Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Torch selection

Posts

Torch selection

#1

Torch selection

Mark Wollschlager

>I am going to use up some fun tickets at Home Despot and got to thinking about getting a torch.

The BernzOmatic line seems to be the way to go for the occasional uses I would have.

Would the MAPP or MAPP with oxygen be a better choice for me?

I would be doing a little brazing and soldering as well as heating steel for bending and some tool making chores.

Perhaps a bit of light welding.

TIA.

Mark.

Re: Torch selection

#2

Re: Torch selection

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>The MAPP torches are a better choice for today's lead free plumbing solders. They are also good for doing soldering on galvanized gutters (worked out handy for a small gutter job), and for brazing work. Did you get enough gift cards for the small portable oxy/acet. welding set? That would be a good choice too.

Re: Torch selection

#3

Re: Torch selection

john lucas

>Mark The small Mapp/Oxy kits aren't worth the money. It gets hotter than Mapp alone but doesn't have the volume to heat big stuff for bending. When you do use it for bending it uses a huge amount of oxygen and the replacement tanks are like $9 apiece.

It will let you do some brazing and welding on small metal but I have found that I can do the things that I do with a Mapp gas torch and silver solder.

If your really serious about gas welding get Oxy/acetolene.

Re: Torch selection

#4

Re: Torch selection

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I have both the MAPP and MAPP/oxygen torches. I rarely use the MAPP/oxygen torch because the heat output isn't that much greater and the oxygen is so expensive.

One trick you can use to braze larger pieces larger pieces is to use propane torches to heat the metal on either side of the area. A while ago I needed to braze three pieces of 1/2" rebar together. Two propane torches and a MAPP torch did the trick.

Re: Torch selection

#5

Re: Torch selection

JohnKJordan in East TN

>You need a lot of heat to bend steel, unless it is real thin.

I also vote for the small oxy-acetylene torch kits which are far more versitile than the hardware store plumbing torches. For occasionaly use, you can get a kit with small bottles in a portable carrying case and a brazing/welding torch.

But if you are like me and start to find so many uses for it, you'll be running out of gas, buying extra tanks and a cutting torch, etc. (Cutting takes a LOT of oxygen) I don't use enough gas to justify renting large tanks (which are generally not for sale) so I bought the largest possible and mounted them on a hand dolly. The regulators and torch from the small kit can be used with the larger bottles. With this, I've bent 1/2" steel plate, cut an anvil out of a railroad rail, welded thin sheet metal, and did a lot of brazing (which is extremely quick and easy with a oxy-acetylene torch).

JKJ

Re: Torch selection

#6

Re: Torch selection

GeeSeaWhy

>Can you (legally) store oxy/acetylene cylinders indoors (in the U.S., MA if it matters)? My wife does glass beadmaking and MAPP alone is barely hot enough for even soft glass. But she has the idea that anything hotter would need to be stored (and maybe even used) outside the house itself. Of course, we have no garage or garden shed.

Graeme

Re: Torch selection

#7

Re: Torch selection

john lucas

>All of the jewelers I know work inside and often use Oxy/acetolene. I'm more comfortable using that indoors than my electric welder. Now I wouldn't use the cutting torch inside. It's kind of like everything else we deal with. You have to read up on the dangers and then take proper precautions.

Re: Torch selection

#8

Re: Torch selection

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I have no idea about your area, but I have never heard of any restrictions on storage. You might check with your home insurance carrier and ask mr Google what other jewelry makers do.

I know of many in use in garages, shops, and studios but I don't know anyone who uses a torch in the living area of a house. My high school had an oxyacetylene torch in the art department for jewelry (but admittedly, that was a long time ago!) Both tanks are relatively safe unless abused.

There are some things to keep in mind. Knocking over a large high-pressure oxygen tank can break the valve and create a dangerous out-of-control rocket, but this would be extremely unlikely with the lightweight tanks mentioned here. Adding oil to an oxygen regulator can cause a fire. Acetylene tanks must be stored and used in a vertical position due to the liquid acetone inside. Small leaks in either tank are not too serious because you can smell the acetylene before easily before it can accumulate dangerous concentrations in an enclosed area and you can breathe oxygen. There are things to learn about how far to open the valves on each tank and the proper lighting sequence.

The kit with small tanks has a handle and can be easily carried for storage. As for using it inside, be aware of one thing: when you light a torch, you turn on and light the acetylene first. Acetylene by itself burns with an extremely smoky flame that will actually put streamers of black carbon filaments in the air - this could be messy as these filaments settle. The flame becomes very clean when the oxygen is added.

JKJ

Re: Torch selection

#9

Re: Torch selection

Stuart Johnson

>There was a well televised news event in Dallas a couple months ago when a large company near downtown had a fire at their tank warehouse. Tanks were going off like bombs and others flying up and over the highway overpass.

Re: Torch selection

#10

Re: Torch selection

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>For bending steel, you can jury rig a forge and use charcoal. Use fire brick or other nonflammable material to contain the charcoal. Run an old steel or iron pipe with the end under the charcoal pile. Get the charcoal burning and then blow air from the exhaust on your shop vac into the pipe. Instant forge! You may have to play around with the amount of air you let blow through the pipe. Charcoal is pretty inexpensive and most of us have the other stuff laying around. A large coffee can full of charcoal was enough for the 1/2" steel rod I was bending.

Re: Torch selection

#11

Re: Torch selection

Mark Wollschlager

>Thanks for the replies.

I went down to HD today and looked around.

They don't carry anything but the bernzomatic line.

The bottles are a bit pricey. The MAPP and oxygen were the same price.

I might take a welding class before spending the money on a small gas welding rig.

Those are not cheap either.

Its been 30 years or so since I operated one of those.

The charcoal idea is good for heating and bending. Good price too.

My little mini torch will continue to fill the bill for a while longer.

Mark.

Re: Torch selection

#12

Re: Torch selection

Dale Johnson

>rather than the big box stuff, check out a jewelry supply, dedicated plumbers supply or a welding supply and look for an acetylene/air torch. smith makes a good set that comes with multiple tips for different jobs. the bigger the job, the bigger the tip. these can be set up on a b or mc sized acetylene cylinder that you can get refilled. with these you can silver solder a bezel on a ring up to bending 1" stock. a night class would be a very good choice.