Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

motors

Posts

motors

#1

motors

robo hippy

>I am considering getting the Robust lathe, and was wondering about motors. I seem to remember reading that a 3 phase motor with a converter is better than a same hp single phase motor. Seems like there is supposed to be more power at lower speeds, and the 3 phase works better with the frequency drive. Anyone know for shure?????

robo hippy

Re: motors

#2

Re: motors

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>To the best of my knowledge there are two ways to have variable speed. 3 phase AC or DC. The advantage to a 3 phase AC motor is that as speed goes down the torque stays almost constant. It does drop but not nearly as fast as the DC motor. I have a Oneway 3 hp AC variable and a Vicmark 1/1/2 hp DC. I will not buy another DC motor.

Save your bucks and get the best.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: motors

#3

Dick Hines

Re: motors

Dick Hines

>If you go with 3 phase you will have to rewire everything in the service box in your shop, I think.

The single phase motors on lather have a phase converter. That is where the vari speed comes from. I bet you will get a better answer before the night is over.

Re: motors

#4

Re: motors

Allen Neighbors

>Dick, Robo, the single phase electricity in your shop will run the 3phase motor, I believe, because the converter on the lathe converts it to 3 phase internally. I think.

I have a 2hp Oneway 1640, and I think it's motor is 240 volt 3 phase. I tried to get 3 phase electricity ran to my shop, but the electric company wouldn't do it because it's in a residential area... here it has to be in a commercial district to get 3 phase electricity.

My electrician son ran the 240 circuit to my lathe. I plugged it in, and it works.

Someone may correct me if I'm wrong... you have my permission. :))

Re: motors

#5

Re: motors

Phil Powell

>If you're thinking Robust I believe that there is only one 3hp motor offered and it is

single phase which allows the motor to be variable speed (easily). I have a Robust 25

and I have to say that I've never needed more power. I've turned many large bowls

and platters and the lathe stands up to what ever I ask it to do. 3 hp is a bunch of power.

Re: motors

#6

Re: motors

john lucas

>Well you've gotten some confusing answers so I'll try to straighten it out. They are right that 3 phase is current is better but you probably can't get it unless you are in a commercial area.

You can however convert single phase into 3 phase. It can be done several ways but the new variable frequency drives do this and give you the advantage of variable speed as well. They do this by changing the frequency of the current instead of the voltage. This means that you get almost full power at low rpm's. with a DC motor the speed change is done by lowering the voltage which also reduces the power.

I don't know if 3 phase motors are stronger or better than single phase but suspect they are in commercial applications. I also don't know if a 3 phase motor as supplied on our lathes is better stronger than the same size single phase motor. However the variable speed certainly makes them better for our use.

The Robust as well as many of the other top brands all use the variable frequency drive to convert 110 or 220 single phase to 3 phase power to run the 3 phase motor that comes on the machine. As I mentioned above this gives us variable speed also and is well worth the money.

If I had the money to upgrade the Robust would be my choice. I currently have the Powermatic and it does 99 percent of everything I need right now but I'm saving my money.

Re: motors

#7

Re: motors

Phil in NJ

>The variable frequency drive used to provide variable speed can only work with a 3-phase motor. As others have said, these drive units can take in 220v single-phase power, like you have in your home, and produce a variable frequency 3 phase output.

The motors typically run at full speed at 60hz frequency, and runs more slowly at lower frequencies.

I don't know too much about the Robust, but I would guess a single-phase motor isn't even an option.

When people say 3 phase motors are better, the justification is usually several things: these motors are simpler, cheaper, have no capacitors and/or switches to fail, and are therefore more reliable. They also run more smoothly because 3 phase power delivers constant power. Some of these characteristics are negated by the use of the variable speed drive, but the advantages of the variable speed are so great that we just accept the fact that the drive is complex, can fail, etc.

I think you do have an option of how big a motor you want... 2 or 3 HP. This depends on the type of work you do. For many people 2 HP is enough (myself included). Others feel they get benefit from 3 HP.

Some professional bowl makers (like Mike Mahoney) have talked about 5 or even 10 HP... but they are really pushing the limits in very large coring operations!

-Phil

Re: motors

#8

Re: Thanks, John,

Allen Neighbors

>now I know which direction the conversion goes!!! :)

Re: motors

#9

Re: motors

gtwilkins

>Robo,

The advantages of using a 3 phase motor with a VFD also include:

-smooth acceleration when you dial up the speed.

- dynamic braking when you shut down (so you are not freewheeling to a stop.

-the VFD can be set to pick-up a catch and instantly interrupt the power to the motor (giving you time to recover) or if the catch is big enough shut down completely.

-the possibility of preset speeds.

-uses common wire and breakers for power (my Vic uses 12/2 wire with a standard 20 amp breaker and a 220v 20amp 3 pin receptacle).

I sent a PM today did you receive it, over.

Talk to you soon, Trevor

Re: motors

#10

Re: motors

john lucas

>It also won't damage anything if you start the lathe with something jamming the piece (like the tool rest or index plate, you know how I discovered that).

If you accidentally hit the reverse button it doesn't do any damage, it simply slows down and then reverses and ramps back up to speed.

The ramp up and dynamic braking are the two best features. When I had my Nova and the DC motor that I installed it would take sometimes a minute for a large piece of wood to slow down enough to inspect it. After I installed the VFD and 3 phase motor it stopped the lathe in about8 seconds or less on a piece like that. You do have to make sure your chuck is fastened down tight on large pieces because the braking action can actually unscrew the chuck. Another thing I learned the hard way.

Re: motors

#11

Re: motors

Jeff Rich

>I have recently purchased a Jet with the 3 phase motor and a variable frequency drive. The inverter requires 240 single phase to operate the motor.

As long as you have a 240 line to your shop and the Robust has an inverter, you have it made.

There are a couple of guys around the board that have Robust lathes.

Hopefully they will join in and give some more info.

Re: motors

#12

Some Clarity...

Peter Teubel

>There is no such thing as an AC single phase ELECTRONICALLY variable speed induction motor (at least in mainstream tools). They are all 3-phase. The electronics box (a.k.a. VFD controller) changes the single-phase input to 3-phase to operate the motor. Most VFDs can use either single-phase or 3-phase as an INPUT, but the output is always 3-phase.

Re: motors

#13

Re: motors

robo hippy

>Okay, I do have the PM 3520A, and love it, but the appeal of the 3hp motor and bigger swing appeal to me. More hp and torque for faster stock removal. I do stall the PM a lot. Perhaps I misread the info on the Robust, but I thought it said single phase motors on their lathes with no mention of 3 phase or a converter. From the comments here it seems like variable speed works better or only on the 3 phase and DC motors. Hmmmm, guess I need to call Brent at Robust and ask him.

Trevor, haven't gotten a pm from you. Nothing sent to my e-mail at home, and if there is that service from WC, then I can't find it.

robo hippy

Re: motors

#14

The Robust has 3-phase motor with a VFD.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>