #4 that recently cut into some small dia. nails that were buried deep in a piece of walnut. I was hollowing out for a deep platter when I heard a strange noise. The Hunter cutter had a tiny chip on it and 4 metal pieces,in the wood, revealed themselves. I tried to pull them out, but they wouldn't budge. I was afraid I was dealing with barbed wire, so I continued working the surface taking light cuts until the metal was carved away. I loosened the locking screw and rotated the cutter to a new area and continued with the project. Prior to this I hadn't noticed any wear on that area of the cutter.