Coring Systems
Thomas Cline
>Interested in coring multiple bowls from one blank. Which tools and setups are the best for large bowls. Thanks Tom
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Coring Systems
Thomas Cline
>Interested in coring multiple bowls from one blank. Which tools and setups are the best for large bowls. Thanks Tom
Re: Coring Systems
Allen Neighbors
>Get ready for as many answers as there are coring systems on the market.
I use the McNaughton system, and am perfectly satisfied with it. You can adjust your arc to make different shaped blanks with this system. On some of the other systems, your bowl form is decided for you.
HTH
Re: Coring Systems
Brodie Brickey
>I have and am happy with the McNaughton. If you get it, and you are on a lathe with a 20" swing or larger you'll need the longer post. The key to the McNaughton is that the cutter tip needs to on the horizontal center level of the bowl, too high, too low and you are screwed.
I've seen some of the other coring tools demonstrated, I'd say others are easier to use, but they don't offer as many different shapes to core.
For 20" bowls you'll want the standard set as well as the large set to allow you to reach deep into a large blank.
Regards,
Brodie Brickey
Re: Coring Systems
Dick Hines
>I agree with Allen and Brodie.
Re: Coring Systems
Donna Banfield
>O.K., Tom, get ready for the many responses.
I've had the McNaughton system, and used it on a Oneway 2436 3hp. Like Allen and others have said, the McNaughton is versatile, in that it allows you to choose the shape of the bowl that you core. A friend purchased the Oneway coring system, and I used -- once -- and decided to sell my McNaughton and purchased the Oneway Coring system. For complete simplicity and ease of use, the Oneway system is superior, in my opinion. It is not cheap, however. For the cost of the base and only one knife (out of four available), you can purchase all the McNaughton knifes. But between the two that I used, I liked the Oneway much better.
If you have the option, try to use the coring systems that you are considering before you buy. If you belong to a turning club, or live near where one of them meets, you might contact members who have coring systems, who can give you some hands on experience. Then, the decision you make is one based on your own personal opinion, and not the varied opinions of everyone who might post a response here.
Good luck.
Re: Coring Systems
Bob Macgregor
>I don't want to hijack Tom's thread, but I have a question about mounting a core. What is the best way to do this? Without coring, I can mount a blank using a screw or faceplate, then turn a tenon on the bottom before flipping it to hollow the inside. This will still work for the first core, but not for subsequent ones. Do you use cole jaws or a longworth (or what?) to get a tenon turned on these cores?
Thanks,
BOB
Re: Coring Systems
adrien Coblentz------WebKitFormBoundaryB5riMd+7AYk
>Don't remember who first suggested it on this board, but using the just cored bowl as a chuck, reverse the core, use tail stock to hold it in place and turn a foot on the core.
Re: Coring Systems
Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner
>Before you core out the center turn a tenon on it, one on each side of the blank. Once it is out you can remount the cored out piece by the tenon and do whatever you like to the bottom of it for normal bottom mounting.
Good turning and be safe
Bill in CG, AZ.
Re: Coring Systems
joaz
>What ever system you use be aware that using any product on dry wood is a pain in the butt. Every one that I have tried or seen demo is always on wet wood. Dry wood gets hot and cracks.
Re: Coring Systems *LINK*
TomCollins
>I have absolutely no experience with coring bowls but noticed the Woodcut Bowl Saver is on sale starting at $184 at this link.
I have no financial or other interest in this company. just came across them while surfing
TomCollins
Craft Supplies USA
Re: Coring Systems
robo hippy
>I have all 3 systems (no,I don't have a tool buying problem). I also demoed them in Portland last summer. I prefer the McNaughotn. It is the fastest to core with, and much more versatile than the other systems. You can core plates, regular bowls, and deep bowl bowls.The problem with it is that there is a learning curve. Since it isn't on a fixed pivoting tool rest, you have to guide and aim it. This is easier if you have the laser pointer that McNaughton makes.
With the Oneway, the down side is that you have to turn off the lathe to advance the support finger under the blade. On a big 18 inch diameter bowl, this can be 4 or 5 times. Also, you have to mount a separate plate for the assembly to go into. This system is the most difficult to sharpen. You have to remove the tip, and then hold it up to the grinder. They do provide a jig now with templates for getting the proper angles. It is precdictable and easy to use. There is some adjustment you can make, sliding the plate to either side to change the angle the blade comes in at, but at the far right or left, you can get some binding because the finger and blade height is 3 inches or so, and it will only fit into a certain limited radius. It is also the most expensive of the 3 systems out there.
The Woodcut coring system is nice and small. The big blade is a 5 inch radius. You also need to attach the tailstock to the tool rest for stability, and I never use the tailstock when turning bowls. If you use a face plate, it has to be removed to core. A recess or tenon is fine. If you have a 12 inch lathe, and a 1 hp motor, this works well.
For mounting the blank, I use a forstner bit to cut a recess in the top of the blank, and expand the chuck into that for turning the bottom. I turn a recess on the bottom for reversing the blank to core. The chuck never comes off the lathe I remove the largest core first. The core keeps the recess for remounting it. I finish turn the big bowl, then start on the core. Mike Mahoney used a tenon. We both have a DVD out on coring with the McNaughton, so you can see mounting with a tenon, or a recess.
robo hippy
Very Sensible Answer, Donna
Allen Neighbors
>
Bob, you can core the smallest first...
Allen Neighbors
>then flip it around in the hole it just came out of, and, using the tailstock to hold it there, and turn a tenon on it.
Or --
Core out the center of your largest bowl and remove it. Turn the remaining core around and jam it between the chuck jaws and the tailstock and turn a tenon on it. Then turn it around, mount it, and core out the next one, and so on.
Or --
Before you core out your largest bowl, mount the blank as if you were going to core it, but turn a tenon in the center of the tailstock side of the blank. Core out your largest bowl. Turn the blank around and mount it backwards. Turn another tenon. Flip it around and core the next, and so on. You can keep using that center tenon 'til you run out of cores, just mark your #1 jaw so you can mount it back in the same spot each time.
And there are many more ways than these to core out a large blank. With practice, you'll decide which is the best way for you. :)