Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Standing on the shoulder of giants...

Posts

Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#1

Steven Antonucci

Standing on the shoulder of giants...

steve antonucci

>I've been reading the responses below regarding lessons vs. going it alone. Interesting topic (to me at least), and since I know some of the people and agree with both sides of the argument, I'll try to stay out of it...

But...

How important do you think learning vs others vs. self exploration is? I'll start with the following:

I think initially EVERY turner benefits from learning from others. We all need to understand how tools cut, good technique, good form and other input is extremely helpful in getting you to a certain point.

However, I think that at some point, you end up needing to be alone to explore doing new, and sometimes "uncomfortable" things. I mean "uncomfortable" in the sense that we may not know how to do it, or it may have never been done and we have to create it. I mean "uncomfortable" in that we might have to expose more of ourselves than we might care to expose.

I wish that I had taken lessons earlier to get past some of the beginner issues. I could have started self exploration at a much earlier time.

Jump in folks.

Steven

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#2

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Steve

I agree. #1 get help and guidance, but keep an open mind. Learn the safe way to do things, but keep an open mind.

Learn the proper way to sharpen your tools, but keep an open mind.

When I teach one of the first things I tell the person is this is my way, not the only way to do things and for them to keep an open mind. I always remember the first AAW Symp. I went to. The first demo person told us we needed to rough up the ways so the tail stock would stay in place when locked, his rule. The very next guy says to keep the ways polished slick and to use a little oil on them so it was easier to move the tail stock, his rule.

My favorite saying was by Albert Einstein " Imagination is more important than knowledge".

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#3

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

Cyril Griesbach

>Very well put, Steve, and right on target in my opinion. If I had found an AAW chapter, a mentor, a nearby class or Wood Central earlier in my turning experience I know I'd have much more easily overcome lots of the initial frustrations.

Just one example...turning and sharpening go hand in hand and the new turner has to aquire two different, yet closely associated, skill sets at the same time. When I finally learned to sharpen a grind that I liked I later tried other grinds just to see what differences there would be. After nearly a dozen styles I now use mostly three grinds for bowl gouges and each is sharpened with a different technique.

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#4

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I've never taken a turning lesson from anyone. That's not a brag, it's just a fact. I bought my first lathe in 1936 when I was a teen ager. I just played around with it...made things like candle holders. small boxes, etc. I would have been delighted to have a mentor to give me some much needed help. I didn't turn at all in the 40's..WW2 and other things got in the way. I acquired my second lathe in the early 50's. I was completely on my own as there weren't any clubs to join, and in fact no other turners that I knew of. I didn't meet another turner until about 1983, 47 years after I turned my first bowl. So yes, I'm 100% self taught.

I've been teaching turning for a lot of years, so I do very much believe in taking turning lessons. I've just never gotten around to taking hands-on lessons from others. The many symposiums that I've attended and watching many club demos have helped a lot. However, demos are great for inspiration but are a poor subsitute for hands on learning in my opinion.

There many turners whose work I admire that I would like to learn from. Some day in the near future I'm going to get off my butt and take some lessons. There is a lot to learn out there.

Wally

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#5

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

don at central illinois

>I agree. I was fortunate to have someone who has been turning for over 50 years and teaches out of the joy of teaching. I first learned the proper techniques, etc. with hands on training and now that I have a lathe at home, those lessons have proved invaluable.

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#6

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

robo hippy

>I have kind of a standard disclaimer that I start every demo with. It goes something like "What I am showing you is what I have picked up over the years. It may or may not work for you. I haven't done anything to the point that I do it the same way every time, which means that I reserve the right to change my mind about how I do things in the future." I watch others to see what they do, how they do it, and why they do it. Then I try it and see if any or all of it can be applied to what I already do. My methods are the sum of many who have gone before me. After all, isn't that what learning is?

robo hippy

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#7

Steven Antonucci

A question for you?

steve antonucci

>A perfect example of my original question. You've spent a lifetime in developing your tools skills and turning techniques. If you were just starting out today, would you want to go through the same process or would you want to build on other people's experience?

I'm only asking about the nuts and bolts- the things that we do standing in front of the lathe with a tool in hand. If there was a way to get tool skills in a short period of time, would you take it? Whether it was a class or a pill, how important do you think it is to "apprentice"?

Steven

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#8

Re:Teaching others is a distillation of .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... techniques that I have learned from others, and it's never "my way or the highway!" I've been around long enough to know the truth in the saying that those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat the mistakes of the past. And I also believe we can always learn something from anyone else, reqardless of perceived differences.

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#9

Re: A question for you?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>If I had had someone to mentor me, help me along the way, I would have been delighted. But I didn't. I turned my first bowl in high school shop. The shop teacher was pretty good at spindle turning, but he didn't know any more about bowl turning than I did, so I was on my own from the start. For me, being self taught was only because I had no other alternative.

Along the way I acquired a couple of books, but they were on spindle turning. Around 1980 I found a book that had just been published on bowl turning. It was written by Dale Nish. There was no mention of a bowl gouge. The bowl gouge wasn't marketed in this country until after 1980. It took a few years for it to be discovered by woodturners.

I have a question: If you had a 4 x 12 bowl blank and all of your tools were spindle turning tools, how would you turn a salad bowl? That's what faced turners in those days.

In 1982 or 83 I saw an ad in a local paper stating that Dale Nish was going to do a turning demo at a local woodworkers store. Of course I eagerly attended. There were perhaps 25 woodturners there. Dale demonstrated a bowl gouge. What an eye-popper! None of us had ever seen one before. Watching those beautiful long curls of wood come off that bowl was an experience for us all. Dale was the first person that I had ever seen turn wood.

Many of the attendees became good friends. The following year I went to Provo to one of the early Symposiums...My turning world had changed forever.

Wally

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#10

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I have been turning for just over 5 years. When I bought my first lathe and set of tools, I had no idea what I was doing, so I just did it. I sharpened those tools the best I could by hand, then figured out how to put the wood on the lathe. I had to make a tail center. That lathe had 1/2"x20 thread so I bought a jacob's chuck and made a dead center from a bolt. I also bought a faceplate at Sears. I then proceeded to mount the faceplate on a section of log, end grain. Then I stuck the tool into it. I woke up very quickly with the big bang I got when to tool hit the toolrest. Fortunately it didn't break. I then proceeded to turn my first piece, a pedestal bowl. I hollowed it with a skew. He**, I didn't know any better, and it cut.

Anyway, I continued working like that, trying different things to see what happened. Then, I found my turning club and everything changed. I discovered the correct way to hold the tools and present them. I found that I was doing everything wrong. I began to absorb everything I could find and watching everyone I could.

I'm hoping to attend my first class this summer, but have been to several get-together's and have had several lessons from members in my club.

If I had know about my club when I started out, I would not have wasted a year trying to figure out what I was doing, but would have been able to get off to a good start in the first place.

My suggestion to anyone is to learn the technique because it will give you a good base and a good base will make it possible to evolve beyond the basic, opening up any number of possibilities.

Sorry this is so long.

keithz

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#11

don't forget books

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I got no instruction to start out, but after a while I saw some demos and took a couple of courses. Although I highly enjoyed hanging out and listening and watching someone's techniques, I don't think I learned much of anything new about woodturning.

But I did have many "lessons" from experts without taking courses or being face to face with an expert. I'm talking about books. I realize not everyone works well with books, but when starting out I learned most of my techniques and safety from books.

When I started turning I bought every book I could find and read them from cover to cover, over and over. I tried the techniques on the lathe, then went back and read again. A face-to-face class is fun, but there is seldom time to get into any depth. I'm as or more interested in the "why" as I am the "how". Videos are also useful, but again, there is never enough time in even a 2-hour video to get into detail.

Books, on the other hand, can contain a wealth of detail, instruction, examples, and techniques illustrated by photos, charts, and sketches. Instead of showing just one way to do something, a book can show several ways and describe the tradeoffs. For example, consider the companions of Raffan's video Turning Wood and the book Turning Wood. The video is great, but the book covers MANY times the information in the video. You will miss so much choosing just the video.

A one or two week course with an expert is a different story, but wonder if short one-evening or one-day courses are worth the money.

BTW, I think a good demo also qualifies as a "lesson". I personally get as much or more from watching a good demo than I did from either of the two classes I took. In a demo, more time can be spent getting information than in a class, where a good part of the time was reserved for students turning.

As for specific books, I'm not going to list my entire library but here are some of the books that were useful to me:

I think these two are by far the best for starting out:

Turning Wood, Raffan

Fundamentals of Woodturning, Darlow

General woodturning:

Woodturning: A Foundation Course, Keith Rowley

Woodturning, Two Books in One, Phil Irons

Turning Green Wood, Michael O'Donnell

Woodturning Methods, Darlow

Woodturning with Ray Key

The Art of the Lathe, Patrick Spielman

Turning Projects, Raffan

Small Scale Woodturning, Duce

Woodturning, A Fresh Approach, Robert Chapman

Projects for the Mini Lathe, Dick Sing

Projects for Woodturners, Chris Child

A few specialty books:

Turning Bowls, Raffan

Turning Boxes, Raffan

Work-Holding on the Lathe, Fred Holder

Making Screw Threads in Wood, Fred Holder

Pens from the Wood Lathe, Dick Sing

Turning Pens and Pencils, Christensen and Burningham

Some great related information:

How to Sharpen Anything, Don Geary

Understanding Wood, R. Bruce Hoadley

JKJ, hopeless book maniac

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#12

Re: don't forget books

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Thanks, John.

I just copied your list so I can work my way through it. I like books, too. I can study the pictures, contemplate the text, try a few things, think things through. Last week I dozed through a video!

In a book, I can also skip around to get questions answered as I learn. I usually need to start the video over from the beginning!

But a combination of the two, if done to compliment one another is a good thing.

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#13

Re: A question for you?

Donna Banfield

>I agree with Wally's comment about demonstrations being great for inspiration, but nothing beats hands-on.

Last fall, my turning club brought JoHannes Michelsen in for a 2-day workshop. On day one, he demonstrated turning his signature full-sized hat. Raffle tickets were sold in the morning, and a drawing before lunch to determine the winner (stealth gloat here), and I had the winning ticket, so the full-sized hat was sized to fit me.

Day two was a mini-workshop where you turned your own mini-hat. I attended both days. Inspired (see, Wally, it does work), I signed up for Hannes' 3-day workshop at his studio in Vermont a couple months later. I turned a full-size range-rider hat, extremely thin. I can also sharpen the tools that are used to turn very thin, and no jigs or grinding aides are utilized. In fact, I prefer the hand-held sharpened grind on the v-fluted gouges to the side-grind or Ellsworth grind for a lot of my bowl work now.

So the point I'm making is, I would not have been able to turn a hat, or very thin "anything" without the 3-day workshop. I would not have been able to sharpen my gouges without a jig without the 3-day workshop. I'll admit that the workshop was a 3-day "white-knuckle" weekend for me, but I came away with skills that I would have taken ten years to acquire on my own.

Here's a photo of the hat I turned, sized to fit my husband's head.


img

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#14

Steven Antonucci

A perfect illustration!

steve antonucci

>Thanks for illustrating my point so clearly! I think sometimes it takes a simple example to clarify a complex point.

I was trying to say that I WISH I had taken a class earlier to advance my skills to a level where I could do simple things well without having to think about them all that hard. I would have shortened the learning curve by 50% or more.

Now that I have most of the basics, I can explore "new" things...

Steve

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#15

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

Don Orr

>Great thread Steven,

I was apparently one of the lucky ones who was able to get some instruction early on. I relied a lot on books at first, which I consider a form of instruction. I went to my first Pro demo only 2 months after starting to turn. Saw Al Stirt on my birthday in 2001 (and I have the signed demo piece !) I joined our local club shortly after that and watched and asked questions a lot. I'm also lucky that I can pick things up by watching or reading and then trying them myself. Now I just have to spend some time going beyond the basics, branching out of my comfort zone.

I firmly believe that a good foundation in the basics is imoportant, whether learned from someone or self taught. I keep going back to the saying I heard from an art teacher-you need to know the rules before you can break them.

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#16

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

Ron in Drums PA

>I was doing flat work for years before I started turning. Almost everything I knew was self taught.

When I got a lathe I decided for the first time to take a woodworking class. The only thing I turned before the class was two dowels. I really shouldn't call it turning, it was more like poking. But I was happy because they used to be square and now they where round.

So after a full week of poking those 2 dowels, I headed down to Allentown for my first class. I walked out of that class with the knowledge on how to cut and mount a bowl blank, a good understand about bowl gouges and how to sharpen them. We also sanded and finished the bottom of the bowl. There was some time left so we started playing with a spindle gouge and then a skew. In no time I was cutting round square spindles with a skew by using both a pealing cut and a planning cut. We played with v grooves. When I finally got back home I was able to show off to my family my first completed bowl.

I learn all this on the first day of real turning and my head was spinning. When I went home I practiced all the new skills I was taught.

I would say I learn from this teacher what would take me three or more years learning on my own.

I wouldn't do it any other way.

Thanks Bill Grumbine

Below is the bowl turned in that class.


img

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#17

Absolutely beautiful wood...

Allen Neighbors

>Ron, what kind of wood is that bowl?

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#18

Steven Antonucci

I'd guess ambrosia maple

steve antonucci

>Grows on trees around here... :-)

Steve

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#19

Re: Absolutely beautiful wood...

Ron in Drums PA

>Ambrosa Maple with a danish oil finish

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

#20

George Balock

Re: Standing on the shoulder of giants...

George Balock

>Steve,

This is an interesting topic indeed! There is a book that I think that all artists should read called "Art & Fear" By David Bayles and Todd Orland. One of the things that the authors talk about in the book is that there are two parts to any creative process, one is technique, two is the actual ceation. You can't progress into the creative part until you have mastered some of the technique. With that said, lessons get you over that first hurdle.

Anecdotally speaking, I was self taught for a number of years, but then I went to the 2000 AAW symposium in Minneapolis. My turning took a major jump forward after that event.

George