Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Solartube in Shop

Posts

Solartube in Shop

#1

Solartube in Shop

Ron McKinley

>Just had a Solartube installed in my shop to light up my turning area. We have 350+ days of sunshine a year here in the Mojave Desert so thought I would save electricity and get better light (daylight).

I don't turn on the 4 (80 watt, 2 tube) overhead ceiling lights anymore. I paid about $260 for it at Lowe's (12" diameter) and HD has two other brands. They seem to come in 8" and 12" sizes. The 12" covers about 300 sq. ft. My handyman installed it for $50.

The photo was a normal shot, handheld and no flash at about 12:45pm today. The light is above me and 3' in front. Looks like it's going to cover my tablesaw and both lathes...Ron


img

Re: Solartube in Shop

#2

Re: Solartube in Shop

georgetroy

>Lights up your Nova real good. It's dark in my shop, windows are just not enough.

Re: Solartube in Shop

#3

Re: Solartube in Shop

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Good idea Ron, natural light is always best but it will never work in Cleveland as we get 30 sunny days a year... our daily forcast is mostly cloudy.

Re: Solartube in Shop

#4

Re: Cloudy?

Ron McKinley

>I couldn't live like that Doug! Come on down to the California desert and get rid of that pallor! GRIN

Re: Solartube in Shop

#5

Congrats

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Ron

I really wanted to install them in my shop when I built it but I ran out of money. Now the attic space has 20" of blown in and I don't want to deal with it. I am looking for a dentist's light for my lathe area.

Re: Solartube in Shop

#6

Thanks Terry

Ron McKinley

>This is my Christmas present to myself. We have a full-moon tonight so I'm going out in a few hours and see how much moonlight it collects. For sure it won't be like walking into a dark shop when the moon is up.......Ron

Re: Solartube in Shop

#7

Re: Solartube in Shop

john lucas

>Ron In the next year my goal is to add a solar collector and possibly the solartube. I have a friend who sells and installs the solar tubes. I plan to build the solar collector myself.

Re: Solartube in Shop

#8

Re: Solartube in Shop

Ron McKinley

>Good for you John! Al Gore would be proud of us! ........Ron

Re: Solartube in Shop

#9

Re: Thanks Terry

John Kyler

>I bet the moon will provide a lot of light!

Re: Solartube in Shop

#10

Re: Solartube in Shop

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Ron,

That is sweet!! I will look into that for my place.

I am... like Doug, in Ohio, but we get 300 days of sunshine a year in Northwest Ohio. :) I wish... but I still think it would be great.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Solartube in Shop

#11

Re: Solartube in Shop

Carole Valentine

>Interesting Ron. I had thought about a tube when I was planning my shop, but was afraid it just would not provide enough light to be really worth while. How is the light mid-morning and mid-afternoon?

Re: Solartube in Shop

#12

diffuse light vs point source

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I'm certainly not trying to rain on your parade (the quality of solar light cannot be beat!), but that light appears quite diffuse. I find (for lathe work) that diffuse light, such as from long fluorescent tubes, makes it harder to see surface irregularities, small scratches, and finish problems since they tend to be lit too evenly. (hiding defects is one reason faces look better in soft light!) Have you used this lighting enough to see if that's a problem? If so, switching on a bright point source inspection light may help.

I do think that light would be fantastic for general tasks. When I worked with a solar lighting research team and we learned that solar lighting was actually better for morale and productivity, at least in an office situation and especially in interior rooms with no windows. One safety concern to be aware of is that sudden changes in lighting, say from moving clouds or even something flying, may startle a worker doing a critical operation with power tools. (Clouds are probably not a big problem in your area!!) The ideal solar lighting system (in our opinion, of course!) uses sensors to monitor the amount of light at the work station and automatically augment with electrical lights as the solar lighting varies.

JKJ

Re: Solartube in Shop

#13

Re: diffuse light vs point source

Ron McKinley

>You're right John. As you can see in the picture I have three task lights (incandescents) around the lathes. The Solartube provides general area lighting to find lathe tools, finishes, rubber gloves, sandpaper, etc. Since I'm also using task lighting a fast-moving cloud wouldn't have much effect......Ron

Re: Solartube in Shop

#14

Re: Solartube in Shop

Ron McKinley

>From shortly after sun rise the light doesn't change much at all during the day until sunset. Right now the sun sets a little early behind the mountains but there's still plenty of sky light for at least a half hour after sunset. Don't know how it's going to work this spring when the trees leaf out but shouldn't affect it much since the nearest tree is about 30 feet from the collector and the collector collects from 360 degrees plus overhead.

Last night with the full moon it was an erie "moon effect" inside the shop.

I have a skylight in a storage shed but it's not like the focused light of the Solartube. You might want to try one in your new shop.

I didn't locate mine where I really wanted it. I had a turbine vent in that location that I wanted to remove since I no longer used it after I added air conditioning.......Ron

Re: Solartube in Shop

#15

Where do I get rain tubes?

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>

Re: Solartube in Shop

#16

Re: Where do I get rain tubes?

Ron McKinley

>Hey Dave! Just leave the top collector and the bottom diffuser off and you've got a very efficient "raintube". When are you coming down this way? ........Ron

Re: Solartube in Shop

#17

They're called downspouts

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>