Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Using Cole Jaws

Posts

Using Cole Jaws

#1

Using Cole Jaws

Justin Fields

>Hi folks.

I'm a rookie turner and I've been having some problems with Cole jaws. I've made a grand total of 4 small bowls so far. In trying to finish the bottoms of the bowls with feet, I've used Cole jaws. On two bowls, the jaws left visible marks on the outside of the bowls, but otherwise worked fine. I was mostly able to run the marks off. On the other two bowls, I ended up with all-but finished pieces flying across the room and cracking/smashing.

So, my track record with the jaws isn't so hot. What methods do you all use to hold the pieces securely enough so they don't fall out, don't obstruct the bottom you are going to finish, and don't mark up or mess up the rims of the bowls.

I thought of putting rubber bands over the jaws and piece together, midway up the sides, but that seems like it ought to be unecessary. Any thoughts on what I'm doing wrong, or other ways to go about this?

Thanks!

Justin

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#2

Re: Using Cole Jaws

Carole Valentine

>Hi Justin. Many times Cole jaws are not the best method for holding a bowl. Jam or friction chucking may be the better option depending on the shape of the bowl. Also, with Cole jaws the speed at which you can turn is limited and the cuts should be very, very light. What was your lathe speed? Always bring your tailstock up for support for as long as you can (until you get to the part in the very middle of the base) As for the black marks from the grippers, try wiping them down good with alcohol. Sometimes the rubber has oxidized a bit. The other option is to put a layer of blue painters tape where the grippers contact the wood.

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#3

Re: Using Cole Jaws *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>I thought of putting rubber bands

>over the jaws and piece together

I usually use masking tape to hold the piece more securely in the jaws.

Also, to avoid the black marks I use paper, paper towel, or tape to protect the wood. I always wished they had made the rubber pieces out of a white or amber non-marking material. If I can find some material, I plan on constructing my own substitutes, probably concave rectangular shape instead of round which should provide more surface area for gripping.

I haven't made one, but some people have made wonderful donut-shaped devices to hold bowls. Example in the link below, or search the net for more.

JKJ


Donut chuck

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#4

Re: Using Cole Jaws

Russ Fairfield

>Now you know why my Cole Jaws sit on the shelf and are only used when nothing else will work.

The advice you have been given is good - turn slowly, take light cuts, and use the tail-center as long as possible.

The black marks they leave on the wood is easilly solved. Craft Supplies sells the rubber buttons made by Axminster. They will work on the other brands, they are a white rubber, and they will not leave marks like the black rubber that everyone else uses.

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#5

Re: Using Cole Jaws

john lucas

>It depends a lot on the shape of the bowl as to how well the cole jaws hold. Straight sided bowls are really difficult to hold with them. Bring the tailstock up and turn as much as you can with it in place. When you remove the tailstock and turn the last little but make sure you are rubbing the bevel and I actually put a little more pressure than normal on the bevel and slow down the speed I'm pushing the gouge. This pressure pushes on the bowl to keep it in place and the slow feed rate won't rip the bowl out of the jaws.

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#6

Re: Using Cole Jaws "Pic"

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Have to agree with John. Most of my bowls are flared or tapered so my Stronghold Mega Jumbo Jaws work very well. (Besides the wind noise.) Plus I don't seem to have the black marking problem unless I overtighten them. Just did a light Maple bowl last night with no marks. See photo!


img

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#7

Re: Using Cole Jaws

Justin Fields

>Thanks for all the good tips, folks! I'm sure that some combination of them will help. I figured there just must have been something I was missing.

Justin

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#8

Re: Using Cole Jaws

Steve Russell

>Hello Justin,

I have attached a picture of the modifications I made to my jumbo jaws. I totally removed the rubber buttons and replaced them with wooden faces. These faces are secured to the jaw plates at the extreme edges of the pie shaped plates using wood screws.

The wood is Poplar, which has been cut to size and trued up. Once modified, the jumbo jaws work much like an adjustable friction chuck... You simply open the jaws up slightly and turn a recess to hold the rim of the bowl. Then, install a paper towel around the bowl rim and install it in the jaws and tighten the chuck.

Using my system, I can use the jumbo jaws freehand (no tailstock) or I can use the tailstock for added support if desired. Depending on the shape of the bowl, I may add strapping tape to the outer 1/3 of the bowl for added safety. I've been using this for about 11 or 12 years and it has worked perfectly. When the jaw faces eventually wear out, they are easy to replace. This is what I use for all of my production bowls and also for many of my artistic bowls. It's fast, easy and it works very well indeed. :-)

I'm posting this from an old Windows computer because I can't post to the board with my Mac right now due to the "webformboundarykit" error. I hope this comes out and the picture shows up... Keeping my fingers crossed!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas


img

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#9

Re: Using Cole Jaws

Rick Allen

>The trapezoidal red buttons for the Vicmarc "cole" jaws are the best at holding and not marking the work.

The big advantage of "Cole" jaws over the "Donut chuck" is that you have access to more of the back side of the bowl. This lets you blend sanding and finish better.

Using the tailstock to apply pressure towards the headstock will help a LOT in keeping the bowl in the "cole" jaws. You can cover the point on the live center so as not to dig a hole in the back side of the nearly finished turning. And you don't HAVE to cut off the last connection between the bowl and the tailstock. You can cut the small piece of wood off the back side after the bowl is removed from the lathe and hand sand that area.

Sharp tools will cause less cutting resistance meaning that the bowl is less likely to be pulled from the "cole" jaws.

Vicmark buttons

Tailstock presure

Sharp tools

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#10

Re: Thumbnail's bigger than pic, Steve.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#11

Re: Using Cole Jaws

Justin Fields

>That is a neat solution. Depending on how the wood was affixed, it could leave the jaws completely intact, should you want to go back to the screw-in knobs. The wood could also be shaped to essentially provide step jaws, with the distance between the steps being a little less than the range of travel of the jaws.

It looks to me like this would be easier to center than the donut-chuck setup, but admittedly less secure (in the absence of the tailstock).

I'll have to ponder this and see what I come up with the next time I go to the shop. "Going to the shop" is part of the issue. I work at a shared club with fairly limited storage, so the bulkier donut apparatus might be hard to keep available, where the modified jaws could probably fit in my locker.

Thanks again, everyone.

Justin

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#12

Re: Thumbnail's bigger than pic, Steve.

Steve Russell

>Hello Allen,

Humm... Never seen that before! Cameras don't like me it seems and this continual error message I'm getting on the Mac is still unresolved. I've tried different methods of getting rid of it as posted on the Internet, but it remains. As for the difference is size of the photos, I'm clueless. I just posted the photo off my computer and somehow it got mangled. :-( Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#13

Mike Stafford

Use blue tape to help hold as well...

Mike Stafford

>I seldom use my Cole jaws these days as I very infrequently turn bowls. However when I did I never trusted them. In addition to using the tailstock for support I also used the blue paint to tape the bowl to the jaws. I put several/many strips of tape across the bowl and stuck it to the exposed surface of the Cole jaw sections and to the back of them as well. I also used tape to protect my work from black marks until I bought the white buttons from Craft Supplies.

My preferred method now is to use a double laminated section of MDF attached to a faceplate with carpet padding on the front. The bowl is brought up against the carpet padding and held in place with the tail stock. Of course you have to have a dimple in the center of the bottom so you can center the bowl with the tailstock. When I was doing segmented work this was my preferred method of reverse turning those pieces. I actually learned this method while taking a course at John C. Campbell.

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#14

Am I The Only One ?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Certainly not. The only time I get black from the buttons is when the bowl is not gripped tightly enough to keep it in place. Because I now have a vacuum system I don't use the Cole jaws much. When I did use them I would have the whole bowl done except for removing the tenon. This would be removed as much as possible with the tailstock in place and then carefully finished with the tailstock backed away.

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#15

Re: Am I The Only One ?

Donna Banfield

>Justin, here are a couple more options for you to consider.

One, when using the Cole Jaws, secure the bowl in place with Saran Wrap, or the clear plastic wrap that shippers use to bundle things. Sort of wrap around the edges, leaving the tenon or foot with plenty of access for turning, sanding and blending into the bowl side. You can purchase the stuff on a roll from office supply stores, like Staples and Office Max. I was given this idea from someone a while back on one of these newsgroups.

Two, when I used Cole jaws with the black rubber bumpers (that come with the Nova, by Tecknatool, I took one of the bumpers with me to Home 'Cheapo' and found clear plastic plumbing tubing, whose (nside diameter (ID) would fit snuggly over the outside diameter (OD) of the bumpers. That solved the problem of the black on my bowls.

I eventually sold all my Nova chucks and accessories and now use all Vicmarc chucks. Vicmarc's cole jaws use the red 'square' bumpers that work much better. However, I rarely use them now, because nearly everything is vaccuum-chucked. If I have a piece that has voids or cracks that prevent a vaccuum chuck from holding, I simply make a jam-chuck using a soft-squishy something (rubber carpet backing, cut-outs from the black rubber floor mats) and place it over the standard jaws of my chuck, place the interior of the bowl up against it, center it, and secure it with the tailstock. When I'm done cleaning up the bottom of the bowl, I remove the nib with a hand-held carving tool, or a skew, held very carefully so as not to remove a body part if I slip!

Woodturners are nothing if not clever. There are probably a dozen different ways to accomplish the same thing. Find what works best for you and your budget.

Oh, yeah...and welcome to the addiction! ;^)

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#16

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Using Cole Jaws

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Justin, liike Carole Valentine recommends always use the tailstock as support.

I too have had nasty accidents with Cole jaws and now take all the precautions I can to protect myself, even though it slows up the process. 99% of the time I avoid using them at all and retain the dovetail as a foot for the bowls to stand on, it sort of balances the whole thing, visually.

I have made ONLY one bowl specifically not to have a base and used a large diameter "O" ring as a stand but also experienced nearly losing fingers in the Cole jaw segments.

My advice, for what it is worth, is that as a newish turner, stick to bowls with bases until your experience increases.

(Steps down from soapbox)

Regards, Peter.

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#17

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Using Cole Jaws (Addendum)

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>I forgot to say that my Cole jaws are fitted with the White buttons from Axminster that are very effective and DO NOT mark the wood!

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#18

ebd

Re: Using Cole Jaws

ebd

>I use Cole jaws all the time and seldom need to use the tailstock. I seldom do a bowl with exactly verticle sides though. Almost always the lip turns in or out so the undercut of the button holds securely. My chucks are Axminster and I assume that the buttons on other Cole jaws are wider at the top and narrower at the bottom in the same way.

Also, some have advised using tape on the wood. I would caution against this. On some woods, especially when sanded extremely smooth, the adhesive will leach into the wood and discolor it. I ruined a very nice bubinga bowl that way. If you use tape, I would put it on the buttons rather than on the wood. That would also be a one time job.

Re: Using Cole Jaws

#19

ebd

Re: Using Cole Jaws

ebd

>Axminster buttons are white and don't mark the wood at all, even if you get some slippage. I don't see why they wouldn't work in any Cole jaws. Even if the machine screws are a different thread you could use the ones from the Cole you have and just use the Axminster buttons. I designed and had some extenders made by my next door neighbor (a machinest with his own shop). He didn't have metric taps so I had him do english and picked up machine screws at the local Ace Hdwr. Works just fine with the Axminster buttons.