Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Hollowing Redwood Vessel

Posts

Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#1

Hollowing Redwood Vessel

Barry Turner

>I had an exceptional piece of redwood lace burl in the shop and decided to turn a small hollow vessel today. The vessel is a classic onion shape. The vessel is about 4" tall and about 5 1/2" in diameter at the widest part. It has a 1 1/2" opening. I am having a hard time hollowing this vessel.

I have the 5/8" Kelton set of hollowers. (They don't seem to cut well in the redwood) I have a straight Sorby multi-tip tool. I also have the larger gooseneck Sorby hollower. And the small Sorby ornament-size gooseneck hollower.

I am having the difficulty at and above the widest diameter. I just can't seem to reach these places. I'm not real experienced with hollow vessels, so I'm not sure where the practical limits of what I can expect to do are.

Do I need some other tool (perhaps the John Jordan small hollowers?) Or, am I just trying to hollow through too small an opening? Maybe I just need to swallow my pride and go to a 2" opening? Any advice will be appreciated.

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#2

Dick Hines

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

Dick Hines

>I have found that shallow hollow forms can be hard to reach in the corners. I useily will use a larger opening so I can get to the out side edge.

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#3

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

eliot d

>Think about making your own curved tools that will reach where you want them to. It's not difficult, and there are many on this site that know all about it. About all you need is a a length of 3/8 " O1 rod , a mapp torch and some of those metal-cutting machinists tips that Enco sells. You won't have difficulty , after a while , hollowing through small openings, like 1/2 ".

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#4

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

john lucas

>Barry I'm surprised you can't reach it with the larger Sorby curved tool. Obviously you tried. That's why I built so many different tools. I never seemed to have the right one. I'm guessing a half inch tool with a gentle curve would reach in very easily. The John Jordan tool that has the flatest curve will reach most places I need to go. It's the unusual vessels that I have problems with. I think that one would reach in for you. I think he has photos of them on his website. Make a drawing of your piece and then run off a copy of Johns bar. Cut that out and hold it up to the drawing and see if it works.

Of course you could also do the same thing with your tools and see how much you would have to enlarge the opening to make it work. You might be surprise how little you would have to enlarge it.

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#5

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I'm surprised you are having problems with the Kelton's. You should be able to get to the parts you're having problems with using the most curved hollower. An 1 1/2" opening should be more than adequate to get to the portion of the walls you are having problems with. Is it possible you are presenting the tip at the wrong angle? I find that by tipping the cutting edge down slightly below center and taking a very light cut, I am able to cut most wood.

keithz

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#6

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

Carole Valentine

>Hi Barry. You should be able to reach those areas with the Keltons, although it may be easier with the 1/2". I have done pieces that were 6 1/2" wide by 3 1/4" tall with a one inch opening and a very high shoulder so the typical onion shape should not give you any problems. Is it that you can't physically reach the area with your tool or that you can't make the tool cut in those areas?

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#7

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

Allen Neighbors

>If you can reach the spot, but just can't make the tool cut because of it's presentation to the wood, try this with the lathe off: See if you can get the cutter to reach the insidewall, with the cutting edge above center slightly, at a downward angle. If not, I think you will need to make a tool with a different swan curve to it.

If you need me to, I can probably explain this a little better. Email me (remove the REMOVE).

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#8

Re: Dissertation on Hollowing :)

Allen Neighbors

>I decided to go ahead and try to explain my previous post.

When I have my cutting edge too low, I get catches. Now lets all look at this problem from a different perspective. Think about this deal from the standpoint of the center of a HollowForm (don't try to stand there), and as if the wood is going around in a circle (Well, it is!), and as if you are going to do all your work in the upper left quadrant... from 9 to 12 o'clock.

Now, draw an imaginary verticle line through the center of the HF, top to bottom as you look at it from the tailstock end. As the wood circles over the top of the arc, it's moving away from the verticle position, and arcing downward. When it passes the 9'oclock position, it heads back toward the verticle position. Make sense?

If you will turn the flat on your cutter to a 45 degree angle... like this slant mark / with a little more lean to it, and take very light cuts using the lowest edge of the cutter (if you�re using a scraper� like cutting on the lower edge of a skew), cutting only in the upper left quadrant of the piece, the wood is moving away from the cutter, which will make the cutter "shave" the wood.

If you have the cutter below center (anywhere between 6 and 9'oclock), the wood is moving toward the vertical position and the cutter, which will make the cutter dig into the wood (catch).

When you go "around the corner" (transition from bottom of HF to side of HF) you want to rotate the scraper just slightly back toward a horizontal position (slightly less than the 45 degree slant / ), and keep cutting on the lower edge of the slant as you move up toward the top of the HF, but quit cutting, before you get to the near-horizontal part of the top.

Now this all makes sense to me, cause I do it this way all the time. But, judging from my inability to explain the theory of relativity and nuclear fission, I'll bet it's confusing as heck to the rest of you. Right?

Well, anyhow, it works for me. Al

Re: Hollowing Redwood Vessel

#9

Re: Dissertation on Hollowing :)

Barry Turner

>I went back to the shop and re-assessed my hollowing problem. I sharpened the cutters on both Sorby multi-tip tools. Then, I began trying different cutter positions. I quickly found that what I really needed was not a new tool, but simply a healthy dose of focus and determination. Today, I was able to hollow the vessel completely and without enlarging the opening. Later, I made a collar for the opening from Cocobolo. It was necessary to increase the size of the opening to 2" for it to look "right". (Had I done this initially, the hollowing would have been substantially easier!) Thanks for the help.