Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

Posts

Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#1

Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

MWWoodWorks

>Has anyone used the Dakota burl pen blank yet? The material made from sunflower seeds. If so, have you had any problems with it? I turned a cigar pen using it and sold the pen very quickly however, lass than a month later, the customer called me back and said that it was falling apart. He loves the pen and would like another one just like it. I am afraid that if I turn him another one with the same pen blank, it will in fact be JUST LIKE the first one and fall apart? I thought maybe he had just dropped it a few times or something? After inspecting the pen, it really is just crumbling apart?! As expensive as they are, you woul dthink that it wouldn't do that? It is sold as a pen blank, again you would think that it would have been tested as a pen before marketing as such? Do you think I just got a bad blank?

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#2

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

Tommy Holmes

>I've turned a few pens Dakota burl and have had some problems with pieces chipping out as I turned them. I have started keeping them soaked with CA glue and putting a CA finish on them. I've had a couple of customers that have had them a year or more and they are still solid and look good.

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#3

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

Cyril Griesbach

>I've turned a few of these Dakota Burl pens and I'm not happy to hear of them falling apart. I did not use any CA on them except to repair some of the inevitable chip out...which is easy to fix with sanding dust and CA.

Could it be that you just happened to get a bad blank?

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#4

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

Rick Davenport

>I turned 3 different dakota burl blanks and blew up all three.

I don't plan to try any more.

R

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#5

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

MWWoodWorks

>I am hoping that it was just a bad blank?! I blew one up myself, luckily, I was turning a miniature vase at the time instead of a pen so I was still able to use a good majority of the blank!I love the look of the dakota burl blanks but I too am giving up on them as they are too fragile and pricey for me. It wouldn't be so bad if they were a bit cheaper. I just recently ordered one of the rattlesnake blanks...

I let it sit around for some time. (Yes, I was scared to turn it! LOL) At $25 a pop I wanted to make sure I was in the right frame of mind before I started spinnin' it! To my dismay, I did not see that where the skin overlaps on the brass tube it sits up much higher than the rest and sure enough I took it down too much. Just by a hair but enough that I could not sell it! The $25 blank matched to the Platinum Cigar pen kit turned out to be an expensive lesson learned! It will be a while before I order another one of those although it was still a beautiful pen if you didn't look at the flaw! LOL

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#6

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

Jerry Whitaker

>I have made one Comfort Pen using Dakota Burl. I started out using my gouge and had a lot of chip-out so I changed to the skew and that solved the problem. I did finish it with 4 coats of CA glue. However, I still have not sold it. I think the problem is that I display it with pens that are more appealing. Our club has two tables in an upcoming woodcarvers show and I plan on putting the Dakota Burl pen for sale there with a few other pens that I really need to get rid of and see what happens.

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#7

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

robo hippy

>I bought a couple of sheets of it from the manufacturer (I do flat work also) and made a couple of table tops out of it. I also glued several pieces together and turned and cored some bowls out of it. It does yield powder instead of shavings, it leaves a coarse surface that needs to be filled, but other than that, no problems. I used Deftoil (danish oil with poly in it). The company (Environ Biocomposites and/or Phenex in Mankato, MN) has some other particle board products out of grass/hay, and paper (looks like granite). The paper stuff would leave shavings when turned. The glue is a soy based resin with no formaldehyde in it. I had to order 5 sheets, and the price including shipping worked out to about $5 per foot. It cost more to ship it than it did to buy it.

robo hippy

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#8

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

Dick Coers------WebKitFormBoundaryqFOmq51H3saAc+aC

>I would wager that you may have cracked it when drilling. If I remember correctly, the core is mainly wheat straw and then they lay on the layers of seed hulls. That wheat straw is the weak section and the reason that people have blow outs when turning. Well besides the seed hulls chipping out. I agree with the others, keep the CA handy.

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

#9

Re: Material for pen turning - Dakota burl

eaglesc

>You would be better off casting them yourself than paying the ridiculous prices charged for a novelty item.

Anything can be cast in resin,the problem is resin does not impregnate the material just the voids between the pieces.

I have made my own blanks out of sisal rope,denim, and various other materials using CA.

Resin is normally too viscous and doesn't soak into the material it encapsulates it.

I would definitely seal with CA as I turned it and finish it with CA.