Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT: Post Christmas rant

Posts

OT: Post Christmas rant

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: Post Christmas rant

steve antonucci

>I have a lot of topics that surround Christmas that really get me riled up, but I'm going to focus on just one: gift cards.

For starters, I think a gift card says "I didn't know what to get you, and this is almost like getting cash". My wife enrolls in one of those credit card programs where they rebate some of the interest to you in awards at the end of the year. This year, I got a gift card to Orvis.

I mentioned that it's almost like cash, because you can buy anything you want FROM ORVIS. Apparently, the participants change every year, and Home Depot wasn't playing this year. I can always spend money at HD, and it doesn't really need to be "sexy" (paint, wall board, etc...)

So I start paging through the Orvis catalog, and they sell some really nice stuff. Stuff that I don't want or need, but it's nice stuff. She tells me that she thought I might want the National Park atlas (trail maps to 70 park, leather bound) for my hiking, and I remind her that I bought a mini deck of cards to cut down on weight.

I figure that with Orvis' reputation for outdoorsmen and that lifestyle, I shouldn't have any issues finding something. Well, I eventually did (travel Scrabble set, and a coffee table book), but it wasn't easy. They are both nice things, but neither was on my list to Santa (I really wanted a peavy- do you think they sell them in the Orvis catalog? Nope...)

My final AARARRGGGH moment comes when I realize that 10% of my gift is going to the USPS to ship it to me. Since there are no Orvis stores for me to walk into (Unless I drive into Manhattan -$10 gas, $40 parking, and $6 tolls and 4 hours of my life), I had to buy online. I'm a hands on guy. I like to touch things to make sure I really want them, and I've been robbed of the opportunity "to shop"...

:-)

Next year, I'm going to be sure to audit the list of approved vendors for the rewards. I'll check off two or three so that there's still some surprises, but my online experience will result in tools!

Steven

P.S. My wife bought herself an Ipod. I was going to get it for her, but she had already wrapped it in November. I made her wait until Christmas to use it. :-)

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#2

We solved the problem

Stuart Johnson

>years ago. My wife and I never make major purchases for each other. Instead we will give the other a web site, item number and user ID if we have one. We will normally make a few small stocking stuffer purchases but that is it. If we want to make a purchase for much over $20 as a surprise it will be a card with a photo of the item.

Each year I am reminded of a lady at a sewing club my wife used to belong to. She had wanted a certain sewing machine for several years but they couldn't afford it. Her husband received an unexpected Christmas bonus so he bought her a new sewing machine. He bought the top of the line Janome that had all of the current bells and whistles. A fine machine but unfortunately she had her heart set on a different brand. She didn't feel she could exchange it because he was so proud of his purchase but she grew to hate the machine and eventually dropped out of the sewing group.

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#3

ditto, sort of

Mike Schwing from Md.

>We give each other lists. We make them much bigger lists than we could expect to have filled, and that way we don't know exactly which things on the list we'll find under the tree. It works great - we know that we will be getting things we want, but not exactly which ones.

Mrs. Schwingding, however, actually prefers gift cards. She hordes them like they're chocolate (something else she loves). I stuff her christmas stocking with small dollar value gift cards from places she frequents - starbucks, panera, target, subway, etc..

Me, I think I'd like a UPS gift card.

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#4

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

Ron in Drums PA

>Teenagers are so hard to buy for so we gave our nieces and nephews Visa gift cards, they can be used anywhere.

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#5

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I give my girls cash (both in college) and there boyfriends a card for Red Lobster. This way they have to take the girls out for dinner.

We don't make a deal that so much money has to be spent at Christmas, I bought my wife diamond ear rings and that's it. I did get a $25 HD card and a tee shirt. Now she'll see a new lathe in a week or two ;)

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#6

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

Don in Central Illinois

>Wow, you can get a lathe at HD with a $25 gift card and a tee shirt? Send me the address of the HD store and I'll get one too.

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#7

Steven Antonucci

I want to know where you get $25 diamonds :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#8

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>My rant is about people who complain about gifts-- It is a gift, not a debt paid. So much for the spirit of Christmas-BAH HUMBUG !!!

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#9

Steven Antonucci

I guess that's what makes us different?

steve antonucci

>I'd rather get nothing from someone than "the wrong thing". It's not the gift, it's the thought that counts. Not knowing what kinds of things might be a good fit and wasting the money to say you "gave" seems like the bigger of two evils to me.

You can nod appreciatively at the pink bunny suit your aunt knit you ("A Chistmas Story"), but I'm going to try to stop it from happening twice.

Steve

P.S. Also got a Nova Chuck and a sleeping bag which were "good" gifts without issue and would have been more than enough... don't get me started on balancing out the $$$ on everyone!

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#10

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>It's going to be a old metal lathe that I'll turn into a CNC. It's not hard to do but does take a little time and the total cost is only 3 - 3,500.

Hopefully this lathe will be the starting point.

http://www.hgrindustrialsurplus.com/search-products/product-detail.aspx?id=20-928-007&searchtable=1&sortExpression=wbprice&SortASC=Yes&pageSize=50¤tPageIndex=0

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#11

Is someone FORCING you to use the gift card?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It is just like any other gift. If you don't want it, don't use it. Just toss it in the circular file!

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#12

You know what....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Reading this just ruined my day. If somebody had this sort of reaction to something I gave them, they'd never see another anything from me again that's for sure. I can't believe I'm even responding to this?

I have a feeling I know what you're getting next year. A friggin' bag of coal!

What a downer post.

Jennifer :(

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#13

Re: You know what....

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Jennifer I would have to agree. I should have stopped at the top.

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#14

Steven Antonucci

It's $100 gone.

steve antonucci

>If it had been a gift, it could be returned with a receipt. I would have rather that she took the giftcard out for herself to a place that she enjoyed than wasting it on me.

Steve

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#15

Steven Antonucci

Would you rather give it to charity?

steve antonucci

>Or would you bandsaw it?

Hmm?

Steve

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#16

Re: You know what....

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>"I have a feeling I know what you're getting next year. A friggin' bag of coal!" -------Or maybe a bag of something that doesn't smell as good as coal-------

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#17

Re: You know what....

Stuart Johnson

>I'm just old fashioned enough that I think a gift card is just another way to say "I don't care enough to be bothered to go shopping and find the right gift".

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#18

What an ungrateful, selfish attitude!

Fred

>It puzzles me how someone could so arrogantly proclaim victimization by receiving any gift � whether it is a gift-card or a head of lettuce.

Could you really have such selfish distain for the feelings of others, who so generously gave you anything, to object to the kindness and thought?

Lord Help Us � are we such an ailing society that we even give credence to this garbage?

You really need to seek help elsewhere, antonNUTci. This forum is not the appropriate place your pathology!

And please, spare us from your expected tantrum from this response ... take a deep breath and just go sit somewhere in silence and THINK about someone other than yourself ... perhaps someone who that gift-card would have brought such joy to.

Fred

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#19

Bags of Coal... I'm taking orders

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>On our yearly trip to Man, WV I have a great supply of washed coal.

Place your order NOW and beat the Christmas rush for next year.

They make great stocking stuffers! Get a bag for all your friends or get one big lump for they special someone in your life.

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#20

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I probably shouldn't even continue this stupid thread, but to me the spirit of Christmas is supposed to be about the giving, not the receiving.

We didn't celebrate Christmas this year because of the loss of our son last year. It still hurts too much. I would have been pleased and proud to have received anything from him this year, even if it was a gift card. I would honestly give everything I have in this world just to have him back.

I'm sorry Steve, but you should be glad that you have someone who loves you enough to give you a gift card, even if it doesn't meet your standards for appropriate Christmas gifting.

Gary

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#21

Steven Antonucci

My original message (thanks for getting it)

steve antonucci

>

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#22

Steven Antonucci

With the price of oil, you'll do well!

steve antonucci

>

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#23

AMEN, Gary

WF Railey

>I would have been so honored to receive a gift-card from my beloved wife, may she rest in peace.

Such a sick man and such a sick society that enables this behavior!

Thank God my daughter didn't marry such an adolescent.

Bill

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#24

Steven Antonucci

Sorry that it's a painful time of year for you

steve antonucci

>I lost my grandfather in 1978, 2 weeks before Christmas, and I've been somewhat of a humbug ever since. He raised me until I was 12, and was my first exposure to man's mortality. I've stood in the cemetary while the Marine Corps representative presented my Grandmother with his flag, and listened to the Priest talk about sin and Heaven. Neither one brought me comfort.

I count my "blessings" (do atheists have "blessings"-hmm?) every day, and I want for very little. I hate the commercialization of the season- even thought there is no Christ in my Christmas- I still miss a simpler time. My indignation around the whole topic comes from "more and bigger every year" as a mantra, which I think is actually the source of my original post.

Read Stu's post to get what I was aiming for- the fact that sometimes people give because they feel they have to give- even if they don't really know the people well enough to pick a present. By giving money, or even worse, a gift card, I think you say "here's something that requires almost no thought, but I checked you off the list".

My wife did get me things that I asked for, and a few well thought out surprises- and my intent was not to belittle her. I also got 2 other gift cards to two other stores, and I would have happily had that money spent on my kids or given to charity.

Hope you can keep your chin up at least a little bit.

Steven

Re: OT: Post Christmas rant

#25

Steven Antonucci

Um, sure Fred. Whatever.

steve antonucci

>