Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Using a skew on larger diameter work

Posts

Using a skew on larger diameter work

#1

Using a skew on larger diameter work

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I have a question about using a skew on larger diameter work:

I don't have many problems using a skew on small things like pens or 2" diameter spindles. However, when I try to smooth the surface of a 5" diameter piece (eg. the base of the face vase in my previous question), I just can not seem to find an angle or tool rest height that lets me use a skew without catching.

Seems like as the diameter of the work increases I should have to either drop the skew handle very low (ie. lower the toolrest well below the centreline of the work - lower than my toolrest will go), or raise the toolrest quite high, but move it very far from the centreline of the lathe so that the skew has a huge overhang.

Any tips for me? Thanks,


Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#2

JL

Re: Alan Lacer!

JL

>Get his videos. They show it all. Failing that, another skew master is Nick Cook.

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#3

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Steve -- I'd be inclined to tell you to raise the toolrest until you find a comfortable level, but not to any extreme. I do a fair amount of stuff that's 4-1/2" or 5-1/2" true diameter, and it seems to me that the toolrest is above center maybe 1/2 - 3/4" -- I do this on someone else's lathe that's 20 miles away at the moment so I can't check it for you, but I'm pretty sure that's what works for me. I know I haven't changed the height for ages.

I do keep the toolrest close to the work, probably not more than an inch and usually less. This seems to give me better control.

I would say that it has taken me a long time to get to my present level of skills, so don't be discouraged. Just keep at it and after a while you'll get the feel of it. Working with a skew (and many other tools, for that matter) is kind of like driving in slick snow -- avoiding a skid - or catch - is largely a matter of finesse acquired through practice.

Best wishes for the holidays...

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#4

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

john lucas

>I think Chuck is right. I raise the toolrest above center line when using the skew and have to raise it higher with large work. I usually have the skew cutting at about 11 oclock if you view it from the end. With a spindle gouge I'm usually cutting at about 10 oclock. Actually by 10 oclock I'm in bed. :)

The biggest problem with large diameter work is that it makes the skew want to take a larger bite. Not deeper, that is controlled by the bevel but since the diameter of the work is larger you tend to cut with more of the cutting edge. This wants to pull the skew into the piece so you have to work at keeping it on the bevel and keeping the cut below the center line on the cutting edge.

I have a 2 1/2" skew and thought it would be good on large diameter work. I find that I can control the 1 1/4" skew better. I think it's because I'm taking off about a 1/4" shaving with the little skew and about 1/2" or more with the big skew.

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#5

I cheat! Use a roughing gouge at 45�

adrien

>

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#6

I used a Lacer skew and a ...

Ed Moore

>Thompson skew to turn a cylinder from the piece you see on the lathe in the picture. I started with a spindle roughing gouge and then switched to the skews. By raising the toolrest and keeping my eye on the presentation of the skew it worked great. Smooth and exact.

Ed


img

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#7

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

JohnKJordan in East TN

>GolfSteve,

Several things I found out (by trial and error!) about skews on larger work.

One, for me, a larger skew works better. It's all relative. As the diameter of the work increases, the curvature of the surface at the tangent becomes flatter relative to the cutting edge of the skew, the smaller the skew the worse. Put a flat edge against a flat moving surface and an extremely small change in the tool presentation puts the point into the wood: bang. Another way I look at it, a 1/2" skew on a 2" diameter piece is geometrically equivalent to a 1" skew on a 4" diameter piece.

Two, I find that the angle of the grind makes a difference - the angle with the flat side of the tool (the cutting/bevel angle), not the skew angle. A slightly larger angle (less of a knife edge) cuts less aggressively but also takes less of a bite and catches less agressively. Going the other way, I sharpened one skew with a much smaller angle (more like a knife edge) and while it cuts more easily, I have to pay more attention to stay in control.

Three, it seems to me that putting a slight curve on the edge helps. My theory is a curve between the work and the tool minimizes the contact area and catches (as in point One above). Cutting into a large diameter piece (relatively flat work surface) with a curved tool edge is somewhat similar to cutting into smaller diameter piece (a more curved work surface) with a straighter tool edge. Note that some people grind a curve on all their skews. However, I prefer a straight edge for detail work.

So when I have a large diameter piece, I reach for one skew on which I've ground a curved edge with a steeper angle. Works for me.

JKJ

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#8

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

john lucas

>John Maybe you can clear this up for me. I hear this quite often when discussing curved edge vs straight edge. When I cutting with a 1" skew with the cutting edge at about 45 degrees on 2" work I'm taking a shaving about 1/8" to 3/16" unless I'm really pushing it. With a curved edge skew I can't imagine it would be more than a few thousandth of an inch longer.

If the skew had a curved edge that resembled a fingernail grind I could see this might introduce a longer cut but when we are talking about the kind of grind that Alan lacer puts on his skews there's a miniscule difference if any at all.

I've also heard that a skew with a curved tip puts the long point further from the work (when cutting short point down). Unless your skew is hour glass shaped the edge is actually straight if you lay the bevel on a piece of glass. If this is the case then the tip is just as close as the straight skew only further back.

Am I totally wrong on this? It's early so my brain might not be in gear and even if it is the gears are worn, I can shift to reverse with no clutch.

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#9

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

Darrell Feltmate

>Try using a straight chisel instead of a skew. The cut is the same but the angle of approach is different. It makes a great planing tool.

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#10

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>With a curved edge skew I can't imagine it would be

>more than a few thousandth of an inch longer

John,

Actually, (if I understand you correctly) all other conditions being the same, it seems to me the shaving from a curved skew would be shorter than those from a straight skew, although perhaps immeasurably shorter.

I'm imagining an extrapolation of pieces with increasing diameter until the diameter is so large that the rotating surface is essentially flat where it meets the tool edge. In this imaginary case, the shaving from a flat skew edge will be as wide as the skew chisel (and impossible to control by hand!)

Now imagine using a curved skew on the same "flat" rotating surface - the leading edge of the curve would cut a shaving much shorter than the length of the sharpened edge. Since both the long and short points are swept back, they will be raised a bit off the surface due to the required "clearance angle" needed to sever the wood fibers - see below. (This is described nicely in the diagram and text on page 33 of Darlow's book Fundamentals of Woodturning). Seems to me this has to make a narrower shaving on a curved surface than you would get from straight ground skew.

BTW, the Darlow book is by far the best resource I've come across to explain the mechanics of cutting and scraping. It has an excellent section on the skew.

>I've also heard that a skew with a curved tip

>puts the long point further from the work.

>...the edge is actually straight if you lay

>the bevel on a piece of glass. If this is the

>case then the tip is just as close as the

>straight skew only further back.

I can't picture it. I went out just now and checked my curved skew and even with the bevel at the center laying flat on the bandsaw table, the tips were a bit off the surface. I tried creating a model in my 3D software with the same result. Attached below are two renderings, one of a curved skew with the center of the bevel flat on the surface (no clearance angle), and the other with 5 degrees of clearance angle. Or did I misunderstand what you meant?

For a straight ground skew chisel, if you lift the handle to create a clearance angle from the flat glass surface, both points of the skew will still remain in contact with the surface*. For a curved grind however, lifting the handle to achieve some clearance angle will raise the swept-back points even more. If I'm thinking correctly, the additional distance raised is the sine of the clearance angle times the distance the point has been ground back from the tangent at the contact point.

(*This is what I believe causes decreasing stability with a straight grind skew of fixed size when used on workpieces with larger and larger diameter. The slightest wobble in controlling the skew can bring the long point dangerously close to digging in.)

OK, now I think I've burned out MY clutch!

JKJ


img

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#11

Nice train of thougth John

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>But maybe there are other solutions, I use my skew at almost 90 degrees to the axis of the points and lead with the heel (short point) of the skew cutting, the tool rest higher than the axis and the tip skew handle a little lower, it works very well for me, as the heel is cutting, the long point is always away from the work, and there is no tendency to dig in. This is how I was taught by my mentor, the local HS Industrial arts teacher.

Jorge

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#12

Re: Nice train of thougth John

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>lead with the heel (short point) of the skew cutting...

If I understand you correctly (I have no idea what "and the tip skew handle a little lower" means), I often do the same, cutting by leading with the short point, especially when I encounter tricky grain, for example with very thin pieces and/or wood with hard and soft areas that tend to make the skew bounce around. This does make for a slower cut at times.

One thing should be pointed out to those who might shy away from the skew because of it's reputation. When I started turning I had several people tell me to stay far away from the evil skew, it was out to get you. But I was determined to learn to use it even if it try to bite me. Guess what, after practicing the exercises suggested in several books (Raffan, Darlow, etc) and experiencing a few spectacular catches, I got the hang of it and the skew is now my favorite tool. (I like a 1/2" non-curved, concave ground skew the best.) These days I have to work hard to get a catch.

JKJ

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#13

Typo, where is the edit???

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Sorry John, I wish we had an edit function here

what I said "and the tip skew handle a little lower" was meant to say and the tip of the skew handle a little lower than than axis of the points.

I was lucky I signed up for a woodwork class at the HS a few years back, I had no project in mind and nobody was using the lathe, so I gave it a try... 20 hours of skew, skew and nothing but skew. I did have tons of catches but now I love it, work mostly with a 3/4" with straight edge and now with a 1" from Doug Thompson that cuts great.

I agree, the bad rap keeps fellows away from a fine tool.

Jorge

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#14

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

john lucas

>Thanks John. I don't own a curved skew anymore so I couldn't actually go out and look. It just seemed to me mentally that you were ginding the edge in the same plane when on the grinder. I think I can see how the ends of the grind might be at a different point on the hollow grind and therefore not sit flat on the glass.

I did make a curved edge skew once and couldn't tell any difference in cutting action for me other than I couldn't see the toe as well when cutting with the toe down on some cuts and it was harder for me to sharpen than a straight edge.

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#15

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

Russ Fairfield

>In my opinion, and for what that is worth, there may be better alternatives for the larger diameter than our normal skew chisels. Don't get hung-up on using the skew. There may be better ways to do it.

I also think you are asking the wrong question when you ask about toolrest height. Regardless of what tool you use, always raise the toolrest to support the approach angle of the tool. Never adjust the tool approach into the wood to suit some predetermined toolrest height.

We have already defined the problems with getting the corners of the skew out of the wood. The only way that I know how to use a skew on very large diameters is to use an appropriately larger skew, the biggest available, and even that might not be big enough. Anything less is like trying to kill an elephant with a BB gun. All you will suceed in doing is getting him mad.

I have a couple skews that are 3" and 4" wide and made from truck springs, and they are used for turning 12" to 18" diameters. I would use the wide skew with a straight edge for turning large diameter pieces, and the same large skew with a curved edge to get the corners out of the way on very large diameters.

The bigger problem might be that the toolrest isn't strong enough to support the forces of cutting large diameters with large tools.

A better alternative for most of us would be a large roughing gouge that has been ground with a 30-degree bevel, as measured between the bevel and the bottom of the flute. When held and used at an angle like that of a skew, it will leave a respectable surface. It might be a couple grades of sandpaper less than that of the skew surface, but it is a lot easier to use, and the cutting forces are more controllable.

I wonder why nobody has suggested using a Bowl gouge on the larger diameter spindle turning. It does a very good job, but again, it might require a couple grades coarser with the sandpaper.

And don't forget the lowly scraper. It can be the better alternative. A heavy scraper with a good burr and held in the 45-degree shear scraping position will leave a very good surface with a minumum of tear-out.

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#16

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>Actually, the more I think about it the more I agree with Russ (is the ceiling falling in?? :-) ) the last time I turned a column I used a 1/2" Oland for the roughing and the finishing. That long bevel and the mass of the cutting tip really help.


Around the Woods

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

#17

Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...It just seemed to me mentally that you were ginding

>the edge in the same plane when on the grinder. I think

>I can see how the ends of the grind might be at a

>different point on the hollow grind

I've thought about this more - as long as the chisel has two bevels, I think it would be impossible to grind a curved edge such that one bevel could sit flat on the glass. Hollow or flat grind would make no difference.

JKJ