Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Location of air cleaner

Posts

Location of air cleaner

#1

Location of air cleaner

Carole Valentine

>I will probably get as many answers as there are people, but here goes. I am trying to decide where to locate my air cleaner so I will know where to put a ceiling outlet. The lathes will be roughly in the center of the shop. The grinding station will be behind the lathe and the bandsaw to the left of the grinding station in the left rear corner of the shop. These are the biggest dust producing areas. I have been told that the cleaner should be to one side of the room, but I see them everywhere when I go into folks shops. Does it need to be close to the fine dust sources? Does it really matter since the cleaner is suppose to exchange the air 10 times in an hour and the DC will pick up the coarser stuff from these machines?

Re: Location of air cleaner

#2

Re: Location of air cleaner

Bill Clark

>Carole, I had a similar problem with mine. The only place I could put it was in the middle of the shop. This did not fit the suggested instructions of putting it on one side so the air flow would rotate in a circle. I was pleasantly surprised however to find that the filter still did a great job of cleaning the air. I'm amazed when I turn it on and in a few minutes you can see the difference. The room looks clear, the dust haze is gone.

The only change I would like to make is to turn the whole unit around 180 degrees. My lathe, the greatest fine and most dangerous dust producer in my shop is on the other side of the air intake. My cutting machines (table saw, jointer, bandsaw etc.) only produce small wood chips. When you sand on the lathe you are producing very small micron sized air borne particles that go deep into your lungs. That's the stuff you really need to get out of the air. If you have an option I would put your air cleaner where it will pickup the lathe sanding dust best.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#3

Re: Location of air cleaner

Carole Valentine

>Another limiting factor is the location of the remote sensing controls on the unit - they are on the right side of the unit and line-of-sight so to be able to use them from the main work area, I need to have the AC situated perpendicular to the right wall of the shop. I wonder how far from the wall the exhaust end of the cleaner should be?

Re: Location of air cleaner

#4

JL

Re: Location of air cleaner

JL

>I am presuming you are going to get a rather "large" or high capacity unit. So if you are, just put it relatively near one wall, about 3-5' out on the ceiling. That way you can have a "circular" motion of air.

One of the better shops that I've been in has two "lower" capacity air cleaners. Both are set 3-5' from the wall on the ceiling along the two side walls. They face in opposite directions. There is a nice circular motion of air in that shop. That set up will clear dust in minutes.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#5

Re: Take into consideration the airflow.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...dynamics, both intake and exhaust,and how these will impact your location choice. I mounted mine with intake above the lathes, aiming the exhaust away from that area so it that it wouldn't create drafts that would affect heating during winter, my busier turning season. In conjunction with 2 ceiling fans, I have a good circular airflow without obvious air movement all year around, and less chance of stagnant air to aid in mildew growth in my wood stash.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#6

Re: Location of air cleaner

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, I suggest that wherever you put the air cleaner, it shouldn't be behind you when you're at the lathe. You don't want to draw the fine dust toward you.

Wally

Re: Location of air cleaner

#7

Re: Location of air cleaner

Stuart Johnson

>My air cleaner still consists of a box fan and furnace filter but I don't see why the line of site sensor is an issue. How long will it take to walk over to the right side and trigger the remote?

Re: Location of air cleaner

#8

Re: Location of air cleaner

Carole Valentine

>It's a JDS 750-ER which should be OK for the working area of my shop (24x24). I have it sitting on a cart in my current shop of nearly the same size and it seems to do a good job even at that level.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#9

Re: Location of air cleaner

Carole Valentine

>No time at all - call me lazy. :) But then what would be the sense of having a remote? I could just use a pull chain.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#10

Re: Location of air cleaner

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I'd put the outlet in the center of the ceiling. If your unit has a 6' or 8' cord, you will have a lot of flexibility in positioning the air cleaner. You can always add a heavy extension cord later if the location isn't correct. Mine has a dedicated heavy gauge extension cord running across the ceiling and down the wall.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#11

Re: Location of air cleaner

Richard Jones

>I ran into the same problem, I wanted the air flow away from me, and the sensor was on the end AWAY from me. I merely mounted a small mirror on the wall behind the unit, stuck the remote on the side of the band saw, no more problem. Works great, and I can see the lights to tell which timer setting the unit is on.

Rich

Re: Location of air cleaner

#12

Re: Location of air cleaner

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>My air cleaner is hanging from the ceiling in the middle of the shop. Problem is my lathe is at the end of the shop under a window. If I run the air cleaner while sanding on the lathe the circulation pulls the fine sanding dust away from the dust collector behind the lathe and draws it towards me on its way to the air cleaner Guess I need to position the air cleaner above my lathe for best results or not run it when sanding? Something to think about.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#13

I removed mine

Garrett in Victoria

>because the fine dust it kept in circulation was more bothersome than the coarser dust that simply settled quickly. Unless you turn it off, you'll find it particularly irksome when applying finishes.

No air cleaner can get it all, and all air cleaners create enough circulation to keep dust airborne long after all of it would have settled normally. Ironically, the more powerful the fan, the worse the problem.

My suggestion FWIW: use the money to buy a good combo face-shield filter mask.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Location of air cleaner

#14

Re: Location of air cleaner

Lan Brady

>Carole,

You are correct. Just as many differnt answers as there are people.

I suggest you start with the natural air current your lathe creates. My Jet naturally pulls dust to the back and around the headstock. My friends Nova is naturally forcing the air down the bed ways. I would consider this flow so the 2 systems work together and do not just create turbulence around your face.

Good Luck, Not an easy decision, Lan

Re: Location of air cleaner

#15

Re: I haven't had time to read...

Allen Neighbors

>all the responses, so forgive me if I repeat any. (I'm involved with my 17 month old Grandson, at the moment, and have to get off of here)

If it was my new shop, I would stand at my lathe with the headstock to the left. Lift my left arm and point to a spot on the ceiling about 18" left of the headstock, and about 18" on the other side of the lathe. That's where I would put the intake. It will pull air away from the operator and circulate the air in the shop in a clockwise manner. That way, the cleaner air will be drawn past the operator.

'Bout a 1/2 cent worth. :)

Bye.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Location of air cleaner

Dick Hines

>Put where the dust is drawn away from the lathe but not past you to get to the air cleaner. As far as the remote swt. Go to a big box store and get a swt for turning the lights on a Christmas tree on and off. I get one a couple of years ago for $12. It comes with one of those little thinges like on car keys to open and close the doors. The swt plugs in and the air cleaner plugs into it. Presto!! It's cheap and works great.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#17

Re: Location of air cleaner

Carole Valentine

>The unit came with a remote that controls everything including speed and run time so I don't need to do that.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#18

Re: Similiar Experience:

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>I had the same trouble with a fairly large unit I bought and installed above my lathe on one side of my shop - the filter was a two stage deal that seemed to pick up most any dust, right? I hung a drop cloth up in my shop, behind the air cleaner on the exhaust side and after a few weeks of running, the cloth was covered in a heavy layer of fine dust!

So, I came up with the best solution for any and all air moving, dust/shavings type collection machines: run the exhaust outside! I waded through tons of stuff on Bill Pentz website, but the most obvious solution to all the filtration problems, is just get that "bad" air outside. So I made a sheet metal hood to go on the exhaust side of the air cleaner, cut a hole in the wall and vented it outside. My shop seems to be in much better shape - not near as much fine dust settles on everything after a lot of sanding.

As a side note, one of the greatest things I ever put in my shop was a used Central Vac I tore out of my parents house - again, I ran the exhaust through the floor, so I can vaccuum all I want, without that vac smell (read: super-fine dust!) all in the shop.

Hope this helps - these two changes in my shop have been some of the greatest things I've done out there.

David

My Dad & Me, Inc.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#19

Re: Location of air cleaner

Peter Hyde

>Carole i just finished building this one and as you can see it is almost directly over the headstock. I find it is really good at evening out the heat in the shop and also it certainly does reduce the amount of airborne dust. But I always use the DC you can see in the back when I am sanding on the lathe. I find this is by far the biggest dust remover but the filter system seems to pick up anything that is released from the DC.


img

Re: Location of air cleaner

#20

Re: Location of air cleaner

Carole Valentine

>From what I have read so far on Bill Pentz's web site, it's almost an exercise in futility with the DC equipment currently available to the normal hobbyist (and their budget). Sounds like whatever I use will be a token gesture to just try and keep down visible dust in the shop, so I'm just not going to worry about it. Besides, until I can manage to quit smoking, why the heck should I be worried about being exposed to fine wood dust? If I don't stop it, the darned smoking will kill me long before the wood dust does. :((

Re: Location of air cleaner

#21

Re: Similiar Experience:

Bob Macgregor

>Did your parents ever figure out who took their central vac?!

I hesitate to use my CV both because I don't want to vent too much of my expensively-warmed inside air outside and because I'm not sure if the unit was designed for quite that kind of particulate load.

I'm going to have to do something, though, because the intake for my forced-air central heating is in the basement with my shop, so the heating system filter is currently doing the dust filtering for my shop work...not good.

Re: Location of air cleaner

#22

Re: Garrett, when my homebuilt...

Allen Neighbors

>air cleaner is running, you cannot see any dust suspended or floating in the air in my shop. But then you can't see anything that's not covered in dust in my shop, most of the time, because I forget to turn it on. :)

Re: Location of air cleaner

#23

Re: Location of air cleaner

Ed Karch

>Here is mine with a magnet based light hanging on the base. very handy for moving the light source.


img

Re: Location of air cleaner

#24

Re: Location of air cleaner

Cyril Griesbach

>Carole, I don't know what brand of air cleaner you have but with my Jet I can activate the sensor with the remote at quite a severe angle...nearly 90 Deg.