Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Who would have figured

Posts

Who would have figured

#1

Who would have figured

Ron in Drums PA

>A McNaughton Coring system is easier to use on my old 1236 than my new 3520.

Ok, so the blank was 17", and I did have the 3520 in the low setting, but I still stalled the 3520 a fews times. I feel like I was in a boxing match after coring three blanks.

Re: Who would have figured

#2

Re: Who would have figured

Brodie Brickey

>Ron,

Are you using the taller post? The 3520 requires a longer post due to its 20" swing. I had a lot of problems with the McNaughton until I was able to bring the tip up to center.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Who would have figured

#3

Re: I had to modify the tool post...

Allen Neighbors

>on mine, Brodie, to get the tip at center. The way it was built, it was either too high or too low. But it works well now.

Re: Who would have figured

#4

I had the same problem...

Jack Savona

>...but mine worked well.

Christened my new 3520 this afternoon and used the McNaughton. Post was too short to get the cutting tip up to center. I had to put the tool post tightening bolt all the way in and set the McNaughton post on the top of the bolt. Perfect level for coring. Post was a tiny bit jiggly, but under load steadied out. Wow, was it easy...and quick...with the lathe on low about 600rpm. Squirted in soapy water to keep it cool and keep the sawdust slurry flowing. Piece o' cake.

However, I would like to get a taller post. Anybody have a creative idea?

Re: Who would have figured

#5

Re: Depends... on how high...

Allen Neighbors

>you need to raise it. You might take it to a good welder, and have him cut the post down low and weld in an extension, so you'll still have the upper end of it as it came from the factory. Just a suggestion... maybe a better one will come along...

Re: Who would have figured

#6

Re: Who would have figured

Ron in Drums PA

>Hi Brodie

Yes, I used the taller post. When I ordered the 3520 I asked CSUSA if the McNaughton I have would work, they threw in the taller post for me.

Re: Who would have figured

#7

Re: Who would have figured

Fog Tanner

>I have cored a number of 22-23" blanks on my Vic 300 and know what you mean. I could only core about 12"-13" on my 16" Delta.

I keep the belt a little bit looser than normal when I core. It is in low range and the RPM is half way between the high and low. I was told this is where the motor makes the most power and it works so far - works out to about 600-800 rpm depeneding on which lathe I use.

While I did not "stall" the lathe, I have stopped the piece a couple of times - reason for the loose belt, no bent tools. After looking closely I noticed that I had used the wrong knife for the size I was trying to cut. I was able to make it work by opening the kerf up to about twice the width. I also had been using the square cut blades, even after a day with Mike Mahoney. After the second time of stopping, I reground the tool like Mike does and that seemed to cure the problems. I also found that I needed to clean the blades fairly regularly and use Pam to lube the knife and tool rest. This helps keep the knives moving freely.

Also on some woods like Mesquite, when you get to the point in the cut where you are "going around the bend" - the wood will want to pull the knife into the cut too quickly and cause a stall or twisted blade. At this point I am typically pulling back in the handle and not pushing. I have known a couple of guys who twisted their blades up when they didn't pull back. They also kept their belts tight too.

I have since bought the micro or smaller blades which is for the 10" and under size. These are shorter knives and will fit in the smaller radius. You can also get a few more bowls with them if you like the 3"-4" size.

Fog

Re: Who would have figured

#8

Re: Who would have figured

Ron in Drums PA

>Thanks Fog

After reading your text I think my problem may have been going to slow. With the 1236 I always cored at the bottom speed and thought that I might be spinning to fast.

I like the idea of keeping the belt loose, I'm going to do that from now on.

I have the standard and the mini set of blades also and have cored small bowls just because I could.

I lube the blades and rest with a candle stick.

Thanks again for the advice