Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Benjamin"s Best turning tools

Posts

Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#1

Benjamin"s Best turning tools

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Penn State has a line of this tool at what seem to be very cheap prices. They are M2 steel. eg.

3/8 bowl gouge 22" long handled $ 14.50

Set of3 tools 3/8, 1/2 and a 5/8 $ 48.40

Have any of you used these tools and what do you think about them ?

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#2

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools *LINK*

Sean Troy

>Bill, IMHO, for the money, check out the thompson tools.


http://www.thompsonlathetools.com

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#3

Others no doubt will disagree

Jerry Hall

>but I think they are great depending on what you need! The steel is no doubt not up to British standards, it stains more easily from green turning. It may not hold an edge quite as long, but I can't tell the difference when I hone them to touch up the edge between grindings. I love that by comparison to the Sorby they have longer handles and tool end, by a lot. I got them on a whim to try out different grinds. The spindle gouges have a lot of metal under the flute and make great detail gouges. Now I have 2-3 of my favorite grinds for each size tool. I would never do that for a tool 4x more expensive. I am disgusted at the short 3/8" Sorby that already is difficult to sharpen with my Wolverine jig because it ramps up and moves in the jig where the flute dies. It has forced me to learn to hand sharpen it. Bummer. If I was to get a better tool because I became a production turner I will look at the Thompson tools. I will never by a British M2 gouge again. Maybe if I was a better turner I could tell the difference, but I wish I had started out with these and bought another chuck. But I did that anyway I guess.... It's a disease. Also the big old Penn State roughing gouge is a steal too. There is no reason for a new turner to look at any other tools, and they are what I recommend for someone starting out and suffering from sticker shock at the demands of our craft. I have used them for 2 years and am very happy. Also it is much less expensive to buy tools you don't use this way.

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#4

me too, jerry

robert davis

>

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#5

They're not too bad

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Bill,

I live really close to PSI's showroom (off of Philmont Ave) so I check them out occasionally for bargains. I've bought several of this brand of tool from their "discount" bin as well as off the "normal price" wall. I think I got a 1" skew for under $10 the last time I was there.

They seem to retain their edge about as well as my Packard Woodworks tools. Maybe not as well as the Sorbys. But not by much. (They ain't no Glaser tools thought!!)

So far the only negative thing I have to say about them is the handle. It's too darn light for my tastes. I ended up turning a new handle for just about all of the BB tools I bought.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#6

no disagreement here

Ralph

>I wouldn't recommend them if I hadn't used them and thought them worth the $$$$

The 2-inch roughing gouge is a monster, as is the large scraper.

Worth every penny

As they has good as my best tools, nope, but they are worth every penny. Great tools to learn what tool shape works best for you, and how to create it and keep it sharp

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#7

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

Texian

>Bill,

I got the set of three bowl gouges, partly for grinding practice. The ones I have are rather "V" shaped, compared to the "U" shape of my one and only Sorby. Have more difficulty controlling the big one compared to the Sorby, but have not tried very hard to "learn it" either. The little one with just a straight conical grind is dandy and gets a lot of use. I can't tell much difference in edge holding ability, but have no consistent data to support that thought.

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#8

Re: Others no doubt will disagree

Ed Larson

>Jerry, I assume you will make this point at the Jan. tool demo.?? I have a BB parting tool that works great.

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

#9

Re: Benjamin"s Best turning tools

George Van

>Bill, I have several of them, I use them for those special grind/use gouges you need occasionally, can't see having a Sorby or Thompson for the occasional use and they are usually sharpened for the final cut any way. I also use them when rocks and dirt are present and roughing as Bill Neddow suggests so you can do a batch sharpening when they are all dull. As others have said they are not a Glaser, Thompson, or Sorby, but they are not junk either.