JOOLTOOL
Mike B
>Does anyone own, or have experience with, the "jooltool" sharpening system? Would really appreciate your thoughts. Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
JOOLTOOL
Mike B
>Does anyone own, or have experience with, the "jooltool" sharpening system? Would really appreciate your thoughts. Thanks
Re: JOOLTOOL
Ed Davidson (Colorado Springs)
>I've had one for about six months. Watched the how-to video several times and could never get a good edge on lathe tools. Maybe it's just me. Would you like to buy my setup? I'd happily sell it for 50 cents on the dollar.
Re: JOOLTOOL *LINK*
charlie belden
>If you NEED a special jig to sharpen one or
more of your turning tools and/or are really
a stickler for precise bevel angles - I'd
suggest you skip the JoolTool. YOU are the
"jig" so it's all "free handing". However, unlike
free handing on a grinding wheel - you can SEE
where the metal is being abraded or polished.
Like anything else new - it takes a little getting
used to. But if you "learn" on an inexpensive
tool before trying your good tools you can pick
up the technique fairly easily in 10-15
minutes.
This thing has a very small footpring so it
can be placed at the lathe and is great for
quick touch ups of an edge.
It does have some limitations. BIG roughing
gouges - ie 1 1/2" width - can't be sharpened
because you don't have room to get the tool
angled properly.
Like everything else with turning, there's a
learning curve - and limitations. Nothing
does everything as well as a dedicated unit
intended to do just one thing.
If you're space constrained, the JoolTool
may be your answer.
If you have a lttle more room - and want to
sharpen plane irons and bench chisels as
well - the WorkSharp system does allmost
everything the JoolTool does - plus some.
More about the JoolTool at the attached link.
Will post url to my WorkSharp review next.
my JoolTool review
Re: JOOLTOOL *LINK*
charlie belden
>The WorkSharp system is an alternative to the
JoolTool. Works similarly but does some
things the JoolTool can't do - like plane irons
and bench chisels. Doesn't do the inside of
bowl, spindle or roughing gouges like the
JoolTool can.
Major advantage is that the consumable
abbrassives for flat sharpening aren't
proprietary (read More Expensive) - so
you can use PSA 6" sanding disks which
are readily available in coarser grits.
WorkSharp review
Re: JOOLTOOL
Dick Coers------WebKitFormBoundaryqFOmq51H3saAc+aC
>Charlie,
I have to admit I didn't read the entire eversharp review, but I have a question about any horizontal grinder. Doesn't the diameter of the disc have an effect on the sharpening? Doesn't the outside of a 2" plane blade see more grinding speed that the inside? Does this cause more material to be removed from the outside of the blade causing an angle on the blade? Or do you place the blade on more of a parallel position compared to radial?
Re: JOOLTOOL
john lucas
>Dick I just read a review of the top 3 disc type sharpening systems and that was one of their concerns. They said it did take some concentration and finesse to keep the edge flat since part of it was being abraded faster than another part. I think the solution would be to let the tool sit at an angle perpindicular to the rotation. This would put most of the tool on the same section of disc and the speed would stay the same. Now how hard that would be to do I don't know. I'm still evaluating all those systems because I need something to sharpen a bunch of carving chisels that I got real cheap.
Re: JOOLTOOL
Russ Fairfield
>There is a demo model at the local Woodcraft store and I have tried to use it several times, and have some conclusions. Others my disagree.
This is a "free-hand" disc sander that is made a bit easier to use because you can see the tool being sharpened through the slotted disc. This tool gives a new meaning to "free hand" because you are holding the tool against the spinning disc with only your hands. There is no toolrest, and no way to add one of them. The only reference is our ability to hold the bevel of the tool against the spinning disc. A table at the right height to rest mu elbows might make it easier to use.
With some practice, it can be relatively easy to use with wood chisels and carving chisels because of their lighter weight and shorter handles which makes them easier to maneuver under the disc. The discs are too small to sharpen a chisel wider than 1" very effectively.
It is totally useless for sharpening lathe tools because their weight and length makes them difficult to hold while trying to grind the varying bevel ahgles of bowl and spindle douges. It could probably be done with a lot of practice. Others may have more success with it.
It is an interesting concept, and it's kind a fun to play with, but there are better ways to seriously sharpen a lathe tool.
Re: JOOLTOOL
charlie belden
>Re: Potential problem flattening the back of
wide chisels and plane irons
The question was:
Because your abrading metal on the flat surface of a 6" diam. rotating disk, isn't there
more metal being removed towards the
outside of the disk than on the inside -
resulting in a trapezoidal cross section?
The answer is yes - IF you hold the chisel or
plane iron still on the disk. BUT you CAN
move the chisel or plane iron in order to
compensate for that. And even if you didn't,
when you grind or touch up the bevel edge,
the bottom of the chisel or iron is registered
on the bevel jig and the right side of the chisel
or iron is registered against the right fence.
THAT means that the ground or touched up
cutting edge will be square to the side of the
chisel or iron - which is what's most CRITICAL
for it is the cutting edge that you register
to your scribe line or in the case of a hand
plane, the depth of cut/edge exposure. The
potential problem of having a bevel that varies
by a half degree acrossed its width is less
significant.
Re: Sharpening large turning chisels and the
lack of control when "freehanding"
It's really not that hard and it's not an issue
of strength. If you've been to a woodworking
show and seen Ani demonstrate the JoolTool
that's not really a problem - she's no Hulk
Hogan. It's all about bevel control - which, if
you're a woodturner, you MUST know how to
do. No other wood working cutting tools
involve more tool movement during a cut as
a turning tool - movement on, and around,
two or more axis - simoultaneously.
Get the heel of the bevel in contact and
lift the handle to "ride the bevel". This is a
skill you already have - but with the JoolTool
and WorkSharp - you can SEE where the bevel
is contacting the wheel.
I've got a 3/8" (maybe it's a 1/2") bowl gouge
with an Ellsworth type grind. It's a LONG tool
and not light. I had the Tormek guy sharpen
it to what he thought was really sharp. I then
took it over to Ani to see if she could make it
sharper with the JoolTool - and she did - in
about 30 seconds, and that's including
felt penning the bevel and talking while doing
it. I'm a sharpening phreak - and I'd NEVER
seen an edge that sharp before - and on a
fingernail type grind.
I think the issue is more of a mental one. The
way these things work is unfamiliar. But it
doesn't take very long to get to know how to
use these things.
Now I do know that for a wide roughing gouge
with a fat, long handle, the JoolTool won't
work because of space constraints - it is,
after all, a jeweler's machine. I haven't tried
sharpening that roughing gouge on the
WorkSharp yet - haven't needed that gouge
lately. I'll report back when I get time to
try it.
Bottom line - NO sharpening system I know of
DOES IT ALL. With the exception of some
special "incanted" carving tools, the Work
Sharp and JoolTool will cover the base. And
I suspect that, using the JoolTool "bristle
brushes" you COULD do incanted carving
tools as well.
When you compare these things with other
methods of sharpening they're pretty nice
No oil or water - and associated mess to
deal with.
No grinder dust all over your bench
No "Grind-check-grind-check-grind . . .
Re: JOOLTOOL
eliot d
>I love mine! I fine it extremely useful for sharpening those metal-lathe bits that we glue into home made hollowing tools. If you ever watch Annie, the gal who invented it and who often shows up at woodworker exhibits to demonstrate and sell it. it's just amazing how quickly she gets a perfect edge on just about any tool -- including the swept back type Ellsworth gauge. But others are absolutely right: its entirely a hand held affair and it takes quite a bit of practice. It's very important to have enough light positioned above the tool so that you can see well enough through the spinning "ninja" sandpaper disks. The nice thing is that by acquiring different disks, including diamond ones and 5 micron disks, etc., you can sharpen just about anything to an incredible degree of sharpness. I once brought one of those old Dennis Stewart slicing/coring tools to a woodworking show and asked numerous vendors to sharpen it for me, as it had gotten very dull, and is made of extremely hard material. No one could do it, until I got to the Jool tool lady; she use a diamond disk and did it perfectly in about two seconds. I just couldn't get sharp with wheels and hones, etc.