Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

blank glue-up grain orientation ?

Posts

blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#1

blank glue-up grain orientation ?

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I'd like to make one of these "face in a turning" things that would look like the following picture (that's my daughter's profile). It will be about 8" diameter at the top. Unfortunately I don't have a blank large enough, so will need to glue something up.


My question is how would you orient the grain when gluing up? I sketched two ideas below, but I think there is at least a third method face-gluing boards together. The first picture shows the grain oriented vertically (like an end-grain cutting board). I could also stack a bunch of discs on top of each other (like picture 2 below)? Seems like Method 1 is a lot more work and results in fragile edges at the top. Method 2 is easier, but the narrow part of the stem would be more fragile.

How would you do it? Is there a better way?



Thanks for your advice.

Cheers,

Steven

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#2

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

Lan Brady

>I am no help as a segmenter, but I sure like your thoughts.

Lan

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#3

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

Barry Irby

>Assuming you do a good job on the glue up (good glue, tight joints etc.) either method would work. I think each would be about the same strength as a solid blank if you ornated the grain in the blank the same way. So, I think either would work, but would have the limitations you mentioned.

Another thing you need to think about is that the glue up will affect the appearance. One is going to end up with horizontal stripes and the other with vertical stripes. The problem is that what you are trying to emphasize is the profile of your daughter's face. My guess is this is a place where you want a sort of bland nondescript piece of wood with very little figure to draw the eye away form the profile. (So your brain would say "Why are we looking at this? Oh! I see, there is a profile!) Not a gorgeous piece of wood that would hold the attention and not have people looking at the profile. The laminated block will introduce a bunch of lines and if the layers don't match up well in color and grain then there will be all sorts of patterns emerging. Especially in the one with the vertical laminations.

A contrary thought is to laminate a bunch of rings of segments. Lots of little blocks of closely matching wood so that the brick pattern would get lost in the background and the profile would emerge.

Yet another thought. Get a blank of burl. Grain gone wild. Eliminate those linear grain lines.

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#4

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The most important thing is to make your joints face or side grain. Butt joints can create real problems.

The series of flat disks has better grain orientation, but you will end up turning a lot of end grain in the profile.

Personally, I would glue it up using sticks and slabs with the grain running vertically. I'd use full length sticks for the central section and shorter board sections for the bowl and foot sections. All with the grain running vertically. That is the way that I do large lamp glue-ups.

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#5

Gluing end-grain

Jack Savona

>Seems to me that I've heard that gluing end-grain to end-grain is a weaker joint. If that's the case #1 would have two "weak" joints.

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#6

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

Russ Fairfield

>You asked which is the better grain orientation. My choice would be neither. Like most things in life, the compromise is the better choice.

Always remember that parallel grain directions in the two pieces is the strongest glue joint, and that end-grain to end-grain glue joints are the weakest by far. An end-grain joint will always break at the glueline, and a parallel joint can as strong as the wood itself, and sometimes stronger.

Combination joints where the grain in the two pieces is at right angles is somewhere in between, and where that "somewhere" is will depend on the wood and our ability to make a tight joint.

As you have drawn them, the upper is a a 100% spindle turning assembly with all of the grain running vertically. and the other is a bowl turning assembly with all of the grain running horizontal. This horizontal assembly makes the weakest direction of the wood across the diameter of the smallest cross-section at the stem. This should not be the weakest part of the vessel.

As drawn, the top one in the spindle turning orientation has a problem with the joints at either end of the stem being a combination joint that won't be too much better than an end grain joint. This one should be modified to eliminate that joint by making the 2 center pieces run all the way from the rim to the bottom of the base. However, this will probably be the least attractive option because it will forever look like something that was slabbed together, and it will be almost impossible to get rid of this appearance by matching grain directions.

My choice would be to make this in 3 pieces. The bowl and the base would be a flat assembly as in your bottom drawing, and the stem would be a spindle turning as in your upper drawing. Make a tenon on either end of the stem that is a tight fit into holes in the base and bowl. That would be the strongest assembly.

If you didn't mind the bowl having 45-degree and straight sides like a Chanpaigne glass, it could be assembled from stacked rings that were cut from a flat board. Make the cuts at 45-degrees, and the rings are stackable. That opens up a whole bunch of design options. But. that is another issue that your turning skills might not be ready for yet.

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#7

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Is turning it in sections an option? Along the lines of a base, a stem, and top section.

Tenons could be used for joining the sections together, although the inside of the top bowl part might need a little tweaking in terms of depth to allow it there. That might allow some flexibility as to how you prepare the stock.

Bob Way

Canton, MI

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#8

Re: Gluing end-grain

GolfSteve in Calgary

>The way I was thinking of doing Method #1 there would be no end-grain to end-grain joints. I must not have explained it very well...

I have a 9" wide 8/4 board that I plan to use. The centre sections would be the full length of the goblet with the grain running vertically. The shorter sections at the outer diameter of the top would be oriented the same way, but just be shorter than the centre.

Thanks,

Steven

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#9

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Thanks Barry.

If I want to put a litte effort into it (which I do), I should be able to a) match the grain well, and b) if the boards are too mismatched, I could dye the piece to smooth out the inconsistencies.

Best regards,

Steven

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

#10

Re: blank glue-up grain orientation ?

GolfSteve in Calgary

>But that is another issue that your turning skills might not be ready for yet. :-) No kidding, but I never was one to stay on the bunny hill for more than a few minutes.

I'll scratch my head for a few minutes and see if I can make this as a three part assembly.

Merry Christmas,

Steven