Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Posts

chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#1

chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Ilya Zavorin

>Hi. This message may be a bit off-topic in this forum, but not completely. I have a 1.5hp Paulan electric chainsaw which I have used a lot to prepare bowl blanks. Yesterday I was cutting a blank and felt that it was time for sharpening. And then all of a sudden bluish smoke started coming out of the motor compartment and the saw lost power, although it did not stop completely. It looked like burning oil. I oil my chain manually by pressing a button every 15 secs or so while cutting.

So what do you think happened? Did I somehow flood the motor with oil, or did I simply burn my motor? How hard would it be to fix it myself? DO you think it is cheaper to just buy a new saw? Thanks.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#2

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...and felt that it was time for sharpening.

Were you applying a lot of force and working the engine hard to overcome the dull chain at the time? The fact that it lost power worries me.

If you have one nearby, a repair shop may be able to evaluate the problem with a quick look which may be better than long-distance guesses.

JKJ

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#3

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Ilya Zavorin

>> Were you applying a lot of force and working the engine hard to overcome the dull chain at the time? The fact that it lost power worries me.

I guess I was although it was certainly not the first time I applied this much force.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#4

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Ruth

>Not meaning to be rude: Did you check you still had gas? Did you check you still had oil. When did you last do a tune up and change your spark plug? I would go for the obvious first.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#5

Buy a real chain saw

Cyril Griesbach

>

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#6

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Bill Howatt

>There was no gas, there was some bar oil, the plug has never been changed but I don't think it's the problem since it still fits snugly into the receptacle - its an electric saw!!!! :)

Bill

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#7

(Ruth, Its electric)

Barry Irby

>

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#8

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Ruth gas is pretty hard to put in and electric chainsaw. ;)

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#9

Just teasing, We love ya Ruth

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#10

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Blow the motor out then try it one more time, I wouldn't even try to repair the motor and the cost would be close to a new one.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#11

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Barry Irby

>I have a Sears Electric Chainsaw. I went through several Remington saws from Lowes. Both crapped out because they had cheap plastic gears. Bought an equally crappy looking one from Sears because they offered a no questions asked extra year on the guarantee for $12. Wouldn't you know it, it looks like it will last forever. If it did any better it would qualify as a Real tool. My point is that I really like it and it cost less than a hundred bucks even with the guarantee. So check with Sears to see if they still have them and the guarantee, before you pay to fix yours. My plan was to beat it to death and let Sears pick up the slack. I use it to prepare bowl blanks often. The oil just drools out and I don't like it in the shop, so I don't even bother to oil it.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#12

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Ilya Zavorin

>Thanks. Which model is it and what size bar?

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#13

Blue smoke => time for a new saw

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I had a Remington electric for a while. After a year it did the blue smoke number. I did a post-mortem and everything on the saw was shot -- the brushes were gone, the bearings were almost dead and had melted the plastic housing around them, and the gears were almost gone.

I replaced it with a Makita electric that I got through Amazon. (I didn't have time to wait for the local Stihl dealer to order one for me.) I've been really impressed with the Makita. It cost twice as much as the home center saws and it is about 10 times better.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#14

Your Choice!

Barry Turner

>First of all, I would fill the gas tank with fresh oil/gas and see if the saw would start and run after it got cooled off. Be sure to fill up the chain oil resevoir, too. If the saw is still giving problems, have the saw checked out by a repair shop. Poulan saws are so inexpensive, I'd just buy new instead of investing more than $25 on a repair.

Most Poulan consumer-grade saws are not made for heavy use. Cutting and roughing bowl blanks is pretty tough on a saw. You can do one of two things. You can keep buying cheap saws (Poulan, McCulloch, etc.) and replacing them on a frequent and regular basis. Or, you can spend $300 to $500 on a quality saw (Stihl, Husqvarna, etc) that will probably serve your needs for years to come. When you have a saw that is actually capable of the work you ask it to do, you don't overload it and repairs are much less frequent. Your choice.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#15

Re: BARRY!! It's ELECTRIC!!!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#16

Sears 16 and 18 electric on sale for 99$

Atwerz

>but they aren't worth a damn. Been thru 4 of them in 11 months. sears replaces. They quit selling the 16 so this time they gave me an 18. These China saws not capable of hard work. The salesman told me they got back most of the 16 they sold.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#17

LOL!

Carole Valentine

>Had your coffee yet, Ruth? :))

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#18

Thanks for the chuckle this morning!

Carole Valentine

>Barry, are you visiting Ruth? LOL

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#19

Re: The problem is obvious!

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>The problem is obvious! If you put all that gas and oil in there, then plug it in, It's gotta SMOKE!

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#20

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

Barry Irby

>Mine is a Model 358.341160 Craftsman 16" chainsaw. Says 3.5 Peak HP on the end. Its two or three years old and gets very sporadic use. None for a while and then beat it to death for a day or two. I really bought it as a disposable piece of junk, expecting Sears to have to replace it several times before the Warranty ran out. I must have gotten the the only good one they made.

As I mentioned, I almost never oil it, but I usually cut green wood, so I delude myself into believing the wet wood keeps the chain cool.

In spite of my profound dislike of most things Craftsman and my intention of having them replace this thing over and over, I have to admit it has done exactly what it should have and I am begrudgingly impressed. I feel like the guy who got the one truly excellent hamburger McDonald's made.

If I had a choice, I would rather have a Makita for twice the money, but then I would feel obliged to take better care of it. And a Stihl was about twice that. A wonderful tool, but way out of my price range when a disposable toy will do tee job as well as this one has.

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#21

Tacky....... :)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: chainsaw: repair or buy new?

#22

Oops! Wrong Ruth!

Carole Valentine

>I thought that post was by Ruth Niles.