Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

dust collection at bansaw.

Posts

dust collection at bansaw.

#1

dust collection at bansaw.

john lucas

>I have 3 machines that produce a lot of dust and shavings. The table saw, the bandsaw and the lathe. As soon as I get my overhead guard done I'll solve the table saw problem. I've got the fine dust under control at the lathe and you know we can't do very much about the shavings.

The bandsaw is defeating me. I just spent the day working on sealing all the openings in my bandsaw. I had already installed a dust collector. Now the inside is practically spotless when I saw. The outside is a different matter. I get dust and crap all over. What you see in the photo is just one bowl roughed out. I even drilled holes in the table insert and sealed areas under it to create more airflow in that area.

Anyone have any suggestions. I would rather clean it at the source than sweep up afterwords.


img

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#2

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

john lucas

>Here are some of the areas that I created seals to keep the bandsaw clean. You see how clean the inside is after cutting the bowl.


img

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#3

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

Jerry Hall

>John,

I notice that the "stuff" tends to gather at the far back corner. How about a hood or large hose on a magnet against the piller? The mechanics of the dust creation is a little like a lathe and this might help. A hood back there shouldn't be in the way and could be "T'd" into your line.

Jerry

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#4

Re: dust collection at bandsaw.

Barry Irby

>John, I have a contractor TS and have got that down to next to nothing, at least under the table. I have not put on a over the blade pick up, but I guess it's not bothering me that much.

I have a similar bandsaw. I used a "End boot" from four inch ductwork for the pick up. As much as I can tell, it is very nearly like yours with the possible exception of mine reaches right up under the insert in the table. Like a finger. In fact, on the rare occasions I tilt the table past about 35 degrees, I have to loosen my pick up and let it slip down a little or it will lift the insert out of the table. Mine also draws straight down. Yours turned it ninety degrees. Wonder if that decreases your efficiency?

Mine seems to work better than yours, but not as well as I had hoped.

I think we need to observe carefully and figure out where the crap is coming from. I think the blade is carrying it all the way around and dropping it back on top the work and table. I am not sure. I have brushes on mine that clean the wheels. I wonder if a set of brushes that the blade would run through would have the effect of knocking the dust out of the gullets and leave it for the DC? Either on the side of the bottom wheel where the blade comes back up or under the table to the left of the insert to sort of brush the crap toward your pickup. Don't even know if there is enough room.

Another thought I had for this and the TS would be to use compressed air. Been wondering if you could set up a nozzle to blow air across the blade through the gullets to dislodge the debris and blow it toward the DC. This would require some sort of solenoid operated nozzle wired to you bandsaw switch or the switch on the DC for the Bandsaw.

It might be simpler to install a DC port over the table like you are considering on the TS. Something that could ride up and down with the top guides.

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#5

Re: dust collection at bandsaw.

john lucas

>Barry I plan to add the brush over the wheel I just haven't had the time yet. The hose angle could be part of the problem but I think it won't solve very much. I think possibly a hose attached to the upper blade guide. Of course that means splitting the air so less volume below.

I have a contractors table saw but I find that a large amount of the dust comes from above the blade. I thought it might be blade alignment but I worked on that and it must be something else. I've sealed off as much of the bottom as I can. There's still a large hole where the saw tilts. I'm sure I lose a lot of vacuum through that.

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#6

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

Russ Fairfield

>You will have better luck at getting more of the sawdust with 2 collecting locations. One at the point you already have under the blade, and the other at bottom dead center in the front of the bottonm wheel cover door. If you only had one collection point, you would most likely find that the one at the bottom of the wheel cover door would do the most good.

Yes, it is in the way, but with the way these saws are made, there is no easy way to locate it on the back side of the bottom wheel cover.

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#7

Re: dust collection at bandsaw.

Barry Irby

>John, I am certainly not an expert on this. I have not tried fifty different scenarios to test what works best so I can only tell you my results.

I put a chute up through the bottom of my TS and made a cover for it that closes the opening down about a half inch by twelve inch slot. I used aluminum tape to close off most of the other parts of the chute. After a while, I realized that you must have some openings for air flow. It occurred to me that as a friend used to say, you got to have "goes into" and "goes out of". In other words, if you expect maximum air flow through that four inch hose, it must have at least that much of an opening. I think I reached the point that I had closed the port down so small, I was restricting air flow.

On the TS, I make it a habit to raise the blade just enough to bring the teeth through the top of the work. If you raise the blade much higher, there is more opportunity for it to throw the sawdust out the top. With the blade lower more of it is below the table and there is more chance for the dust to fall out below. On a Bandsaw, you don't have the same effect as raising the blade.

BTW, the last big improvement I made on my TS was to epoxy brushes to the bottom of my table insert. This physically restrains the dust and causes it to fall back into the chute. I actually measured the effect. I tested using a larger hose and with and without the brushes. The brushes reduced the amount dust below the table by about fifty percent. The larger hose did nothing.

If I were to do anything to my BS I would try a second pickup but first I would try brushes on the blade.

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#8

Re: dust collection at bandsaw.

john lucas

>Most interesting. Thanks Barry. I probably have great airflow from the slot in the back by the belt to the hose. I guess I'll have to work on the direction.

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#9

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

john lucas

>Russ I thought about mounting it there after I built the other adaptor. Since there isn't any dust in the bottom after cutting several blanks I assume it's working. I need to run some sort of experiment to see if I can figure out where the dust is coming from.

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#10

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

wilbur

>Did you get this much dust on the table before you made your bandsaw dust collection setup?

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#11

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

john lucas

>As much or more. The worst problem before I added the dust collection was it would follow the wheel all the way around and come out by the upper guides. this made a dust cloud that you had to breath. I don't have that anymore.

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

#12

Re: dust collection at bansaw.

wilbur

>Putting together how clean the bottom well of your bandsaw is with the amount of dust on your table, it's clear that you have enough suction to clean out the bottom well. Therefore, the dust left on the table isn't being pulled down below the table to be collected.

In order to collect this dust, you either need to increase the suction that your dust collector provides, or have some dust collection above the table. Barry's comment about how sealing the bottom of the bandsaw too tightly can actually lead to less efficient dust collection certainly is true. For effective dust collection, you need to move large volumes of air, which is not the same as high velocity. If you use a hood at the lathe for sanding operations, you already know this is true. That is a completely unsealed system that collects dust very well.

What may be happening is that as you seal up the bottom well, you are reducing the supply of air. If the bottom of your bandsaw is completely sealed, the only place that air would be able to enter would be around the bandsaw blade, where you may feel a rush of air, but that would be an inadequate volume of air for good dust collection. Think of the difference between a garden hose with a high power stream that shoots across the yard, and the Mississippi River on a slow day. The hose certainly shoots water faster than the Mississippi, but the Mississippi carries more water. You want the Mississippi River in your dust collection.

Try unsealing the bottom of your bandsaw one piece at a time to see if your dust collection improves. Providing some sort of above the table dust collection may be the easier route to take. You also may want to rethink that 90� turn the air has to make to go into the hose. That definitely is going to reduce the efficiency of your dust collection.