>I usually make a vacuum fit for small boxes, but I wanted the lid on a cocobolo box I just made loose enough to lift without picking the rest of the box off the table. I made the fit on this one as loose as I dared without making it sloppy, but it still has bit too much suction.
Is there a good way to get a loose lift next time without a sloppy fit? Perhaps a tapered flange?
Any good way to fix the one already made? Machine some air relief groves in the flange? Drill some tiny air holes? Fill the base with lead? Super glue it to the table? Wire a CO2 cartridge to a trigger on the lid?
>Personally, I like the CO2 answer the best. Having only made a few boxes, one with a vacuum fit (luck) and the rest a 'normal' fit (again luck) I can't offer a lot of suggestions. Let me know how the CO2 trigger works, though.
>I guess the easy way would be to start with a vacuum fit than take sand paper to either the mortise or the tenon (your call) until you get the fit you want.
This is how I used to get a loose fit by accident.
>I would try making the tendon short. That way even with a good tight fit, there would be little vacuum since the vacuum would be broken before it has much of a chance to develop one.
>John, I have only made a couple of dozen boxes. Some of them with the pop fit and some looser. I started by watching Richard Raffin, both in person and on video. Its been about eight years, but as I recall he was the master of the vacuum or pop fit. Then our club brought in Chris Stott for a day. His technique was different. Again, As I recall, he turned the box with the bottom of the box mounted in the chuck and cut what amounted to a tenon between the top and bottom at the join. Then he parted the top off, leaving about a 1/32 or 1/16" of the tenon attached to the top. He reverse chucked the top and hollowed it. By working from the center out, when the little residue of the tenon disappeared he knew he was just right on the diameter.
I have done a few this way and find that if I really nail it, I get a pop fit, but most of the time ADHD Boy here gets distracted and I over cut it slightly. It forms a loose fit and works well.
I think the pop fit is a "turners" trick and most people don't care.
I believe the ones that work best are the ones where the male tenon is tapered so that it is larger at the bottom and smaller at the top. The female tenon is smaller att he opening. This way, the top sort of snugs up just as it closes home, but loosens quickly as the join begins to separate and lets the air flow.
>I started out trying to turn the vacuum fit but picking up the whole box just to remove the lid is a nuisance, particularly when the boxes are 4+" in dia. Imagine you keep loose diamonds in the box and when you pop the lid, the contents go flying out all over the place. A pop fit is not practical. I do follow Raffan's method, though. I just cut a little more off the tenon to get a loose fit. Sometimes it comes out too loose. Then I apply a little lid tightening gel and move on to the next one.
>I will go with Ron and suggest using some 400 or 600 grit paper and sanding the flange until you get the fit you want. If you have access to some fine grit non-abrasive pads they might work as well.
It has been my experience that lids have a tendency to get tighter rather than looser. The fit you finish with on the lathe is not the same fit you will have a day or two or a month later. It is much better to have the fit a little looser than you want before you take it off the lathe. The only problem with sanding on the lathe to get the fit is that you may end up with a twist fit where you have turned the flange "oval".
John, it sounds like you have the perfect fit except for the fact it is not what you want. I sure hope you post a picture of this cocobolo box as I love boxes and particularly cocobolo boxes....
>John funny you should ask that. I'm just finished fighting a box. It had a perfect fit lid. no slop and you could lift the top without lifting the bottom. that was yesterday. Today the top is too tight. I think the top actually became slightly oval. Fortunately I was able to put the box back on the lathe by making a jam chuck. I took the outer lip down a hair.
I have found that a long tenon and tight fit is what causes or at least inhances the suction fit. This is because it takes longer for the air leak out. Making lid tenons shorter reduces this affect.
I have a special made tool that I built that has matching tapers on both sides. I can make the lip on the lid and box match with a taper that lets the lid fit snug but without sticking. Well that's the theory anyway. What I found was that it fits too good. Kind of like a morse taper. Works well most of the time but it can jam. If you wax the lips it prevents it. I found puting a rabbit on one end of the taper so the lid can't seat any further than snug your OK. If the lid warps it still works well it's just finicky to do and get it right.
Did you rough turn then let the wood stabilize? Raffan says there are stresses even in very dry wood that can release slowly after hollowing, sometimes causing the box to go out of round overnight. I think he said to let it sit at least for a few hours. I wait at least over night (I rough-hollowed these cocobolo blanks a week ago), then let it set again before the final fit on the lid.
I still have the jam chuck I used to finish the bottom of this box - I may try shaving and shortening the tenon a bit more.
>Wood over 2" thick really never dries, even if placed in a kiln.
I rough turn a box and return to it in a few days. I have a bunch of roughed out boxes ready to go at anytime.
Another thing I found is if I create to much heat while sanding (back in the 1236 days) it would be best to let the box "rest" overnight before fitting the lid.
>John I rarely let boxes sit when I'm using dry wood. Most of the wood I use for boxes has been sitting a while in my shop and i use end grain as much as possible. I haven't had many problems with woodmovement but I know it does occur. This box was extrememly old dry wood but the top was long grain and I think that might have been the problem.
It was either that or the fairly thick lacquer finish. I don't think it was the finish because I had to remove too much to make it fit again.
>John, it is not a bad idea to let them sit. When you hollow a box you will almost always see a change in the shape from round to slightly oval. The flange on the lid and the box body may not be "flat" any longer. Because of that I always true up the flanges using my skew as a scraper. Make sure the skew is razor sharp and remove dust until you get a shiny surface all the way around. Once you see that shiny surface i.e. freshly scraped wood the flange surface will totatlly be in the same plane.
For the same reasons I do not do any final body shaping until the lid and body are mated and turned together making sure that I align the grain before beginning the turning.
>I have some 4" thick square bubinga that was cut into spindles 12 years ago. I checked the outside and the MC was 11%, about as low as any wood that is air dried gets in my parts. I cut a 4" long piece from the spindle and checked the inside MC... 20%
The center of thick wood doesn't dry like the outside.
>I use a skew also for the tenon and mortise. With the long point facing the headstock and the skew aligned with the ways, I shave just enough off to make a perfect fit.
>final scrape the tenon to round, won't that make a tight lid loose? I can understand allowing the box to sit overnight to equalize things, and I understand waiting to final shape the outside, but I don't think I understand when you do the final lid fit. Can you clarify this for the old gray dense guy? :)
>Allen, when I initially jam fit the lid onto the body the fit is too tight for use. It has to be tight so that you can finish turn the lid and match the lid to the body. After the lid is shaped and sanded you need to adjust the fit so that lid removal is user friendly, i.e. it doesn't take two men and a boy to remove the lid. So I use my ever faithful Craftsman 1/2" skew as a scraper to adjust the fit. I can take the long point and slide it in next to the body and scrape dust right next to the body and roll it gently toward the body opening, all the while keeping it flat on the tool rest, and remove dust along the entire flange. And I do mean remove dust. If you make shavings you have just made the lid too loose. Stop the lathe and check the fit of the lid frequently. Alternatively with the lathe off hold the lid in your right hand and turn the spindle with your left while holding the lid against the body flange. The mark that results is the precise diameter where the lid fits. You can use that burnish mark to help you judge how much wood to remove when you are scraping dust.
By the way, did I mention that you should only remove dust????? The amount of wood between an overly tight jam fit and a too loose fit is just a little more than dust.
>I have found similar results, Ron, that is why I have been rough turning my thicker wood blanks and doing the alcohol soak and dry routine. I can almost always tell when I am doing the initial roughing if the wood is too wet as the chips will come out feeling cool. If the wood is dry enough for turning the chips will be warm or hot.
Like you 11% is dry for me. Here in the coastal plain of NC we have too much humidity for kiln dried wood to stay below 10% for long.