Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Respirators

Posts

Respirators

#1

Respirators

Randy G

>Okay, so I've searched the archives, looked around and am still confused as to what to get. There's full mask battery powered respirators that people love and hate. There's the 3m full masks that use cartridges and some people appear to prefer, and then theres the 1/2 mask ones that I'm guessing you wear under your face mask you have. So instead of asking what you prefer, brand etc... I'd like to know why you prefer the different systems. Powered, Non-Powered, 1/2 mask or something I've yet to read about?

And I guess the other question is, you always hear people mention to wear them but do you wear them while your turning big stuff, little stuff, only when turning Dry wood, or just when sanding/finishing?

Thanks

Re: Respirators

#2

Re: Respirators

Stuart Johnson

>I'm in the 3M half face respirator worn under my face mask. I don't wear it while turning but always do when sanding. I like it because it is the only one I've tried that I can wear and my glasses don't fog up.

One problem I create myself and probably would with any respirator is I wear it when I'm sanding and take it off when done. This means I am breathing in the fine stuff that is still hanging in the air.

Re: Respirators

#3

Re: Respirators

phil in NJ

>I have and like the 3M airstream full facemask...

- keeps glasses from fogging up, nice cool stream of air

- impact resistance better than standard face-shields

- visor flips up

- not too heavy on your head, and battery pack belt isn't too big or heavy

- works well enough that I can turn and sand cocobolo and other exotics without additional dust collection and not be affected at all

The battery in mine seems to last for a 3 or so hours of constant use. So I do have to remember to charge it after each use.

Re: Respirators

#4

Martin Harris

Re: Respirators

Martin Harris

>I have been using a North 7700 half-face mask with North 7580-P100 particulate filters for about 6 weeks. Glasses don't fog and it is comfortable and easy to put on and take off. It works extremely well even though I have a full beard. I do't do shellacing, etc. so can only speak to dust.

I use it only for sanding or roughing down bark. Haven't turned any dry wood, but from what little I know I would probably use it for that also. (I'm very allergy prone :-( )

Re: Respirators

#5

Re: Respirators

Barry Irby

>I have the North 7700 half mask also. It wears well with my glasses and face shield. I wear it when doing anything dusty. Sanding, on and off the lathe. Doesn't seem to help or be necessary when turning green wood. I have dust collection on most of my tools except the lathe, but there is still some fine dust hanging in the air. Lately, I have begun to be suspicious of lacquer from spray cans (probably the propellant). I am wearing the combination filters that are both for particles and activated charcoal for the fumes. I really like those and can not even smell the lacquer through them. Really helps.

Re: Respirators

#6

Re: Respirators

Fog Tanner

>I have both the Powervisor and 3M Airstream. The Powervisor is the same as the Trend unit. I have take a direct hit (fairly hard one) on the face shield of the Powervisor with no brakage - of either the face shield or my nose. So I will say it is good from that stand point.

My preference is the Airstream. The visor is better than the Powervisor and I can flip it up when needed. The helmet protects your skull in the case of the wood missing your visor a little high. Raffan received 13 stitchs in is head from a piece that came loose in a demo, one of the few times he does not wear his Airstream.

The filtration is much better than the Powervisor, it will go to the submicron level. I am allergic to Cedar and was recently turning some Aromatic Cedar. I could tell that the wood was red, but could not smell it until I opened the visor. With my sinus and allergy problems this unit is a real must.

I wear glasses and they do not fog up like the half face units I have tried. If you have facial hair, there are no sealing problems either. I use a half face respirator when painting, and when I hada beard I always had problems with sealing.

It is better balanced than the Powervisor or Trend. The fan unit is in the back and the battery hangs on a belt. The front to back balance is very good and after a short period of time you don't even notice it. Then after using it for a few times, it is more comfortable to wear than a regualr face shield. In the summer it is espeically more comfortable as it blows air across your face, and in Texas any breeze is welcome in July-September..actaully anytime, but those are the months that concrete starts to melt here.

The battery on mine will last 10-12 hours before recharning. I bought the "Smartcharger" which will only charge the battery to what it needs. If the battery has only been used for 30 minutes, it will charge only enough to bring it back up and then go to trickel mode. You can leave it on trickle for a month, so it is always ready to go when you need it.

I think enough of it, that when I took a class with Raffan this past summer in Provo I drove from Texas (1600 miles one way) just so I could take my Airstream. We had a solid 5 days of making dust and I did not have any sinus problems from it. Normally I would have made it one day and sinus headaches the rest of the time from the dust. Anytime I am turning I wear the Airstream, regardless of wood condition. I have a cyclone dust collector, which is also running when I turn, and can see the stream of dust comming off the tool. So you are generating dust all the time, not just when you are sanding.

Re: Respirators

#7

Re: Respirators

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>North 7700 with dust filter: effective, comfortable, fits under face protection, inexpensive, no batteries. I have been using one since 1985 when I started my sawmill business. I used it for flat work, cutting flooring, and now turning.

Re: Respirators

#8

Re: Respirators

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Randy,

I use the Trend, a 3M full face, a 3M half-face, and another half-face respirator from Home Depot.

I like the Trend in the summer for the air movement. When sanding I use the 3M half-face most of the time - it is the most comfortable of all the masks and quick to don and remove. (I like it better than the one from Home Depot) I don't use it while turning unless I'm making dust on walnut endgrain with a scraper. I rarely use the 3M full-face at the lathe. I use an industrial face shield when turning something that might be painful to my face if propelled. Unlike the 3M full-face, it can be flipped up out of the way. The half-face respirators work well under the face shield.

The worst I've ever used were the paper dust masks - hot, irritating rubber bands, fog glasses, restrict breathing.

BTW, I occasionally use the 3M full-face around the farm. The most interesting time was when I came home one day and the woods down over the hill were on fire. I jumped on my tractor and went down the hill to cut a fire break on my property boundary. At one point the smoke was thick and very irritating to the eyes until I popped on the full-face respirator.

JKJ

Re: Respirators

#9

Re: Respirators

RPE

>I use the 3M full face unpowered mask. I wear glasses and have no problems. It totally protects my face. I don't have to charge anything. I don't have to fool with batteries wearing out. New cartridges are at Lowes. I've used mine for 3 or 4 years and havent changed them yet. New filters cost $25. It has organic vapor and 95 particulate filtration. I can use any finish and not even smell it. I have been hit in the head with no damage to me or the mask. I cut out my own tear-offs out of document protectors and protect the face shield. The mask cost about $110 with filters. Look around on the web and you will find them.

Remove the 1 in my email address if you want more info.

Re: Respirators

#10

Re: Respirators

Chris LaPine

>I use the Trend all the time when turning and especially when sanding. I am very satisfied with the unit.

Chris

Re: Respirators

#11

Re: Respirators

Mike Brazeau

>I am surprised no one has mentioned the Triton. It is not perfect but for $199 I feel it gives excellent value. Includes full face protection and a hard hat as well. I have had one for three years. Triton recently replaced battery pack for me for cost of freight after one of the Ni-Cads had shorted out. I would say though in summer heat, it is barely adequate for air flow and not something I would want to wear all the time.

Re: Respirators

#12

Re: Respirators

Randy G

>I appreciate all the feedback and responses. I'm kind of gathering that the 1/2 masks will do for starting out and determining if I need something more. After that the Trend/Triton route seems to be the way to go. I checked into the Airstream and unless I'm not searching right, it's a little to far out of my budget to consider at this point. Thank you again everyone for the replies.

Re: Respirators

#13

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Respirators

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>I use the Trend Airshield ALL the time I am working in the shop.

It does tend to get a little heavy after several hours of usage but I would prefer a stiff neck to a smashed face. It happened once and I hope it never happens again!

Regards, Peter

Re: Respirators

#14

Re: Respirators

Dale Johnson

>i use a 3m breatheasy system. i have had a beard for 30 years and the half masks won't seal properly. i love this system, hard hat, impact rated face shield, filters and motor ride on your lower back and the batteries run 10+ hours. the moving air feels good when it is hot. the down side is that fully decked out the package will run you around $1,000. my former employer provided them and when i was declared surplus i was told to take my all my ppe with when i left. they didn't consider it cost effective to sanitize it for re-issue

i wear this wherever i am generating dust.

dale