roughing gouge
Steve ponch
>Is it acceptable to use a roughing gouge on a bowl?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
roughing gouge
Steve ponch
>Is it acceptable to use a roughing gouge on a bowl?
Re: roughing gouge
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I would never use a roughing on a bowl. I did once many years ago -- I survived but the gouge didn't.
Use a bowl gouge. It is designed for the task.
Re: roughing gouge
john lucas
>Steve An expert can use a rough out gouge on a bowl although most will tell you that a bowl gouge is better. That's why they were developed. The old guys did turn bowls with rough out gouges and spindle gouges but they had many years of experience. Back in the 70's or so the guys who turned mostly bowls developed the bowl gouge. This was a tool designed specifically to handle the rigors of bowl turning.
A new turner should not use the rough out gouge for bowl turning. It is too easy to get a catch and the rough out gouge can't handle it. The tang will be bent or break and ruin the tool. That also assumes that you don't get hurt. The rough out gouge was designed for spindle turning.
Re: roughing gouge
Steve ponch
>Thanks, Brian and John, I heard it, but now I understand it. You guys are a saint to new turners. I learn every day from you. Thanks for sharing.
Re: roughing gouge
Dick Hines
>Not unless you have good insurance. Get a bowl gouge
Re: roughing gouge
Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner
>AS NEW TURNER DO NOT DO IT !!
Now after many years I use one on the outside of large pieces. I extend it max about 1 " over the tool rest and I hold the tool handle with the tang in my hand. If you try to hold it in a normal manner with your hand on the end of the tool it will bend where the tang and handle meet and bad catch.
Good turning and be safe, Merry Christmas
Bill in CG, AZ.
Re: roughing gouge
Peter Charles Fagg (UK)
>Like Bill Hale, I use a roughing gouge ONLY for reducing the immediate outside of the log.
I would NEVER try to use it internally because the catch can be extremely vicious due to the raised shape.
Regards, Peter.
Re: roughing gouge
john lucas
>Peter I think the rough outside is where the beginners have the most problems. It's easy to hit that one high point that sticks out wham, bent gouge. I use a 5/8" bowl gouge for those kinds of things. It would be hard to bend that 5/8" shaft. The wings are also ground back which helps also.
Re: roughing gouge
Glenn Hodges, Nashville, GA
>No, no, no, no, no, no, and no