Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Cocobolo and ebony box

Posts

Cocobolo and ebony box

#1

Cocobolo and ebony box

JohnKJordan in East TN

>This box is about 4.6" high by 3" in diameter, made from cocobolo with an ebony insert in the top. Experimenting with shapes.

JKJ


img

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#2

WOW! That really is nice, John.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

Mike Stafford

>John, it looks as if you don't need any instruction on turning boxes. That is a sweet looking piece of work. You polished that baby up to a "I can see myself in it" shine. Nice work!

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#4

Re: My first impression is that....

Jamie Donaldson

>..the top is too large in proportion to the bottom. The handle area is about the same diameter as the base, and the rule of thirds is a good guide for placing height of the separation cut.

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#5

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

Allen Neighbors

>That's pretty. I love Cocobolo, and you've done it justice. I also like the shape of this one. It sort of reminds me of those little Russian Dolls that all fit inside one another... :)

Nice work on the finish, too, John.

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#6

You're right.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I didn't look at it closely enough and just assumed that the separation line was near the top at the little step in the shoulder. That seems to be the natural place for the lid in a shape like that.

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#7

I don't see it as a flaw.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>To me, I would reach for that box if it was in a groups of turnings. I don't know, it just looks like something I wouldn't mind having. The cut for the lid looks "right" where it is in regards to that prominent grain feature. My .02 again...:-)

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#8

Denis Putland

Re: My first impression is that....

Denis Putland

>this was a good time to break that constrictive rule of 2/3 rths.

Very pretty box.

Denis

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#9

thanks, and a word about The Rules

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Thanks for all the comments! Working on this piece was good clean fun and I plan on trying a few more with similar design. (all of cocobolo) The finish is Mylands friction polish, applied by hand off the lathe.

Of all the boxes I've made, this particular one has had more favorable response from people who have held and opened it. (Of course, by the critical eye that may mean all the others really stunk!:)

I do admit I laughed out loud when I saw the message about the proportions and such, i.e., The Rules. A woodturner frined and I had a bet as to how long it would take before someone pointed out the ways this box didn't follow The Rules. I won, but not by much!

My take on The Rules: When I became aware there was such a thing as The Rules as a beginning turner, I decided to consciously avoid even learning them. I'm sure they are useful, at least as starting points, but if all woodturners followed The Rules every time, creatitivity would be surpressed and some new things would never be created.

Instead of even knowing The Rules, I prefer to experiment with design and form, usually by starting with a sketch, refine while turning, and then decide if I like the result. If not, few will ever see it!

BTW, the inside is egg shaped. The break is at the widest point for ease of access to the contents.

JKJ

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#10

My apologies...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I should have noticed that you didn't ask for comments or critiques.

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#11

Re: Come on John, you know there have ......

Jamie Donaldson

>... to be rules to learn, or how else could we have ART majors?! My policy is that you should know the rules before you are allowed to break them, and that's called creativity. There is a logical basis for such standards, and in this particular case the mass of the top makes the box proportions appear top heavy. It may be a more practical size for gripping, but offers less internal space for storage- it's all about the trade-offs, but you did a swell job with the finishing! ;-)))

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#12

yikes, back up

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>I should have noticed that you didn't

>ask for comments or critiques.

Don't get me wrong! (internet messages don't project attitude well)

I LOVE reading critiques and comments. I didn't mean to sound like I was complaining about the comments, it just struck me as funny that my friend and I anticipated the response. - we knew the design on this one was a bit unconventional. (And I DID win the bet!) Sorry if I came across as too defensive about the comments: I plead the late hour, too many drugs, foot-in-mouth disease, the phase of the moon, mental deterioration, just in from two hours out in the cold...

I personally think anything anyone posts publicly opens their work to comments and criticism. Yikes, to avoid the critics, keep the pictures off the forums!

I probably shouldn't be so obstinant and close-minded about "The Rules", but I was broadsided when I turned my second bowl (my first "real" bowl", below) - the first expert turner I showed it to dismissed it and me with "the base is too big, the rules say it should be...". Sure, the foot is probably too big, but since then I noticed how almost everything that guy did, while technically excellent, looked about the same - just different sizes and different woods!

I also remember seeing work by a famous turner (not mentioning any names) that I thought was spectacular until I saw the 5th and 25th version of the same forumula. Ack! But he makes the big money.

I'm having a lot of fun bumbling around, perhaps accidentally discovering my own rules. Fortunately, I have no pressure to make anything I hope someone will pay money for. I just hope I don't look back someday at everything I've done and thing, "hmm, all those look kinda the same, and they're all boring."!

I'm personally happy with most of the way this one came out except for the base - after looking at it I thought it should be bigger and my friend thought it should be smaller. I want to try a few more with a similar curved shape, but with some variation in the base and top. I want to try turning an egg-shaped box from dogwood that just barely fits into this one and see how that looks. If it's thin and light enough, it might be a fun surprise when opening. The egg could even be pierced and carved, but I haven't tried that yet. I have no idea how you'd grip an egg-shaped box to open it, though.

>...how else could we have ART majors?!

Ha, let's not get started on that one!

JKJ


img

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#13

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

Mark Williamson

>I think this is a true representaion of unique art! If it broke a few peoples rules here or there who cares?! Some of the most facinating art that I have seen has been mostly because of it's unique qualities! If we didn't test our boundaries, we wouldn't grow. The lines are pleasing and have a wonderful roll to them. The whole piece flows very well. One curve compliments the next. I believe that it will bring much happiness to whomever is lucky enough to have it through its many years to come!

Mark

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#14

Re: Come on John, you know there have ......

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I think almost anyone who teaches or has taught feels that the best way to learn is to follow "the rules" and then find ways of deviating from them and still achieving a good or better result. In our case some of us are more sensitive to proportion than others. This is not necessarily bad. All beginners should try and follow the "rules" of proportion when they are learning.

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#15

learned proportions

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>All beginners should try and follow the

>"rules" of proportion when they are learning.

I think that is good advice.

My biggest concern is that by learning a set of "accepted" proportions, a person might learn to like those proportions, slowly convince theirself that those proportions are somehow right or better, and never stretch to experiment with significant deviation. (I suspect some personalities are be more susceptable to this type of influlence than others.)

This type of learned preference is obvious in many areas: consider how many people in certain circles believe country music is better than classical is better than rock is better than jazz is better than...

I think one positive path would be to experience a series of teachers, each with a passion for different preferences.

Much of what I find compelling when I see a turning I really like is in how it is creatively unique in some way, perhaps in form, surface treatment, proportion, material, figure, size, complexity, and so on. For example, considering proportion alone, although the basic salad bowl form is well proportioned I rarely see one and say "wow, look at that".

JKJ

Re: Cocobolo and ebony box

#16

Re: learned proportions

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I think ultimately it depends upon the personality of the person as well as the innate ability and creativity. I seriously doubt that learning and having an appreciation for the classical forms (those on which the "rules" are based) will prevent someone who is truly creative and innovative from developing those gifts.

You use music as an example which took me back to my college days at Western Carolina up in the mountains of North Carolina. Country music was something I had never been exposed to. Back in 1964 that was all you could get on the radio up in Cullowhee. I was horrified at the twang and corny lyrics. Once I unbent my stiff neck I learned to appreciate and enjoy Country music as well as Bluegrass.

Creativity is a fascinating thing. I am not a particularly originally creative person. I do benefit from exposing myself to innovative ideas of others which sometimes gives me the kick start I need to think of how one idea can be changed to produce something else. I still really appreciate a beautifully executed salad bowl though. :-)