Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Cherry Ogee

Posts

Cherry Ogee

#1

Cherry Ogee

George Van

>I haven�t posted in a while, I have been trying some new ogee shapes and I must say some have not been very pleasing. I have difficulty finding the proper transition spot to make a pleasing curve. I think this one works well with the cherry grain. This piece of cherry had so many soft spalted and rot spots as it had been found on the ground that anything other than a foot would have been impossible. I think it worked out ok. It is 9.5x3.25 with 1/8� walls. The finish is oil. Comments and suggestions are appreciated.


img

Re: Cherry Ogee

#2

Re: Cherry Ogee

Mike Brazeau

>That is a very pretty bowl George. Cherry is the best! I like a slightly less lift, but have certainly seen lots of bowls with the elevated look too.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#3

Re: Cherry Ogee

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Yep, you got this one right. I like it. It's true that getting the transition area where the curve changes direction is a bit touchy. One of the forms that I suggest in my bowl turning classes is the ogee. I always have to work with the student to try to get it right.

A suggestion that you might try on a future ogee form. I like to make the foot more of a dovetail shape. It allows the curve to go just a little farthur. If the foot is deep enough, a small bead where it joins the bowl looks nice.

Wally

Re: Cherry Ogee

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Cherry Ogee

Mike Stafford

>George, your choice of wood, your work and your photograph are quite beautiful. Not much to complain about here. Lovely ogee form bowl!

Re: Cherry Ogee

#5

Re: Cherry Ogee

Phil Powell

>George,

What a great bowl! it's nice to see your transition from one shape

to the next. Growth and change can be so damn difficult. Very

good work! Phil

Re: Cherry Ogee

#6

Steven Antonucci

Nice job lining up the grain

steve antonucci

>It wouldn't have been as good if you had the grain running all wild. You did a fine job composing the bowl.

Steven

Re: Cherry Ogee

#7

Re: Cherry Ogee

Rick Allen

>That is a nice looking bowl to be sure.

You might try going overboard on the curve with the next one.


img

Re: Cherry Ogee

#8

Re: Cherry Ogee

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Good looking bowl. My suggestion is to visually separate the foot from the bowl so the bowl's curve can continue to flow through the bottom. I'd probably use a V-grove -- yah, it will look like a tenon for chucking the bowl, but if it makes the form work better...

It looks like you have an interesting grain pattern on the inside.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#9

Re: Cherry Ogee

Allen Neighbors

>You're right, George, it did work. I like the foot, too.

Beautiful work.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#10

Re: Cherry Ogee

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Beautiful wide bell shape. Would love to see another angle of the foot if you could post it.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#11

Re: Cherry Ogee

Don in Central Illinois

>Beautiful bowl and wonderful wood. You did it justice.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#12

Re: Cherry Ogee

George Van

>Thanks for all the suggestions and compliments, they are appreciated.

Mike, I had to go this high with the foot to get to sound wood or the base would have had too much rot, if it had been sound I would have gone shallower or a slight recess.

Wally, I understand your suggestion, I have a maple bowl I am going to buff this evening that has a dovetail style foot. I will try the bead on a future bowl. I have been practicing for some nicely spalted pieces that are finally ready. Do you think the bead would compete with the spalting?

Rick, I will try that with one of the spalted blanks, the form should show the spalting pattern well.

Brian, I will try that in photo shop and then again on one of my practice bolws that are destined for the fireplace when they get too thin to use anymore. Many times I get a better visual that way and the bowls have cracks or bad spots so I just lengthen there time before they are in the ash bin.

Bruce, I will try to get a photo when I'm in the house for supper and will post it at that time.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#13

Re: Cherry Ogee

Sean Troy

>Beautifully done ! Great looking wood also. You OK up there after the storms? Sean

Re: Cherry Ogee

#14

Re: Cherry Ogee

George Van

>Here is a shot of the foot Bruce, hope this helps!


img

Re: Cherry Ogee

#15

Re: Cherry Ogee

George Van

>Hey Sean, we are ok, thanks for asking. Everything was 300 miles south of here. I was thinking of you today, I am finish turning one of the roughs you gave me when you were still in Phoenix three years ago, Carob I believe.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#16

Re: Cherry Ogee

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Thanks, it looks good!

Re: Cherry Ogee

#17

Just a beauty George

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>I would not change a thing!!

I love this one.

Dave

Re: Cherry Ogee

#18

Re: Cherry Ogee w/question on tools

David Churnega

>Very nice and in my favorite wood.

I am new to lathes and own an old 1950 rockwell. Bought a chuck for it last night and installed it.

The question:

I do not own a bowl gouge, what size should I get 3/8 or 1/2? Was told that I could not get a large enough blank to justify at 1/2.

The lathe I have has an 11" swing.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#19

Re: Just a beauty George

George Van

>Thanks Dave, I appreciate your comment.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#20

Re: Cherry Ogee

Cyril Griesbach

>Same comments regarding the foot, George, but I really like the lift. You really nailed this one!!

Re: Cherry Ogee

#21

Re: Cherry Ogee w/question on tools

George Van

>Thanks David, if it were me, I would get the 3/8�, it would be slower roughing but allow me finer finishing cuts on items below 12� diameter. Others may have a different opinion. I do a lot of my finishing cuts with a �� flute width gouge. If you do a search on the main page for �gouge� you will get a lot of good information and varied opinions. The most important note is that it must be sharp, you should not have to push a cut, it will lead you. I use a Oneway Wolverine sharpening system with the Vari-Grind. The Grinds library on the left on the main page is a good reference for grinding profiles. Any old gouge will cut well as long as it is sharp, some stay sharper longer than others. I do like Doug Thompson�s gouges in the medium price range.

Re: Cherry Ogee

#22

Re: Cherry Ogee

George Van

>Thanks Cyril, after this thread I can think of a lot of different foot variations to try. This is the good thing about comments is it gives us "good food for thought".