Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Spinning Tops

Posts

Spinning Tops

#1

Spinning Tops

Ron McKinley

>The challenge for this month in our Inland Woodturners is spinning tops�a spin-off. Like an Old West Shoot-out! The one that spins the longest wins.

What's the secret to a good spinner? We're limited to 3" in diameter so I suspect mass and weight are important. Must be all wood, no metal or anything else allowed.

I made two this afternoon from box elder scraps (a light wood) and the prettiest and most elegant is a rather poor spinner. I made another from what was left from that one and it's a great spinner. It is much smaller, has a tapered handle from the base to the tip. It has a few gouges and tool marks that I couldn't get out since I was working extremely close to the chuck. Obviously finish isn't an attribute of a good spinner.

So what is the secret? When you answer please whisper as my competition may be listening. GRIN Merry Christmas to all and thanks....Ron

Re: Spinning Tops

#2

can you have a metal tip?

Wayne

>about 4 years ago I got a wild hair and made about 40 tops that I sold on Ebay. They sold fairly well but I didn't get rid of them all. Made them up to 6" dia. The ones that were about 3" dia. spun the best but they hade metal tips. Don't think that a wodden tip would last long. How about making replaceable wooden tips that are made out of different colored wood, just the drag on a wodden tip will really cut down on the time spinning.


img

Re: Spinning Tops

#3

Re: Spinning Tops

Jerry Glaser

>The best way to make a top that is going to spin the longest is to concentrate as much of the mass as is feasible at the rim. Don't make the mistake of tapering the body of the top from a fat middle to a thin rim. In a flywheel the mass is always concentrated at the rim.

Re: Spinning Tops

#4

What Jerry said plus

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>keep the mass as close to the table as possible. The stem should only be long enough to spin the top. The denser the wood the better. When you turn the top crank the speed all the way up. Take light cuts on the stem. Pushing too hard will make the top spin excentric.

I have only turned a couple hundred so I am still learning.

Terry

Re: Spinning Tops

#5

Re: can you have a metal tip?

Ron McKinley

>No metal tips are allowed and no strings. These have to be spun between the fingertips......Ron

Re: Spinning Tops

#6

Re: What Jerry said plus

Ron McKinley

>Thanks Terry and Jerry. That makes sense to me......Ron

Re: Spinning Tops

#7

Steven Antonucci

echoing some thoughts-

steve antonucci

>I've made them in a few shapes and sizes, and the winners all are flat, thin disks with thick rims and sitting low to the table.

My best will spin for 4 minutes, but it's from countertop plastic with a 4" disk. It's really heavy and the spindle is a little thicker because it's spun between palms.

Steven

Re: Spinning Tops

#8

Re: can you have a metal tip?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>> Don't think that a wodden tip would last long.

>How about making replaceable wooden tips

When I made that type of top (throwning tops) I turned tips from nylon and glued them into the tops. Nylon is far kinder to floors.

However, this is not the type of top Ron suggested.

JKJ

Re: Spinning Tops

#9

Re: Spinning Tops

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...what is the secret?

Psst, can you keep a secret? So can I. (Sorry, old joke.)

I've made many hundreds of finger tops and have had some very good spinners, but I've never timed them or tried to analyze. I tend to go for interesting form and pretty wood rather than for long life. Kids of all ages love them. The picture attached below shows some from a few years ago.

(BTW, for those who haven't turned tops, all of mine are turned with the blank in a chuck - turn and finish the body at the end of the blank before turning the handle, support the top with the left hand if necessary to prevent vibration when the handle gets very thin, then part off with the skew and touch up the top of the handle by hand. I usually use a fairly long blank and make three or so from the same blank.)

As for spinning, much depends on the surface - very smooth glassy surface is best. Also, a sharp point decreases friction. The point will last longer if the top is made from hard, dense wood. VERY important is balance - figured wood can have areas of dense and light wood and can cause a wobbly top so bland, boring wood may spin better. Dogwood and hard maple work great, as does ebony and other exotics. Beyond that, I was surprised by the variety of shapes that spun well. One of my best was contrary to expectations - it was made of light weight e.r.cedar, shaped heavy in the center and thin at the rim, but relatively wide for it's height.

Hey, when you meet for the spinoff, challenge the others to a contest spinning them upside down. If no one else is prepared, you may win that one easily. A good inverted spinner has just one additional design requirement: a sharp point on the top of the handle! The length of the handle doesn't seem to matter. (For anyone who hasn't tried it: To spin upside down, hold and twist the top exactly as you would normally, except twist your wrist first so the point is up and the handle is down. Spin as hard as you can and when released, move your hand quickly out of the way and let the top drop to the table.)

JKJ


img

Re: Spinning Tops

#10

Re: echoing some thoughts-

Ron McKinley

>Thanks Steve. They don't have to be pretty or elegant looking--just spin the longest.....Ron

Re: Spinning Tops

#11

Re: Spinning Tops

Ron McKinley

>Great picture John. Gives me some good ideas as to shapes.......Ron

Re: Spinning Tops

#12

more shapes

JohnKJordan in East TN

>

Re: Spinning Tops

#13

oops, more shapes

JohnKJordan in East TN

>(I messed up the picture attachment on the other reply)

In case you are interested, here are a few more old pictures of experiments with shapes.

JKJ


img

Re: Spinning Tops

#14

One last tip

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>If you need to harden the tip you can use super glue. Happy spinning.

Terry

Re: Spinning Tops

#15

Thanks John

Ron McKinley

>

Re: Spinning Tops

#16

Good idea-Thanks

Ron McKinley

>

Re: Spinning Tops

#17

Just what I needed...

Carol in Illinois

>for a little post-Christmas spinning project! Great pics, everyone - especially John - and great tips. Thanks for the inspiration!

Re: Spinning Tops

#18

Re: Spinning Tops *LINK*

charlie belden

>Silicon Valley Woodturners has been having an

annual Tops Night for several years. Attached

is a link to a PDF file with Gary Petretti's

secrets to long spinning tops. Though he

includes metal, a lot of the WHY in his article

is true for all tops. CAUTION: the PDF file

is 4.1 Meg so if you're on dial-up send me an

e-mail and I'll try and cut just that article out

of the whole newsletter.

Basically, you want as much mass as close

to the bottom as possible, the sharpest point

made from the hardest wood you've got. Then

spin it on the flattest, smoothes surface you

can find - making sure that surface is as close

to perfectly horizontal as you can get it. And

the higher the initial rpms the longer the top

will spin so see if you can rig up an electric

drill driver.

We've got club members that really really

really get into the Tops Contest. The club

record is almost 20 minutes!


http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Temp/Newsletters/05-2005.pdf

Re: Spinning Tops

#19

Re: Spinning Tops

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>The club record is almost 20 minutes!

Wow, is that spun by hand or did they use a motor to spin it up?

If there are no limitations on the materials and drive mechanism, my friend Joe could show how he built a little spinning top-like thing that spun for hours before he stopped it. Of course, everyone can make one (ha!): Joe used a magnet levatation device to suspend a "top" in a vacuum chamber. The top hung from a small steel ball bearing which was suspended magnetically by an electromagnet with optical feedback for vertical position. He had tiny magnets embedded in the top and built an electronic magnetic drive system to spin it up real fast. I forget the numbers, but I think it was in the thousands of revs per minute. (so fast that some flew things he spun apart with a loud bang.) With the mag lev, the item floats in mid "air" so there is no contact point. The only friction comes from what few molecules of air remain after vacuuming the chamber and what force the mag lev exerts against the turning of the earth (I don't know the physics of that one). It is a huge task requiring incredibly expensive equipment to achieve ultra-high vacuum so the home version was nothing like the one at work. This toy, BTW, was a home built spin off (pun intended) based on Joe's day job working with magnetically-levitated high speed electric motors. Good clean fun.

Seems like some smart Silicon Valley wizard might like to whip up one of those maglev vacuum top spinning systems!

JKJ

Re: Spinning Tops

#20

Re: Spinning Tops

Ron McKinley

>Hey John. Ask your friend how I can levitate an all wood top. Tell him I would like at least a 20 minute spin time. GRIN ....Ron