Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Another Nikon D40X Question

Posts

Another Nikon D40X Question

#1

Another Nikon D40X Question

Stuart Johnson

>It B&H has the Nikon D40X with an 18-55mm lens for $609.95. They also have a 55-200 VR lens for $229.95. In my prior email I mentioned I would be taking photos of a lot of coins I inherited and will be listing for sale. I also want to get serious about taking quality photos of my turnings.

My questions this time are about the lenses. The main one is the about the 18-55mm and 55-200 mm lens. Which one will I probably use more for the type of photography I've mentioned? Which is a better all around lens? I guess the basic question might better be when are they normally used?

If I was going to buy the body and just one lens which would I be better off buying?

Thanks for the help. The way things are going the camera will probably be out dated and obsolete.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#2

Re: The 18~55mm lens is your.......

Jamie Donaldson

>,....most useful range of focal lengths and will probably focus closer than the telephoto.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#3

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Check the specs on both lenses for the closest focusing distance and the listed reproduction ratio if available. I'm not certain these are the exact lenses that come with the camera (I got them from an Amazon package deal and looked them up on the Nikon site), but if correct notice the closest focusing distance. The longer lens may not get as close as you need.

18-55mm f/3.5-5.6G ED II AF-S DX Nikkor Zoom Lens

Minimum Focus: 0.9 feet

55-200mm f/4.5-5.6G ED AF-S DX Zoom-Nikkor Lens

Minimum Shooting Distance: 3.6 feet

Neither is advertised as a macro lens, which you may want if shooting closeups of individual coins. Best thing might be to go to a camera store and try out the camera on a coin or two and see if you can get close enough.

If not, you may have to purchase a separate macro lens. You can often add screw-on closeup "filters" for SLR lenses, but the quality is not as good as a dedicated macro lens. I'm facing the same issue with one of my Olympus dSLRs - I have two lenses for it and neither will focus as close as I'd like. A good macro lens for my camera is about $400. I read that good lenses for the Nikon D40x are expensive, but I didn't check.

When looking at lenses, note that given two lenses with similar macro capabilities, the longer lens may be better since it will let you get a little further away from the object, important when shooting live things like bugs, but also makes lighting small objects somewhat easier.

JKJ

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#4

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

RP

>We are talking digital here. The camera has at least 8 megapixels. Just take the picture with whatever lense you choose. Get as close as the lense will permit. Take the shot. Then crop it. With these high megapixel cameras you don't need macro lenses and all that stuff. You don't loose resolution or detail. It is there. Lighting is more critical for detail than focal lenght. You have to think digital! and quit thinking film! Just my thoughts.

P.S. The Olympus E500 takes great "macro" shots with the lenses that come with it. Just get yourself a photo editing program. You don't need to buy one that is expensive either. Olympus Master software is great.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#5

Re: RP is obviously not a techno-nut- if .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... any image is cropped there is a loss of resolution and detail,and the question is whether it is acceptable or too much at a given file size. That is a universal fact in both film and digital.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#6

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

john lucas

>I have to disagree on the cropping issue. Of course it depends on what you are going to do with the final image. In my experience you lose quiet a bit of sharpness when you crop more than 50%.

I think the 18-55 will be the most useful lens. The 55-200 will be too long for many things and as John said it probably won't focus as close.

You can easily get close up filters if the lens doesn't focus close enough. I would try the lens, and then crop the image if necessary and see if it will do what you want. if it won't then get a set of close up filters. If for some reason this won't work, and I think it will, then buy a good macro lens.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#7

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question - thanks

Stuart Johnson

>for the input. I'll go with the D40X and the 18-55mm lens. I'll also read as much of the the photography tips already posted before I start asking too many questions. FWIW, my last real photo experience was close to 50 years ago when I was an Army photographer using a 4x5 Speed Graphic.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#8

Re:Hey Stuart- I'll make you a real .....

Jamie Donaldson

>....deal on a Speed Graphic for old time sake!!!

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#9

Ric Taylor

No so......

Ric Taylor

>Cropping an image does nothing to the resolution, if that's all you do to it. You are only trimming off the edges. The part of the image that remains is still at the original resolution. It is only smaller in outside dimension, and because of that, smaller in file size.

Ric

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#10

Re:Hey Stuart- I'll make you a real .....

Stuart Johnson

>I suppose that comes with a nice darkroom set up. I still think black and white photos just seem more artistic. One of my favorite pass times after the Texas honky tonks was using oil paints to tint mat photos.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#11

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>P.S. The Olympus E500 takes great "macro" shots with

>the lenses that come with it. Just get yourself a

>photo editing program.

To me, cropping to zoom in a digital camera is somewhat analogous to using the digital zoom on a digital video camera.

I prefer to frame in the camera rather than crop significantly. For one thing critical focus is easier and for another, sharpness is preserved. My Olympus E10 takes far better macro and near-macro pictures than my Olympus E510 with either of the kit lenses. I'm looking at an Olympus macro lens and the Signma 105 f/2.8 macro lens recommended by several E510 users on DPREVIEW.

I personally use the full version of Photoshop for photo editing. It has a full set of features not often found in other editors.

BTW, given the choice, I also think a longer lens looks better than a wider lens for most macro work due to the perspective (but it's nice to have the option of both).

JKJ

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#12

Re: Ric- the assumption is that .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... the image viewing sizes will be equivalent rather than cropped to thumbnail size when viewing digital, also the same effect whether film or digital.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#13

Re:No darkroom left. And those oil.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....tinted prints you made will be around a lot longer than the chromogenic/dye color prints, or the "archival" ink jet prints of today. Kind of sad! ;-(((

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#14

Re:JohnK- I bought the 14~54mm...

Jamie Donaldson

>...f 2.8 zoom rather than the kit lenses for my E510, and it will focus to about 1" from the front element. Of course it cost almost what the body did, but I have always liked to use the best glass available.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#15

Ric Taylor

Re: Ric- the assumption is that .....

Ric Taylor

>There appears to be a misunderstanding of terms. Thumbnails are not normally created by cropping. Cropping is only used to delete unnecessary parts of an image, and this does not reduce the size of the main part of the image.

To make a thumbnail, an entire image (or an image that may have already been cropped) is usually reduced in overall size. These are two very different actions. Cropping and making a thumbnail are not the same thing.

Ric

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#16

I have a Speed Graphic

Ron in Drums PA

>Great Old Camera. My father bought it new right after WWII. I started using it in the 70s.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#17

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

john lucas

>John I also prefer a slightly longer lens for shooting artwork. The 55mm focal length is very good for this. On digital that equates to about 80 or so depending on the sensor size.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#18

Re: No so......

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Cropping an image does nothing to the resolution...

Ric,

You are right if discussing only the resolution of the cropped portion considered by itself.

However, I believe the issue discussed was the final difference between two methods of creating a "macro" image of say, a coin. RP suggested that in the absence of a close focusing lens, simply take a wider photo, then crop to get the desired closeup of the coin.

Consider a full-frame closeup taken with a macro lens where the coin fills the frame. Compare this to starting with a wider photo and cropping until the coin fills the cropping rectangle. This will certainly result in fewer pixels across the coin, reducing what might be called spatial resolution. While this resolution reduction may be insignificant if both images are displayed at equal size on a low resolution device, it can make a big difference in image quality if the end result is, say, a large print.

JKJ

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#19

Bill Blasic

Re: No so......

Bill Blasic

>Look to the secondary lens market, I bought a Sigma 70-300 with macro for my Canon XT. It takes very nice pictures with the macro setting plus the telephoto because the sensor is smaller than the area of a true 35mm the lens is virtually close to a 500mm lens. If the glass was compared to the glass in the high priced Canon and Nikon lenses in a laboratory I'm sure that there would be lots of differences but I've found it to be very satifactory in every day use and the price will not break the bank.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#20

Re: Telephoto focal lengths in a zoom.......

Jamie Donaldson

>......len usually exhibit less obvious pincushion distortion than the more pronounced barrel distortion characteristic of wide angle lenses, plus you have a better working distance lens to subject. That's really important when shooting snakes!

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#21

Geesh!

Ron in Drums PA

>Bottom Line

It really depends on what you are going to do with the final image. Remember you are using a 8mega pixel camera.

1. Max out your resolution

2. focus in on the coin with your 18mm-55mm lens using the 55mm focal length.

3. Shoot the picture.

4. Crop the image to your hearts content.

If you are displaying the pictures on the web, you will need to reduce the resolution

If you are going to print and the image is around 3" x 3" you will have no problems with the image.

Take a look at my article in this issue of WoodTurning Design. I took those pictures with a 2mega pixel camera.

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#22

I have several Graflex cameras

john lucas

>Several years ago I brought my camera collection up to work. I had about 80. Since then people have donated some and I've picked up some more. I think we have about 100 from Minox size to 8x10.


img

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#23

I forgot to mention

Ron in Drums PA

>Set your camera to marco

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#24

Steven Antonucci

He can buy my darkroom :-)

steve antonucci

>It's sitting in a box in the basement. Most of what you need to print up to 4x5 negatives and 16x20 prints in color and/or B/W.

Steve

Also, gone digital... :-(

Re: Another Nikon D40X Question

#25

Re:Who's marco? ;-)))

Jamie Donaldson

>