Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

Posts

Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#1

Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

Barry Irby

>I attended a demo by Lyle Jamerson and bought one of his captive tool hollowing rigs and a No. 3 Hunter cutter.

I am finding some things about this to be hateful. The tool holders have a 3/8" shaft that slides into the boring bar. There is a disk on the tool holder that holds the Hunter Tool or other 3/16" square cutter.

I am have trouble with a couple of things. I have been doing Hf's with Ellsworth tools that are a boring bar with a tooth. I'm finding the disk on the Jamerson tool to be a hindrance. The hole in the HF must be larger to pass it through. Also, the No. 3 Hunter Tool has the cutter set at a predetermined angle. The problem is that as you pivot the disk on the Jamerson tool the Hunter cutter changes the angle it approaches the wood, if that makes sense. Also, I find it difficult to keep the disk stationary on the Jamerson tool. I really have to "set down" on that little bolt to keep the cutter from floating around.

I was thinking that if one of the other Hunter tools had a 3/8" shaft, I could mount it directly into the Jamerson boring bar and skip the little contraption with the disk. (I'm really hating the disk, if you turn it this way it rub on that side, if you turn it that way it rubs on this side.) Has anyone tried this. It seems to me that a Straight Hunter tool and perhaps one with a Swans neck would be great for this. Are the shafts on the Hunter Tools too long for this? Any thoughts?

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#2

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

john lucas

>The #3 Hunter tool has a 3/8" shaft. You might have to shorten it depending on how you mount it in Jamieson style bar.

I built a home brew version of the Jamieson tool attachment. I thought mine was made poorly because I had trouble locking it in position. Apparently you have the same problem. I also had the same problem with needing a large hole to get the cutter into.

I haven't used the Hunter tool in the Jamieson adaptor. I use it in my John Jordan style bar. some day soon maybe I can build a project where I can use it in the Jamieson adaptor.

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#3

My mistake....

Barry Irby

>I have a Hunter No. 1, not a 3. It's tiny, about 3/16" in diameter and mount on a 3/16" square bar about an inch or inch and a quarter long. It's pretty sweet when it works, but has a hateful learning curve. Its so small there isn't much bevel to ride and because I can't see it inside the form I really am working blind. The problem is that when you pivot the cutter, it changes everything about the cut.

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#4

Re: My mistake....

john lucas

>I knew you were talking about the #1. It is the cutter that comes on the 3/16" square and 1/4" round bars.

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#5

Re: My mistake....

Dennis Daudelin

>Using the Hunter tool on the Jamieson rig has some set "rules" that you must follow to make it work properly.

First, you have to start from the inside and work outwards (right to left). It will not cut from left to right due to the angle on the tool.

Secondly, after your right to left cut, you can pull the cutter towards you. But you can not cut from the neck of the vessel towards the bottom of the vessel, once again the angle of the tool prevents this.

If you follow these two "rules", the cutter works well.

I still struggle with getting the center flat but the Hunter tool works well otherwise.

Also having worked with the Hunter tools both in the Jamieson and hand-held, I know that the angle on the tool is important. If the cutter was horizontal, you would get catches and the tool would try to self-feed. The Hunter tool needs the ~45 degree angle to run the bevel and to get clean cuts!

In general, I've found that it takes some time to master but the finish left by the tool (when you're working it properly) is quite amazing! And doesn't require sanding! So, for me, it's worth the learning curve.

Dennis

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#6

Re: My mistake....

Barry Irby

>So, What you are saying is that if I bought a No. 3 tool (with a 3/8" shaft) and inserted it directly into the Jamerson system I should set it so that the cutter has a 45 degree slope? That is, the front or left edge would be rotated downward?

I knew the other "rules".

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

Lyle Jamieson

>Hi Barry,

You posed some very sophisticated and advanced issues that would take pages to explain and I have many questions to trouble shoot your process with you. So, if you are in the AAW book I will call you to fix your dilemma. Hate is a pretty strong word you used. I get feedback on the Jamieson system with the new "Hunter" carbide cutter that has been unanimous. They say this is the best thing to happen to hollow form turning in a long, long time. I want everyone, whether you have my system or a copy cat version to have more fun turning without beating your body up. If anybody out there in cyber space is having any problems I offer you my assistance. Call me and we can chat about your specific concerns. I designed this tool to get into any shape vessel that can be done with any other hand held tool...only easier and faster. Anybody can do it.

Let me try to skim the surface of some of Barry's questions.

First the small hole issue. Let's talk the same language. The disk you refer to let's call that the swivel assembly. The swivel assembly is an integral part of the Jamieson system. It's what sets it apart from most others. Why?? Dedicated position cutters work most of the time...but there are times when it just won't reach into the tight spot desired. The swivel assembly gives infinite control of positioning the cutter. This is important when using the HSS cutter when cleaning up tool marks left from hogging out. And it is even more important when using the Carbide cutter to take advantage of its three cutting actions of ride the bevel, sheer cutting, and negative rake scraping. I do a 2 hour demo on getting into small hole hollow forms so I can only outline it here. But the swivel assembly is 3/4 inch diameter and the boring bar that needs to get into the hole is 3/4 inch diameter. So we can get into a hole that is just a little bigger than 3/4. To use a smaller diameter boring bar would limit the size of your vessels. Don't go past the vibration point off the tool rest. It takes some fiddling to get the mouth opened up as it would with any tool system but small holes are not hard to accomplish. Sometimes it can be just as simple as turning the back rest around 180 degrees to get the entry started.

Let's define some other things. The #3 Hunter hand held tool has a 3/8 inch diameter shaft and 3/8 inch dia. carbide cutter. The #1 carbide cutter assembly I use in the Jamieson system and Mike Hunter has made them to retrofit many of the supported tool systems out there. See Packard and Craft Supplies catalogs as reference. I choose to use the #1 cutter because it works better than the bigger cutters. It is the most efficient way to cut wood without vibration. If you choose to use the #3 cutter and 3/8 inch shaft in the Jamieson boring bar or other supported system you loose the flexibility of the swivel assembly. It will work some times for some shapes but I would guess it would drive you crazy when it won't reach the shape you designed.

The HSS CUTTER in the Jamieson system has little learning curve, a 10 year old kid can do it. But, there is a short learning curve to using the carbide cutter and mastering the three cuts mentioned above. I will have an article out soon to show the dynamics going on with this seemingly simple tool. But Dennis was correct there are just a few tips. Only cut to the left. When you swivel the carbide cutter assembly around to the left to undercut a shoulder now left means cutting toward the tailstock. Always get the waste wood out from behind before undercutting a shoulder. (Barry, is that what you are doing??? Rubbing the swivel assembly on the waste wood while trying to cut??) You can set the swivel to ride the bevel across the bottom of the end grain vessel and get a much superior cut to scraping, or you can hog off using the peeling, sheering action, or you can use the scraping mode to clean up shoulder areas.

On your issue of the swivel assembly moving in use...that's a no-no. Make sure it is tight. Make sure everything is secure. If anything moves in use including the laser you are dead in the water and many bad things will happen.

Again, if anybody has any questions on my systems please feel free to call me (231-947-2348). I prefer to talk to you directly since e-mail is only one way communication and is subject to misunderstandings.

Lyle Jamieson

www.lylejamieson.com

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#8

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Lyle, I'm using the Hunter no. 1 cutter on my Stewart tool. I haven't been using it for removing wood, only to clean up, leaving a very nice smooth surface. (I discussed this with you in Portland).

My question: You mention negative rake scraping with the Hunter tool. How is that accomplished?

Wally

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#9

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

john lucas

>I had the same question on negative rake scraping. Lyle thanks for answering Barry. I've been playing with the Hunter tools for a while now but haven't used them in all configurations.

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#10

Man am I Busted!

Barry Irby

>Just spent over an hour on the phone with Lyle Jamerson. He called me.

Thank you, Lyle.

Lyle has given me a number of tips and pointers and I am sure it will help me master the system. Or at least improve my skills enough to enjoy it.

Let me say that any problems I have been having with the system are of my own making. This the first captive system I have ever owned or used. It is also the only Hunter cutter I have ever seen. And To make matters worse, I was unwilling to start with something easy and practice. I jumped right in trying to do difficult shapes through the smallest possible hole. I also expected it to be as easy as Lyle made it look.

I am in the steep part of the learning curve.

OTOH, I am often in the steep part of the learning curve.

So, thanks again Lyle for taking an hour or two out of your Sunday to help me.

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hunter Tool/hollowing question?

Lyle Jamieson

>Hi Wally,

Nice to hear from you. The 9 o'clock side of the carbide cutter is tilted down and there is no slicing/sheering action going on there so it is scraping. I use this mode to clean up tool marks when undercutting the shoulder area of a hollow form.

The other two cuts, briefly, are at 12 o'clock you get bevel support and the 10 to 12 o'clock area is the slicing action. From 12 to 3 o'clock it will not cut but only rub dull steel and cause vibration.

I am using the Carbide cutter for almost all hollowing now.

Happy Holidays to all

Regards,

Lyle Jamieson

www.lylejamieson.com