Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

CA glue problem(Tool making)

Posts

CA glue problem(Tool making)

#1

CA glue problem(Tool making)

Eric Knutsen

>I've made a few Ellsworth style hollowing tools but I seem to be having an issue with the tip falling out of the "sidewall tool". The rod is drilled at approx a 70 deg. angle for the cutter tip which is dowelled down to fit into the drilled hole in the rod. I've CA glued it in but it eventually falls out while turning. I don;t use accelerator. Could it be the glue is bad? My shop, when I'm not in it can drop down to 45-50 deg. Any suggestions?

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#2

Steven Antonucci

Probably not a clean surface

steve antonucci

>I have used set screws in the past (square peg, round hole). This is harder to do when the cutters get small, so I have CA'ed them in some cases.

If there is sawdust, or oil on the steel, the CA seems to let go once in a while. Not sure if it's an issue with heat build-up or contamination. Ellsworth uses a torch to change cutters, so I suspect it might be heat related. Make sure you've got the gap filling CA and a "close fit" that's been cleaned with mineral spirits or smiliar. That's all you can do...

Steve

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#3

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

Cyril Griesbach

>Eric,

I just made two of them today and used the straight one and it seems fine. I haven't used the angled one yet but I'll let you know if I have problems. How big did you drill the holes? The bits I used are ones I got from David and drilled 3/16 and 1/4 inch holes.

Cold should not have an adverse effect on your CA. I believe that lots of folks store unused CA in the freezer.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#4

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Eric

My guess is that you may be getting the tip hot when you use it and the CA releases. If you turn dry wood the cutter or cutting point of a tool may get really hot. If it were mine I would drill and tap. I like hard 10 - 32 cap head screws, not the stuff you buy at Home Depot. The cap head has a Allen wrench type hole so tightening and loosening is easy.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#5

Sounds like too much heat killing the CA

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#6

Re: Probably not a clean surface

john lucas

>I'll agree with Steve I think it might be oily or some other debri. I've made several of these and used to glue them all. I've never had one come out. I do use allen screws now but only to make the tip easier to remove.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#7

Re: Sounds like too much heat killing the CA

Eric Knutsen

>Right now I'm turning a piece of apple wood that is 30 days sealed. I'm thinking maybe the hole I set the tip in was a little too big giving it too much wiggle room. As far as using a set screw, is it tough to tap drill rod?

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#8

Re: Sounds like too much heat killing the CA

Cyril Griesbach

>Eric, I just finished using my angled cutter that I mentioned in a prior response and had no problems. My guess is that your glue is bad, your holes are to big/small that the glue won't hold it, or, like others have said...you got it too hot.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#9

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

Ed Karch

>I had that problem and after the third try with CA I cleaned it up and brazed it in with a mapp gas toarch.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#10

Re: Sounds like too much heat killing the CA

eliot d

>I think you've got it right this time: the time I've had problems with the tip coming out was when the fit between the tip and the drill rod wasn't so good. Ellsworth makes this little crank-type thingy that turns the square cross-section tip against a grinding wheel so that the end of the tip becomes a round tenon. If this tenon is sized just right to fit the hole in the drill rod and then glued in with good CA glue, it's not going to come out , unless you really heat it up while turning too aggressively.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#11

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

eaglesc

>CA glue is excellent for glue ups when you understand the limits of its' uses.

One this going for it is its' wicking properties in porous materials .

It has a few down sides.

1.It has a lousy shear strength.

2. working temperature is up to 160 degrees.

3.It gets 80% of its bonding strength in an hour but takes 24 hours for a full cure.

As much as I use CA(most of my blanks are glued with CA even the ones with metal in them)I would not trust it to make a cutting tool

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#12

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

eliot d

>Ed, you are so advanced! I can't stand it. Hope to see you at the MCW meetings. Who else is going to identify the weird woods?

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#13

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

Allen Neighbors

>Well, I've only read a couple of the posts, and I agree with John Lucas on this problem.

Most likely, if you used a cutting lubricant when you drilled the hole for the cutter, that's the culprit. Just blowing the oil from the hole isn't enough to get rid of it. If it were me, I would use acetone or lacquer thinner to clean the oil out, and allow it to dry (it won't take long), before applying the CA.

But, another thing could be the vibration from the cutting. CA is brittle when set. If there is any space around the cutter, it could be vibration shattering the bond. Just my thoughts.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#14

Eric, it's easy to drill and tap.

Allen Neighbors

>I use 1/4 x 29tpi Allen-type set screws in all my tools, except the ones I screwed up at first... those are larger.

I use a 13/64 drill bit to drill the hole, and a 1/4 x 20 tap, backing out often, to clear the shavings.

Now... if it's pre-hardened drill rod, I know not how to drill it. If it's not already hardened, you can drill it, easy. If you drilled the hole for the cutting bit, and haven't hardened it since, go for it.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#15

Re: Sounds like too much heat killing the CA

Eric Knutsen

>You know Eliot, I've tried to duplicate that grinding jig he showed us and I haven't been able to do it. I end up making a slight taper rather than a perfectly dowelled end. I really don't think it's the heat because it doesn't seem to stay in long enough to even heat up. Before I put another tip to the grindstone, I'll put my nose on it first and see what I can come up with. Thanks.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#16

Re: Eric, it's easy to drill and tap.

Eric Knutsen

>Allen, I haven't hardened the rod. I generally don't. Where would you recommend getting the taps to do this? The only negative thing I read about tapping the rod to secure the tip was that certain wood (high tannin?) will progressively rust out the set screw. Have you found this to be an issue?

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#17

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

Eric Knutsen

>Ed, what is the proper way to braze the tip in place?

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#18

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

Ed Karch

>Eric

just clean it up so all areas show bright metal. heat the parts and dip in flux. Join them in their final position using gravity to your advantage. (Clamps act as heat sinks and it may take more heat than you have in mapp gas.) heat the assembly and your brazing rod, when the rod starts to melt apply it to the joint and keep heating as it will probably stick and re solidify. Just keep the heat on until you see brass flowing in the joint. let it cool and scrape off the solid flux. The function of the flux is to keep the cleaned metal surfaces from oxidizing from the heat until the brass has a chance to sneak under the flux and form a bond which replaces the flux.

wear welder glasses and dont burn yourself.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#19

Re: I bought Vermon American...

Allen Neighbors

>taps at a local hardware store. And I've turned a lot of green wood, and have never had the set screws rust in. I've got some that may set for 6 months or so, and they've never been hard to remove. However, every time I finish using a tool, I give the set screw a blast of air, to get the chips out of the allen wrench hole. I learned to do this after I had to use a needle to dig the hardened dust out so I could sharpen the cutter. :)

The only problem I've ever had tapping for set screws was drilling through just one side of a hole in a 3/8" rod. The hole was for inserting a 1/8" cutter, and I drilled and tapped it for a 1/4" set screw. The small hole I was tapping into wasn't deep enough for the tap to reach the widest part of the cutting threads. I screwed the set screw in, and couldn't get it back out. I ended up cutting the end off, and starting over. I drilled the set screw hole all the way through the 3/8 rod, so the screw would screw in like it was supposed to, against the cutter.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#20

A cheap set of taps and dies...

Allen Neighbors

>can be bought at any flea market, or Harbor Freight, for about 20 bucks, and they'll work fine for a while... that's what I started with. Now, when I wear one out, or break it, I replace it with the Vermont American. I've used my 1/4x20 sized tap enough that I've had to replace it 3 or 4 times.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#21

Re: A cheap set of taps and dies...

Eric Knutsen

>Allen, thank you for the info. Much appreciated!

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#22

Re: Eric, it's easy to drill and tap.

Texian

>Oops, it's a typo (9 is nest to 0). Had me going for a moment there.

Have used several sizes of set screws in home made tools. Some are 15-20 years old with original set screws and tapped holes. A couple of my favorites have been loosened and retightened at least hundreds of times to remove, sharpen, reinstall the tool bits with no observable degradation. For me the use of a single allen wrench is just too simple and too fast to ever consider having to use a torch to melt the glue, be sure the tool bit and holder are cool enough, and then glue it back together.

Re: CA glue problem(Tool making)

#23

Re: Eric, it's easy to drill and tap.

john lucas

>When I use set screws in my boring bars I use a fine thread so there are more threads ingaged. I might use 1/4X28 instead of 1/4x20.