>I'm still in the beginning stages of learning how to turn. I have a 1" Thompson scraper that I am going to turn into a "bowl scraper" shape, and will be ordering another so that I can still have a square scraper. But I was wondering what other scraper shapes I should be considering before placing an order. I thought maybe a smaller scraper with a round nose profile.
>I use a round nose a lot, but even more I use one that is rounded on the left side only. I also use a spear point scraper for getting in to recesses and for end grain hollowing.
Also, keep in mind that if you buy some straight, square scrapers of various widths, you can make them into any shape you want on the grinder. I made the spear point I mentioned.
>I rarely use the roundnose anymore. I used to use it a lot for bowls but simply don't need it anymore. I use a flat scraper a lot for shear scraping the outside of my handmirrors. For the outside of bowls and vessels I use the John Jordan shear scraper.
I used to have scraper that I think was made for hollowing under the lip of the bowl. I never used it. I finally turned it into a convex edge skew.
>I recommend a skew scraper. Shaped like a skew chisel but with only one bevel. It's great for working around the foot where a gouge might not do well. You'll have to make your own out of a square nose or even a round nose tool. I use mine a lot.
>I have a number of scrapers. I prefer the inside, or rounded off on the left side also. I have a round nose, a Raffen shear/skew scraper that has more of a skew chisel profile, an outside profile (rounded off on the right side) and a round nose scraper. I use them mostly for roughing out bowl blanks. I prefer the inside scraper for bowls. I like the flattened profile on the side for flattening the bottom of a bowl, and it will also do shear cuts. The flatter profile is also better for getting the final shape on a bowl before I take a finish cut with a gouge. This profile also works well for a finish shear cut across the inside bottom of a bowl. The round nose isn't flat enough to get a consistant shape on a bowl without a lot of effort. I am slowly regrinding it each time I sharpen it to take on more of a outside profile. I also just ordered some of the Thompson scrapers.
The inside and outside profiles come from face plate turning, where you mount the face plate to the bottom of your blank, and then turn the whole bowl from there. The outside profiled one works better this way, coming from the headstock up to the rim of the bowl, and the inside one works better on the inside of the bowl. When you use a chuck, and turn the bottom and outside first, then reverse it for coring and/or turning the inside, then there is no inside or outside profile difference in which works easier. I do use the outside profiled scraper to flatten off and even up the top edge of the bowl blank to help balance the blank (so I can turn at higher speeds. One advantage in using a scraper for roughing cuts is that you can remove a lot of wood very fast, and you can cut easily on push or pull cuts.
>I also don't use one a-lot, but I have the huge one that woodcraft sells with there name on it. I use this primarily for cleaning up any tool marks I might have left but I also put a negative rake angle on this tool. I grind the top edge down at an angle so that the cutting edge is a 1/4 inch below the top where it would normally be. You have to sharpen often but it takes a very nice fine cut.It also takes away a-lot of catches grinding like this.
>Depends on what your area of interest is. Boxes have a set of scrapers that are not normally used in bowls. And some of those used in bowls are too big for boxes. Also a good bowl scraper will generally be thicker than ones used for boxes. I have some that are almost 1/2" thick to go over the rest much like the deep fluted gouges vs the shallow fluted.
I do both so I have some for bowls/boxes and some for boxes only and some which were for bowls only. For boxes, I use a 1" round nose ground up the left side - it is a "Raffan" scraper and you can find the shape in the C.S. catalog. I also have another which is a "Ray Key" style, ling grind up the side but the end is ground back at and angle with a radius for rounding corners. I also use some 1/2" and 1" square end scrapers along with a 1/2" round nose for some detail work. The Raffan style is what I use the most. I also use a skew layed flat as a negative rake scraper on the end grain, it produces a fine surface not needing sanding if done correctly. Since it is hard on the edge, I bought a 1/2" square end chisel and ground the same angle and slight bevel on the top so I don't have to use the skew for that anymore. I only use this on boxes.
For bowls I also use the Raffan scraper. I have one of the Raffan spear points and a 1 1/4" or 1 1/2" wide scraper which has the same profile as the Raffan box scraper. In a hands on workshop, Raffan gave me the profile for a scraper he uses a lot. It is made from a 1" skew and has the same profile as his skew, which is a slight radius and not the simitar sweep from his early videos. It has a 45 degree bevel and used to clean up the outside of bowls. Can be used flat or in a shear. He also uses this on the inside of bowls for removing material quickly and getting a smooth surface. I have several of these in both left and right hand for inside and outside of a bowl. I don't use these on boxes.
>I have several scrapers ranging in size from 1/4" to 1 1/2" wide, and ranging is shape from square to round. My 1/4" round and square are used for small turnings like bottlestoppers. My 1/2" round works really well for turning corian and antler pens. I also use it in the bottom of mini hollow forms. In addition to the regular style scrapers, I also have one of the Sorby multi-tip shear scrapers with the teardrop scraper. I occasionally use it on both the inside and outside of bowls, but not as often as I used to because I am working to get used to using my Hunter cutters instead.
My recommendation, since you are a new woodturner, is to first invest in a good woodturning course from a good and knowledgeable woodturner. This will save you a lot of money in unnecessary tool purchases, will get you started with the proper turning techniques and safety procedures, and will point you in the right equipment direction for the type of turnings you want to do.
>When ever I read the recommendation to take a course on something,I always wonder about the first guy who ever tried something no one else had ever done.
>Very true but a lot of inovations in tool usage also come from long time turners who understand how tools work and develop new techniques.
I think the main reason we recommend courses is that it reduces the learning curve so greatly. Most of us who didn't learn from advanced turners can vividly remember the many catches we had and the frustration of trying to create a shape only to mess it up with a bad cut.
What puzzles me is the first guy to decide that eating something that came out of a chickens butt would be a good idea.
>I admit I was and am dumb. I learned driving from lessons. It took my mom to teach me how to count fingers, my teachers how to do math; and I still can't count the change right every time. I was not the first to invent and discover every thing.
I would rather learn from others experience. I would rather learn the safety precaution on a table saw from others' accidents.
I am not 16 any more. I am afraid by the time I invented and perfected every technique I need to turn, not much time would have left. I doubt a lot of people can chase threads with hand chasers without watching some demo, video or lessons.
I did enjoy all the classes I took in woodturning. To me, I think money spent on classes has more returns than on tools.
>his first try for Mammoth steaks was his last. The second guy took notes and almost made it. The third guy studied the notes then did what his wife told him to do and had grilled steaks.
>I have seen many woodworkers who have clear visual evidence that they learned woodworking safety through the school of hard knocks. Those injuries could have been prevented, in most part, if they simply had learned proper usage from someone elses experience and knowledge. In my 60-years of woodworking I have not had a serious accident, because I first sought and followed good advice. I have seen accidents and injuries that could have been prevented with a little forethought or assistance from an experienced woodworker.
>Thanks for all the input! Just so that you don't worry, I've taken two courses on turning so far, although they were about a year ago and I just got my lathe setup up and running in December. I'm set up to take another bowl turning course weekend after next, to help me remember what I've forgotten since those first two classes.
The main reason I posted my question is because I want to order some more scrapers from Doug Thompson, and was hoping just to make one order to save on shipping.
>No. What I'm saying is we all benefit by those going before us. Do you not use an electrical lathe probably made from some sort of metal or is part of your success based on the fact that you have invented an entirely different means of making your pens. You don't copy other designs or I think construction methods but it appears you do use pen parts designed by others. Would any of that be possible if somewhere along the way others were willing to teach?
Independent thinking is wonderful but if we didn't have good teachers I doubt we would have progressed much past the stone age if that far.