Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

Posts

Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#1

Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

Ron McKinley

>I�ve had the machine for a little over two weeks and have put it through its paces. The ProEdge is a robust, precise sharpening system. The fit and finish is superb and this machine exudes quality.

First a few CONS: This is a $500 machine and Sorby included a 25 cent instruction manual. Well, maybe a little more since it�s printed on glossy paper, in full color and a convenient size. But, it left out the most important information the user needs. More about that later.

When sharpening skews the table gets in the way of the handle when you flip the tool to the left side of the triangle. Sorby is aware of this and may be working on a redesign of the table. They suggested in an e-mail that some users build a wood table to go over the present table to lift the tool up so the handle of the skew won�t interfere. I found a good workaround is to use just the right side of the triangle jig and flip it over each time and there�s no interference.

The belt tilts from the vertical to probably 45 degrees�didn�t measure it but that�s approximate. This is a handy feature, especially when sharpening skews. Other tools work better at more vertical angles. The weakness here is getting to the back screw to loosen or unloosen so it can be tilted. In the more extreme angles there is a hole in the belt guard to reach through with the hex wrench but the only way I can reliably find it with the wrench is with a flashlight pointing through the right side of the belt. Understandably, with an all-in-one machine there are a few compromises. This isn�t a major problem.

To sharpen a fingernail gouge you must remove the table or the jig will hit the table on both sides. The manual doesn�t tell you this and the photos don�t show the table removed when using the fingernail profiler jig so I removed the table in the obvious way�by removing two hex screws that can easily get lost-- the correct size wrench isn�t included. Still the bracket that supports the table is still in the way. After a few e-mails to Sorby I was told the correct way to remove the table which is simple and easy and takes about 10 seconds! Strangely, this information isn�t included in the manual.

Now for the PROS: This machine puts the finest edge on my tools of any system I have ever used. Now it�s pleasure instead of drudgery to sharpen! For the first time ever, every tool in my shop is sharp.

The machine comes with three belts--60, 120 and 240 grits. First off, since all my tools had a hollow grind, I changed to the 60 grit carbide belt and removed the hollow grind. I then finished up with the 120 grit belt but I really didn�t need to as the 60 grit left a fine edge. I checked the grind with a magnifying glass and it looks smoother than a baby�s bottom!

The Turner�s version of the ProEdge doesn�t come with a jig for sharpening flat chisels. No matter, the Standard Profile Edge jig for sharpening spindle roughing gouges and conventional bowl gouges works just as well. Just use the right or left side to keep the chisel flat and perpendicular to the belt.

Other Comments: Three accessories are available at extra cost for turners. The honing wheel and the buffing mop require you to remove the belt guard and the belt before you can attach them. I doubt if any turner would be interested in these since they�re not convenient to use and require re-configuring the machine for both operations. The other is the Cutter Holder that looks like it will sharpen every type of cutter available. None of these accessories are available in the U. S. as of now but they soon will be.

Summary: This is a fine machine and I recommend it. Would I buy it again? Absolutely. Is it a good value? When you consider the price of a Tormek with all the needed accessories--yes. When you consider a good grinder with Norton SG wheels and a sharpening jig like the Wolverine--yes.

Disclaimer: I have no financial interest in the Sorby Company but I do own several of their turning tools��Ron

For more details go here: http://www.robert-sorby.co.uk/ then click on Latest Products, then ProEdge Sharpening System

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#2

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Thanks for this review Ron, I think I may have one of these in my future. It sounds impressive and will take up less space than my wolverine setup. I'm going to keep your review for future reference.

keithz

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#3

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

john lucas

>Thanks Ron. I've been interested in this machine but I'm also looking at some of the carvers sharpening machines. They seem to be a little more specialized and I'm still not sure I want a machine that tries to do it all. Did you try that machine on plane blades?

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#4

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

Ron McKinley

>John I haven't used a hand plane in so long I had forgotten about them. Shouldn't be any difference in sharpening a flat chisel though...Ron

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#5

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

don lewonczyk

>Ron I got the last one one in the box that klingspor had and encountered the same problems, I wish they had all the bugs worked out before putting them on the market but it is a nice machine, no junk about it. I haven't tried removing the table other then the the two screws holding it, whats the 10 second secret? Your right about the manual and also about their video at their web site, leaves you guessing what to do next. When I put the fingernail grind on I had to go almost to the bottom of the belt to get the full profile but it turned out good. You seem to have mastered it very well and thanks for the tip on the skew sharping trick, I hadn't thought of that. All in all it works great and a lot simpler then some of the other sharpeners out there. Don L

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#6

How does it compare with the Lee Valley

Russ Fairfield

>Does anyone know how the basic grinder part of the Sorby compares with the belt grinder that is available from Lee Valley??

I ALREADY KNOW that the Lee Valley doesn't include a motor or any of the sharpening jigs and fixtures that are included with the Sorby. But, it also sells for only $70 and uses the standard 1" X 42" belts that I can buy everywhere. I can buy a small motor and a complete set of tool grinding fixtures for a lot less than the $400+ difference in price.

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#7

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

don lewonczyk

>Ron it looks like from the manual you just remove the table looking lever and the whole works slides off. I didn't look at the machine yet its down in the shop. DonL

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#8

Re: How does it compare with the Lee Valley

don lewonczyk

>Russ, I looked at the Lee Valley belt sander and for the money you can't go wrong. The Sorby is ready to go out of the box and your bevel angles are set for what chiesels you'll be sharpening everytime, no guessing and im not sorry I bought one. As you know you get what you pay for and pricy as it was its worth it. I have the other systems but like this one best. Don L

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

#9

Re: Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System-Review

Ron McKinley

>You're right. Use the hanging wrench and unscrew the one bolt and the table, bracket and angle guide comes off in one piece.