Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

butternut bowls

Posts

butternut bowls

#1

butternut bowls

mfoster

>I turned some butternut bowls for our office staff for xmas. I rough turned the bowls a few of weeks ago. Butternut really sucks to turn wet. It is really stringy, which constantly clogged the gouge halting turning, and tearout was unavoidable even with the keenest edge. I dunked the blanks in EtOH, then re-turned them last week. Turned a little easier when dry using a really sharp gouge and shearing cut. Getting through the oval shape from drying, then the tearout left from roughing out I was unable to to alter the final form much from the original. Sanding was just as frustrating. They required a lot more sanding than I am used to, mostly because I was still trying to get rid of tearout.

I like the final results, but butternut goes to the bottom of my list for turning wood. I have made several pieces of furniture out of butternut which are very nice, but it's not worth the required effort for turning.


img

Re: butternut bowls

#2

One bowl

mfoster

>Here is a shot of just one bowl. The tree must have had a funny growth pattern with all growth rings sort of serrated around the tree, giving a ray like pattern across the bowls. All of the bowls showed this pattern.


img

Re: butternut bowls

#3

Spalted American Hophornbeam Burl

mfoster

>I turned this piece for my colleague. He and his wife have a collection of turnings, mostly off ebay. This was an American Hophornbeam tree that died on my property last year. It was hollow, but had several burly sections. This is from one of those. It already had spalt going on when I took it down, and not a lot of solid wood left. Really dense wood, and fun to turn wet or dry. Even the spalted sections turned well. Numerous critter (ants and grubs) holes were filled with colored epoxy.


img

Re: butternut bowls

#4

Re: One bowl

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Nice bowls. I didn't have as much trouble as you when I last turned it.

The rippled growth rings are normal for butternut.

Re: butternut bowls

#5

Re: One bowl

john lucas

>Very nice bowls. They will really love them. I just turned several butternut mirrors. This was air dried stuff and it turned just like walnut. Very clean, easy to sand and took a finish nicely. Haven't turned green butternut so I can't answer that one.

Re: butternut bowls

#6

Steven Antonucci

Still, those are some good looking bowls

steve antonucci

>I have a few woods that the trouble is less than the results, and so I spend the time with the sandpaper. I know carvers like butternut, so maybe you could take up carving?

Steve

Re: butternut bowls

#7

"Bitter"nut

Joe Pack

>My wife's grandfather, a top quality woodworker, called it "bitternut," in that it was a "bitter nut to work with." He gave up on trying to sand down the nubs before applying a finish. Smoothing one way raised grain the other...sort of like rubbing a dog's hair against the grain. He applied a thin finish to harden the wild nubs, then sanded. He had more available in his woodlot than he could ever use, and chose to avoid it most of the time in favor of woods he considered easier to work with.

I made a quilt rack from some butternut I inherited from him. I tried sanding the stuff and immediately learned what he was talking about. Out came the thinned Deft. A light scuff sanding later, it finished beautifully. I have a bunch left, but not too anxious to use it.

Re: butternut bowls

#8

Re: butternut bowls

RevDoug

>I understand you not liking butternut so much. I guess I'm kind of weird in that I like it. If what you have sitting around is turning stock, for either bowls or platters, I might be interested in trying to make some kind of deal. Drop me a private message if you'd like to get rid of some of your stock.

Turn 'em round,

Re: butternut bowls

#9

Re: butternut bowls

GaryG in MD

>I'd say the results are worth the effort (of course I didn't have to make the effort). ;-)

Nice wood; nice bowls -- lovely HF too. ...Gary

Re: butternut bowls

#10

Re: butternut bowls

Charles B. Watson

>Nice looking bowls! But as for me, I like turning Butternut when I have the oportunity which isn't often enough as I rarely can find any.

Re: butternut bowls

#11

Re: butternut bowls

George Van

>Looks like the effort was worth it Mike, I love the rippled look of Butternut. I have my first couple of pieces under the overhang, now after seeing this I will have to rough one today.

Your Hophornbeam surprises me, it does not appear to have all the splits I see on mine out in the woodshed. Maybe it�s the burl. Perhaps I am overlooking something and will have to give some a try. I like the idea of cutting and finishing some �hard� hardwood after a stretch of yellow birch and spalted woods.

Re: butternut bowls

#12

Re: One bowl

Bob Macgregor

>It saves a lot of extra work to find a wood that has built-in scalloping. I love that grain pattern.

Re: butternut bowls

#13

Beautiful!

Pete Kekel - Kentucky

>I love the grain patterns in Butternut bowls. Easy for me to say, because I didn't do the sanding, but I think the results were worth it.

Re: butternut bowls

#14

Wow that's nice!

Steven Kubien

>It may have been a PITA but that is beautiful wood in my opinion. Thanks for sharing.

Steve Kubien

Re: butternut bowls

#15

Re: butternut bowls

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Beautiful....looks like you did a great job!

Mike

Re: butternut bowls

#16

Re: butternut bowls

mfoster

>Thanks all. I handed out the bowls today, and they were a big hit. RevDoug, I have a lot still in the round. It is actually a log still up in my woods. Too hard to get to with my tractor, so it hasn't been hauled out for firewood yet. I have a log sitting up there (it came down last winter) that should still have fine wood in the middle. Perhaps 18" in diam. and 20' ft long, or so. I got the wood for the bowls out in cut up pieces. The log is actually off the ground, so spalting should not be a problem. If you're interested in getting up to Springfield VT and hauling it out yourself, I'll show you where it is. I am considering getting my tractor up there when the ground is a little more frozen and winching it out for firewood, or perhaps have it sawn for lumber.

Re: butternut bowls

#17

Re: butternut bowls

Carol in Illinois

>They might have been a bear to turn, but them sure is purty bowls! I turned dry butternut for my first bowl, and it turned easily and nice, from a newbie's perspective. Then again, what do I know! (grin)