Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

35mm slide scanner???

Posts

35mm slide scanner???

#1

35mm slide scanner???

The MountainMan

>Anybody ever use one of these? I can find them on ebay - different price ranges... I would like to digitize my European slides before they are not usable...

I am not interested in printers with slide readers...

Regards

The MountainMan

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#2

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>This was discussed about a couple months ago. My resonse is there. I'm still working on doing mine. It is very time consuming.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#3

Nikon

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>makes them, do a search...

Big price tag...

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#4

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

James Fox

>I have a Canon 4200F scanner. It does regular paper documents, magazine pages, etc. It also scans slides and film strips. I scanned in all my slides from Vietnam not too long ago. Yes...it's a long process but it does a good quality scan. Satisfied customer.

James

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#5

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

Andy Blackwell

>I have a SmartScan 3600. It is just for scanning slides. Does an excellent job and is relatively fast. A little pricey.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#6

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

JohnKJordan in East TN

>The thread mentioned has details. I've bought and used several brands and subjected them to careful tests, some were junk. I'm happy with the Nikon have now (although I use it only rarely). It was a bit pricy but sometimes you get what you pay for! Flatbed scanners with transparency adapters will work but may require significant compromise. Much depends on what level of quality you require.

JKJ

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#7

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>I just checked a photo company that I buy from and they seem to have several that attach to your digital SLR camera. It looks like about $ 50.00 bucks may do it. I use

adorama.com

but others may be available. Some of our photo people may have a comment on the quality of these, I hope. It sure would seem a fast and simple way to duplicate. You could just set up on a tripod by the TV and just keep loading and shooting.

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#8

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

Don in Central Illinois

>You could look for a 35mm slide duplicator. They fit on the front of the lense, some even have a flash. If they will fit on your digital camera you will have a digital image of the original slide.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#9

Re: Unless you have a good macro....

Jamie Donaldson

>...lens(flat field) for your DSLR, most consumer cameras with zoom lenses will not do a satisfactory job of copying slides with a lens attachment. I have been scanning negatives and slides for several years with a flatbed scanner (old Epson 3200)with very good results, and it is now several generations in digital years. There is no practical need for a dedicated slide scanner unless you can justify the high cost.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#10

Dimage Dual Scanner

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I have a Minolta Dimage Dual IV film/slide scanner. Unfortunately, this is now discontinued as Minolta merged with Konica and the merged company quit the digital business. That does not mean that this is not a good machine. I have scanned hundreds of slides and negatives into my system with it and am very pleased with my results.

One should be available on ebay and shouldn't cost all that much.

keithz

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#11

Re: Unless you have a good macro....

john lucas

>My boss says that cameras don't have the resolution of scanners so he wouldn't do it. I had thought about doing the same thing because I have a set of bellows and copy attachment.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#12

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

Terry Fox

>Hammacher-Schlemmer sells a dedicated Slide or Negative - to- Digital Converter for $100. Reviews are mixed - some negative, most positive - good value for money, and good unless you want 'professional' results.

Also fotobridge.com offers a fixed price batch conversion mail order package that seems pretty reasonably priced if you have 150 or more slides to convert.

Terry

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#13

Re: Unless you have a good macro....

Don in Central Illinois

>Jamie, the Epson scanner you spoke about, will it handle old 3 1/2 by 4 negatives. I had to turn down a job because my old scanner wouldn't do a good enough job. Need a decent scanner at a 'reasonable' cost.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#14

Re: Don-this series of Epsons will.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... give good scans of all film sizes up to 4"x5"(film holder will hold 2) and has carriers to match. The newer V series Epsons will scan up to 8"x10" or batches with a variety of carriers.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#15

Steven Antonucci

Another question for the photo experts-

steve antonucci

>I had heard that a good slide scanner needed to be illuminated from both sides of the image. Has that changed in the new scanners?

I've tried scanning some 6x6 cm slide before on a regular scanner, but the results have always been horrible because I didn't have the right scanner.

Have you every tried to put a light box above the scanner bed to illuminate the transparency? just wondering...

Steven

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#16

Re: Another question for the photo experts-

john lucas

>Steve both or ours have white reflective panels but no light above. I'm sure some light is reflected back over because there is a gap of about 3/8" that the reflective panel sits above the slides. The slides fit in a plastic holder. Our latest scanner is the Epson V750. don't ask me anything about it because I'm not the one who uses it and can't answer a single question.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#17

Re: Another question for the photo experts-

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>To scan slides, you have to have a transmission type of scanner (light is above the slide) rather than a reflective and most flatbeds are only reflective. There is just not enough light reflected off the white surface on the inside of the lid to get a good scan. The light has to pass through the slide to get the best scan.

The new flatbed scanners that have built-in transparency holders are designed to allow for proper light dispersion in order to achieve a good scan. I have played with one with a built-in scanner and thought it was quite good and adequate for most purposes.

keithz

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#18

Re: Another question for the photo experts-

JohnKJordan in East TN

>The flatbed scanners that I have had which handled transparencies used a separate diffuse light source to pass light through the slide. On one, I had to remove the document lid and substitute the slide cover. This worked well, but the big limitation was still the resolution of the scanner. This was not a problem for 8x10 transparencies (quite rare, even for our work!) but a critical issue for 35mm slides and negatives. We always got much better results with a dedicated 35mm scanner.

Note that you can also send your negs and slides to a photo shop or service which will scan them for you. This might be cheaper depending on the quantity.

JKJ

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#19

Re: Steve-having light strike both.......

Jamie Donaldson

>....sides of a slide makes not sense at all. A scan is the same as projection of a transparency- light shining straight thru the film layers and recorded on a sensor.

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#20

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

Jim Terry

>I recently purchased the Canon CanoScan 8800 which is a flatbed scanner with adapters for negatives and slides. It will scan 4 mounted slides at a time. The nice thing, it will scan up to 9600 dpi on film or slides. I have only had a chance to run a test but it looks very good. It beats the HP and Microtek that I have tried. I must agree with Jamie, the slide duplicators for a 35mm camera are not good. The CanoScan 8800 was about $200 at Best Buy. I need to find time to use it as I have well over 1000 slides that need to be scanned. Jim

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#21

Steven Antonucci

I thought it might help with the amount of light

steve antonucci

>being picked up by the sensor. If you think about it, a scanner illuminates from the same side as it scans. By placing light above the slide, it would increase the amount of light passing through the slide significantly.

I tried it with a light box laying face down on the scanner bed, and it improved the scan results over just putting the slide on the scanner, but not to a point where I'd consider it useful. How much light needs to pass through a slide for a scanner to scan it? My lightbox is 8W.

Steve

Re: 35mm slide scanner???

#22

Re: Steve- a scanner for flat docs ...

Jamie Donaldson

>...operates by reflection, but slide scans are captured by transmission of colliminated light to a sensor.