Re: Using a skew on larger diameter work
JohnKJordan in East TN
>>With a curved edge skew I can't imagine it would be
>more than a few thousandth of an inch longer
John,
Actually, (if I understand you correctly) all other conditions being the same, it seems to me the shaving from a curved skew would be shorter than those from a straight skew, although perhaps immeasurably shorter.
I'm imagining an extrapolation of pieces with increasing diameter until the diameter is so large that the rotating surface is essentially flat where it meets the tool edge. In this imaginary case, the shaving from a flat skew edge will be as wide as the skew chisel (and impossible to control by hand!)
Now imagine using a curved skew on the same "flat" rotating surface - the leading edge of the curve would cut a shaving much shorter than the length of the sharpened edge. Since both the long and short points are swept back, they will be raised a bit off the surface due to the required "clearance angle" needed to sever the wood fibers - see below. (This is described nicely in the diagram and text on page 33 of Darlow's book Fundamentals of Woodturning). Seems to me this has to make a narrower shaving on a curved surface than you would get from straight ground skew.
BTW, the Darlow book is by far the best resource I've come across to explain the mechanics of cutting and scraping. It has an excellent section on the skew.
>I've also heard that a skew with a curved tip
>puts the long point further from the work.
>...the edge is actually straight if you lay
>the bevel on a piece of glass. If this is the
>case then the tip is just as close as the
>straight skew only further back.
I can't picture it. I went out just now and checked my curved skew and even with the bevel at the center laying flat on the bandsaw table, the tips were a bit off the surface. I tried creating a model in my 3D software with the same result. Attached below are two renderings, one of a curved skew with the center of the bevel flat on the surface (no clearance angle), and the other with 5 degrees of clearance angle. Or did I misunderstand what you meant?
For a straight ground skew chisel, if you lift the handle to create a clearance angle from the flat glass surface, both points of the skew will still remain in contact with the surface*. For a curved grind however, lifting the handle to achieve some clearance angle will raise the swept-back points even more. If I'm thinking correctly, the additional distance raised is the sine of the clearance angle times the distance the point has been ground back from the tangent at the contact point.
(*This is what I believe causes decreasing stability with a straight grind skew of fixed size when used on workpieces with larger and larger diameter. The slightest wobble in controlling the skew can bring the long point dangerously close to digging in.)
OK, now I think I've burned out MY clutch!
JKJ
