Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Posts

OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#1

OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Dick Coers

>I've posted a couple of pictures of some boxes I've made on a rose engine modification I've made to a Jet mini lathe. Should I try and patent this thing before selling kits? Or should I just make a little money on the parts and assume it will be a little while before someone knocks it off anyway? Is it really expensive to get a patent? Never came close to doing something like this before. Can you even patent a modification to an existing machine? There are specific new parts and modifications to parts on the lathe. I don't have an idea if this will be something that will sell much anyway. It will get you a true rose engine lathe for less than $400 if you already have the lathe. Any other rose engine lathe is way above that.

You don't HAVE to be one of the Indy crew to answer, I just know those guys are working on a project.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#2

Check you email

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#3

Thanks Ray 

Dick Coers------WebKitFormBoundaryqFOmq51H3saAc+aC

>

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#4

landmines

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Dick,

I'm no indyfester and certainly no expert on patents, but I do hold multiple patents through the organization where I worked before I retired. I would NOT have applied for even one if I had to do it by myself and with my own finances - the expense, the time, and the effort involved is daunting. We had patent lawyers who did the leg work: searched for prior art, prepared and submitted the application, and made revisions when certain claims were denied. Even with experts doing everything right it took several years and multiple revisions before some were awarded. (And the patent team wouldn't even make the effort unless an initial review showed the potential for significant payback.)

The way I understand it you can patent a modification of an existing device or process, but among other things you must show your modification is novel, i.e., something not already known before you invented it). My impression of the whole process is one of a field of landmines, best navigated by a good ($$$) patent lawyer. I suggest contacting one - the initial consultation is often inexpensive or free and he can advise you as to whether your idea is even patentable and give you an idea of the level of effort and cost.

Patents are wonderful when you have something useful and valuable enough that others are willing to pay money to license (the annual checks are nice!) or if the idea is valuable enough to protect from the competition. But even having a patent won't protect you from someone stealing your idea and selling a product. If threats and intimidation don't stop them (the most common method), I understand that recourse through the courts can be astronomically expensive (and there is no guarantee you will even win the case) - would your potential profit loss make it worth it?

JKJ

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#5

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Black Bear

>Hi Dick,

Since you and I work for the same company and I came out of the intellectual property department at company before this assignment, I can probably give you some guidance. Bottom line, the other respondents are right on cost, time and defense of your IP. You would go broke filing and defending if someone else decides to violate your patent, especially if they are bigger ($) than you. Hope to see what you have going when I am back there in January.

Merry Christmas to you and yours,

Greg

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#6

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Likewise, Dick. Waste of money. I started patents on my jigs, spent too much money, and abandoned it. Lawyer was kind enough to point out that patenting is only a position is a court of law in a suit the patent holder brings forth. If the defendent(s) have deeper pockets, they WILL prevail, as their attorneys can suck you dry with delays and continuances, discovery motions and all sorts of legal gymnastics that only lawyers make money at.

Get your product out there and make bucks as long as you can. Your device is attractive to a small portion of the market, probably not big enough to attract the people specializing in knock-offs. Now derivatives are yet another matter and you would really go broke trying to patent every derivative of your idea.

Sorry to rain on your parade, but best to have a cold shower than drained pockets.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#7

Steven Antonucci

A buddy of mine just went through this

steve antonucci

>I don't think it cost him all that much(<$2K), but he did a patent search on his own (he's not a lawyer), and has a substantially large market than woodturners (golfers). He intends to license his invention to Nike or Callaway, and by establishing the patent pending, figures it is worth the investment and will bring credibility if they try to go outside the contract...

BTW- A patent means nothing overseas. China will copy anything it wants to.

Ask yourself the following question- would anyone WANT to mass produce what you offer to sell as their own? Would you be able to catch them and handle the legal process? I'm guessing no, so even if a patent is granted, I doubt it buys you much...

Steven

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Dick, In my opinion, as one who holds several patents, the whole mess isn't worth it. One example, I invented a tree-staking device, which received a utility patent (the good kind). My invention is being marketed world-wide by a major corporation who basically stole my idea. The company bought out my entire stock at a trade show and said they would be in touch....they most certainly were, but not in a good way.

There is no way on earth I could afford to fight a company, with their own legal staff, for even one day, let alone the several years it would take in reality. In this case, the patent, and the expense I went through (10 K), was a worthless waste of time.

Remember, the goal of the US patent office isn't to protect the patent holder....it's to promote innovation. Your patent can be used as the basis for a newer, more comprehensive patent...In that case, your patent isn't worth the paper it's written on.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#9

That's a good summary.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>John's information is good. I've been through the same processes, include the legal defense of the patent and litigation against companies that infringed the patent. (The court said it was infringement.) It is an expensive business.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#10

Re: My experience is with copyrights, ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... closely related to patent law, and the expense of filing and defending is very significant. The question that must be asked is what is the potential return on such an investment, and I doubt that you have a broad enough potential market to make the process viable. Corporations usually prevail with the deep pockets defense, an unfortunate reality in the worlds of law and marketing.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#11

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Russ Fairfield

>Most people have a misconception of what a patent is, and what it can and cannot do. Here are a few thoughts about the topic.

I have no idea what you are doing, but I suspect that your invention isn't something as fundamental as a rose engine, but a simpler way to make a rose engine or similar way to make an ornamental turning.

Secrecy is the most important factor in any new product or design. You need to get it developed and into the market before anyone knows about it. You have already violated this secrecy rule by showing it to the public at Indyfest. You have no idea how many people have seen it or what they will do with it. You have essentially already published your invention. It could be argued that it is already a part of the public domain, and any subsequent patent would be useless.

The most important thing you should have have done was to document, date, and notarize the original concept and everything that went into its design beforde you showed it to the public. Most would-be inventors haven't done this basic proof of their invention. This would establish the date of the concept and could be used to show prior-art if there should ever be litigation against someone who might copy it. To that end, these documents and design drawings can be more important than any patent you or anyone else might hold. A working notebook is best, but even scraps of paper are a valid proof if they are signed, dated, and notarized. If you haven't already done this, it might be too late, and it cannot be documented retroactively.

A patent is not adviseable unless you have a major scientific or technological breakthrough, a product with a market potential that is worth millions, or a process that is worth millions to a manufacturer. Anything less is not worth the cost of defending the patent. There is no Patent Police to prevent people from copying your invention. It is up to you to find them and prosecute your claim in court. And here is where that prior-art documentation is important.

You could invest a couple thousand to get the process started and establish the right to label your product as "Patent Pending", but this is only there to scare away the little guy who is not the problem, while doing nothing to discourage the big guy who could be the problem.

Or you could pursue a patent for the vanity of having your name on a patent diocument, and for a lot of people, that is a valid reason for having a patent .

As always, your best bet is to put your efforts into making and selling as many of them as possible before anyone else starts making them, and hope that whoever does that is an ethical person who will offer to reward you for your efforts. That does happen a lot in this world, and having that prior-art documentation is a good way to start a conversation with the other person.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#12

Legal Advice

Stuart Johnson

>You are getting a lot of input but for one I would be a little worried about hanging my hat on some of the what sound like legal opinions. I doubt if any lawyer is going to give you free service on a woodturning board.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#13

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>We are such a small group you need to ask yourself

How many can you sell, say in a year? Be honest.

How much will it cost to bring to market including the patent? Then add some extra for unexpected expenses.

How much profit on each?

How many will you have to sell to pay for the patent?

Don't forget about taxes you have to pay.

You have a rough dollar amount... NOW figure the time you will spend talking to people about the product, answering email, phone calls, bookkeeping and don't forget the time to pack it and drive to the post office. Divide all the hours into your profit... say no more.

IMO - Do it because it's enjoyable

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#14

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Russ Fairfield

>Of course all free advice is worth what you paid for it, and there are a lot of attorneys whose advise will have the same value. Of course the final word will have to be that of an experienced patent attorney. But they will cost a lot of money, and the clock starts at, "Hello, please have a seat."

You are looking for advice on whether you should take that seat or not. All that has been said here are shared experiences that can make you aware of some of questions you will have to answer for yourself and the attorney, and some of the homework you will need before seeking the advice of an attorney and taking that seat that will cost you $200 an hour to sit in.

This is not a decision to be taken lightly. A serious patent application is a very expensive and time consuming process.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#15

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Pat Riley in SLC

>The patent process does not have to be ultra-expensive. It can be done relatively inexpensively if you want to do a lot of the work yourself. There are quite a few books etc. on how to do it. (by relatively inexpensive I mean 3 or 4 grand. - The corporate patents I hold cost tons more.)

My hesitance with you getting a patent is if it would ever even be granted. A quick patent search on the rose engine showed the first patent issued in 1882 and literally hundreds of patented refinements and improvements in the following 100 years.

Your idea may be novel, but doing all that work and getting denied would not be much fun. In the rose engine arena, your idea may not be so novel once you research it. I do know this - If it is a brand new concept, you will be able to get a patent on it. If it is a device to implement an existing concept that is already patented, you will most likely be denied.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#16

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>I too have a patent through a previous employer. It was for a concept in manufacturing and it really stirred the long-wall coal mining industry when it was introduced. The patent was applied for in many nations the last of which I signed was for China. Keep in mind that this was a patent for a new manufacturing method combining an old part and an old process. Made the company I was working for alot of money but their legal team also spent alot of money defending against anyone elso marketing the process. While later working for a carbide cutting tool company as a field rep, I met inventors that tried the copyright avenue (less out of pocket, better protection under the law but still required big bucks to fight of an infringment) and inventors that successfully patented their ideas.

If you are serious about seeking a patent you will need to spend a chunk of change talking to lawyers about how to proceed efficiently.

Your best course of action may be to find a smaller company that specializes in woodworking equipment and enter into a disclosure agreement where you demonstrate your invention and if they are interested, they produce and market the conversion and you receive royalties or an upfront buyout of your rights.

Good luck.

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#17

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

Dick Coers

>Thanks for all the responses everyone. Most of you are confirming what I was thinking. Just sell your kit, it's not the 100 mpg carburetor!! It looks like it will be a fun toy to play with. Thanks again!

Re: OT? patent question for Indyfest crew, Jerry?

#18

Re: landmines

Jerry Whitaker

>How about getting with Jet and see if they will work a deal with you for royalties and let them do all the other stuff. They already have lawyers etc. in place.