Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Too much horsepower?

Posts

Too much horsepower?

#1

Too much horsepower?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>I am currently using a Jet mini-lathe. My City just cut down a large number of London Plane trees and I scored a truck load. I understand my Jet mini does not really have enough power for one of those wonderful coring devices. Got me to wondering, is there such a thing as too much horsepower in a lathe? My reading indicates that some models can be had with an upgrade to, say, a five (5) horse motor. Is that just asking for trouble? My tablesaw has three (3) horse and when I bought it, was available in 5 horse motor, but, only in three phase. So, why not a five horse for a lathe?

Re: Too much horsepower?

#2

Re: Too much horsepower?

E.T.

>My friend built a Nichols style lathe and installed a 5 hp motor. He was no expert lathe designer or mechanical enginer. He just heard that motors loose power when they run at lower speeds and he wanted lots of power. I think 5 hp is way too much, but he hasn't killed himself yet and the price of a 3 and 5 hp was almost the same. ET

Re: Too much horsepower?

#3

Re: Too much horsepower?

Fog Tanner

>Mike Mahoney had Vicmarc put a 5hp motor in a VL300 for him. Mike does a lot of coring and doesn't want the lathe to pull down any. I am sure there are other's out there with five or more on them. There have been some with car engines and steam engines on them, and some powered by a tractor. All of which had more than five horsepower.

There is an old saying in hot rodding, "If one's good, two is better"...

Its not so much the horsepower, but what you do with it. If you spin anything too fast it can be dangerous. A box blank pulled from a min-lathe is just as lethal as one pulled from a 5hp lathe. Both require caution and common sense to use safely.

Re: Too much horsepower?

#4

Re: Too much horsepower?

Allen Neighbors

>My thoughts, when I read your post, immediately turned to a 12 foot skiff with an inboard 455 Olds engine. :)

Or... a Piper Cub with a Rolls Royce Jet engine mounted on it. :)

Just my thoughts....

I core bowls up to 16 inches with a 2 hp motor on my Oneway. I would thing 5 hp on a Jet Mini would be overkill, to the max. But. It doesn't depend on what I think. It depends on what you want. Get what you want... (and then be careful). :)

Re: Too much horsepower?

#5

Are We Still Talking About Mini Lathes?

Barry Turner

>Are we still talking about Jet Mini Lathes here?

Oneway routinely puts 3 and 5 HP on their 2436's, but me thinks 5 HP, or even 3 HP might be a bit much for a Jet Mini.

If, as I suspect, you are talking about larger lathes, I think the answer is that you can reach the point of diminishing returns. I'm not an engineer, but once you pass about 3 HP, other factors come into play. You can add more HP, but is it usable. Getting all that power to the lathe becomes a problem. A single V-belt or multi-groovebelt no longer is sufficient. So, then what? Multiple belts? A drive shaft? I hope you see where I'm going with this.

Re: Too much horsepower?

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Are We Still Talking About Mini Lathes?

Keith Tompkins

>Not a bad idea....a 5 hp motor would also serve as very stable base for the lathe. LOL.

Seriously, a 5 hp motor spinning at 1750 rpm is no more dangerous than a 1/4 hp motor spinning at the same speed...it's not like the bigger motor will spin uncontrollably. It's the dumb things a turner might do that will cause the trouble...a catch on a small motor will just stall the motor. A catch with a big motor may give you a broken arm...or worse.

Re: Too much horsepower?

#7

Re: Too much horsepower?

robo hippy

>Drive shaft? Transmission? Variable speed? More power? Holy 'Tim the Tool Man Taylor' Batman, I want one!!!!!!

robo hippy

Re: Too much horsepower?

#8

This should answer your question. :) *LINK*

john lucas

>I know this has been around but it's still fun to watch.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOGJLoVi-Bg

Re: Too much horsepower?

#9

Re: Too much horsepower?

Fog Tanner

>Allen,

I hadn't even thought about that until you mentioned it. It was actually a 13 foot outboard tunnel hull with more horsepower than the olds. Was good for 140mph on water....talk about a blast. 2 sqaure inches and part of the prop was all that was in the water at speed. Those were the only times I wore a skid lid driving a boat.

Talk about a rush, would be like putting a faceplate on the crankshaft of a blown 426 fuel hemi and turning a bowl at speed - no bogging down there for sure.....

Re: Too much horsepower?

#10

Re: Are We Still Talking About Mini Lathes?

Fog Tanner

>If you have ever been to or seen a drag race where they are running the fuel cars you would see the belts. The fuel cars,(Top Fuel, AA/Fuel, and Funny) all run a blower. The first ones were GMC

6-71's off of two cycle diesel engines. To drive them back then they used a 2" wide Gilmer toothed belt. The pulleys on the crank and blower were toothed as well. With a blower taking upwards of 1,100 horsepower to drive it, they are up to a 3" or 4" belt today.

When I first worked in a machine shop the engine lathe I ran had a 2 hp motor in it. The drive was a 2" toothed Gilmer belt, and it ran all day long cutting steel. No slippage in that setup, so if you wanted to loosen the belt in case of a catch, this isn't the belt/pulley setup for you. But, if you want to hook up a 327 Chevy small block - no problem....

Re: Too much horsepower?

#11

Another funny one, chainsaw motorcycle  *LINK*

john lucas

>


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDWqJe1dCgY&feature=related

Re: Too much horsepower?

#12

Steven Antonucci

Too much HP? Nope, too little wood...

steve antonucci

>If you live out in the Western US, you've seen some trees that can justify all the HP you can get your hands on...

Most of us would probably benefit from another 1 HP every once in a while...

Steven

Re: Too much horsepower?

#13

That's what I want, a 327 Chevy small block!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Fuel injected of course. Is it available with a blower for those really large pieces?

Re: Too much horsepower?

#14

Steven Antonucci

I seem to recall seeing a VW powered lathe

steve antonucci

>I can't find it (honestly, haven't looked that hard...), but I remember seeing someone that had a gasoline powered VW engine hooked up to a gearbox to turn some big items. I was in Hawaii and not really a turner at the time, so I forget his name. The pieces were 3-4' tall and they were lag bolted on the axles.

When your lathe has an ignition switch, you might be looking at too much power :-)

Steven

Re: Too much horsepower?

#15

Too much horsepower.

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>Hey group, thanks for the input. I think my question has been answered in the sense that, when I do buy my new lathe, I should spring for the greater horsepower offered by the manufacturer and, always keep in mind speed and safety.

My issue was all the wood that ends up on the floor because I don't have the ability with the mini or, the horsepower to core. My good frineds in the city parks and public works departments keep me in mind whenever they cut down a tree and, too much goes to waste.

I bought the mini as an inexpensive way to find out if I even liked turning as I mostly do flat work. Even have had some commissions thrown my way and was thinking this was a great way to subsidize my hobby in retirement. Now, I just need a bigger lathe to do what I want.

Re: Too much horsepower?

#16

Re: That's what I want, a 327 Chevy small block!

Fog Tanner

>You can definately put a blower on one. But for the normal large piece, unblown will work fine as you can get around 500-600 horsepower with a little work. The small block normally produces it power in the upper rpm range - 5,000-8,000 depending on the cam. Since that is a little too much rpm for bowl turning, you can reduce that which ups the spndle HP even more. You could easily get 800-900 available spindle horsepower, after the mechanical loss. This should be enough for most any bowl you are likely to turn.

I think the best power for a wood lathe is a steam engine. They have great amounts of torque at low rpm and while you are turning you are creating the fuel supply. There is a compnay that sells castings for small steam engines. If my brother-in-law, who is a machinst, ever gets to feeling good again (cancer) I plan on getting a set. The ones I am looking at produce enough horsepower to run a mini. Would sure beat a pole lathe, and be a lot of fun at club picnics.

Re: Too much horsepower?

#17

Re: Too much horsepower.

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Doug,

Most of us went through the same path. Get now the bigger you can afford. I am saving my sous for a Powermatic 3520.

Jorge