Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Turning Burl's

Posts

Turning Burl's

#1

Turning Burl's

john lucas

>OK this applies to turning any piece of wood really. I was reading an article about Mike Jackofsky and he made the statement. "Most people seem to make a shape that is dependent on the size and shape of the piece as it was cut. But I have realized over the years that it is better to lose some of the material and end up with a smaller piece that you find pleasing, rather than trying to get the biggest piece you can make."

What a perfect statement. How many of you have taken a 5x5x2 inch piece of exotic wood you bought and made a 5x5x2" bowl. I have and probably still will sometimes but mostly now I try to imagine what I can best make from the piece of wood even if I need to make it smaller. This is especially true of odd shaped burls that you acquire.

Re: Turning Burl's

#2

Re: Turning Burl's

Steven Kubien

>As I struggle with 'form' more, I find myself sacrificing some good, pretty wood in order to get a better shape. Gotta admit that it's tough to see that feathery grain disappear. Sometimes figure only appears through part of a blank and as that part gets smaller... Well, let's just say I stop the lathe a lot, look at what I've got and shudder as I take more away in the interest of a pleasing shape.

Good topic John. I hope it encourages a few of us to try to get the best from a piece, not just the most.

Steve Kubien

Re: Turning Burl's

#3

Re: Turning Burl's

Texian

>John,

Please send me a burl and I will try it.

Richard in Wimberley

Re: Turning Burl's

#4

Re: Turning Burl's

Brian McInturff

>I tend to spend a lot of time looking at a piece of burl before I ever put a tool to it. I trie to see if there is any that I can cut away with the bandsaw and "save" for a later time. I even do that now with heavily spalt figured wood.

Re: Turning Burl's

#5

Re: Turning Burl's

Carole Valentine

>One of my first comments to new turners is that basically, turning is taking away wood to create a pleasing form. One thing I have noticed is that almost all beginning turners (and some more advanced) will get a nice piece of wood as you described - maybe 5"x5"x2" - and in the interest of "saving wood" will end up a 4.75x4.75x1.75 straight sided dog dish. Now there is nothing wrong with a dog dish, mind you, but because of the sharp transition between side and bottom, this is the most difficult type of bowl to turn - especially for beginners. It leads to a lot of frustration, catches and tool marks for someone who is just learning the craft. Fair curves and smooth transitions are more important than what's under your feet. I never worry about how many shavings are on the floor or what those shaving may have cost. I only worry about the form when I am turning. When I am cutting up a chunk of wood on the bandsaw or with the chainsaw, however, I do try to get as much as possible out of it and still have the grain and orientation I want for various pieces, but that's another story.

Re: Turning Burl's

#6

Steven Antonucci

It's a really, really, really hard habit to break

steve antonucci

>I think it's even harder for those among us that "buy" wood. I've gotten to the point to where it would need to be the single most incredible piece of wood I've ever seen before I'd pay for it.

It's also one of the reasons that I break things down as soon as I can (way before I'm ready to turn it). The longer it sits in a big log, the more likely I make a 5x5x2 piece.

Steven

Re: Turning Burl's

#7

Re: Turning Burl's

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Burls are like diamonds. Uncut they are pretty. Cut PROPERLY, they are beautiful. I have been studying a cherry burl for several months now, and just today cut it, slicing off about a third. It is on the lathe right now, waiting to be finished tomorrow morning. I still have 2/3 left for other pieces.

Bill

Re: Turning Burl's

#8

The form needs to be 1st , but

Jake Niedling

>....I always try to maximize the use of the size of the wood. That is why many times that piece of burl will wait patiently until I can decide what to make with it. An yes sometimes it does need to be cut to a different size with the cut-offs saved for something else.

Re: Turning Burl's

#9

Re: Turning Burl's

Cyril Griesbach

>John, you are so correct. Having talked extensively with Mike when he was here in November he attributes much of his skills to having been mentored by Mike Mahoney who is known to believe that it's always better to sacrifice wood for form. Now, in reality, just how long did it really take most of us to come to that conclusion. And, have we really made it.