Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

Posts

PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#1

Aage Rendalen

PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

Aage Rendalen

>When I put rough-turned bowls back on the lathe I struggle at times to get the bowl to run true. Yesterday I worked on a poplar bowl that I bandsawed out of five months old square blank (most tear-out prone wood I have ever worked on) and it never quite quit wobbling. I began wondering if the lathe could be at fault. When I push in the stop bolt, there is at least 1/8" play in the spindle. I don't know if that is a problem. I use a supernova chuck. What do you think it is? Wood going out of round because of warping during the turning process? Faulty lathe or faulty technique?

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#2

Dick Hines

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

Dick Hines

>All green wood warps. You said it was a roughed out bowl. If it had dried it could be real warped. When you rough out your bowls leave that little nib on the bottom with hole made by the live center. If you finish the bottom while the wood is wet you may never get to run true.

If the nip is still on the bottom you can use that to line up the bowl. Use a jam chuck to hold the bowl between the head stock and tail stock. Then true up the foot so it will be true and then check the bowl up and return.

That's how I do it but I bet you get more ideas.

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#3

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>I seriously doubt your lathe has a problem. I'm certainly no expert, but know that any wood (especially green wood) can easily go out of round as you turn due to released stresses and other issues. So I don't worry too much about it. Plus, that's one reason I sand and finish the outside of the bowl before I work on the inside. If I waited until after finishing up the inside and then went back to sand and finish the outside, it could be slightly out of round and uneven.

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#4

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

john lucas

>Several things come to mind. First, as the others have said a rough turned bowl will always be out of round. Second. You say it is a very tearout prone wood. I find poplar to be a pretty forgiving wood so I suspect there might be a problem with your gouge usuage, at least to some extent. If the wood is tearing out badly it could be getting punky. This means the tenon could be soft. As you try to turn an out of round piece you vibrate the bowl which can make the jaws get loose on the tenon.

If the tool is vibrating try taking lighter cuts and push down on the tool rest rather than pushing the tool into the wood.

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#5

Aage Rendalen

Poplar a guess

Aage Rendalen

>John, I guessed it was poplar. It may have been something similar. The wood is white with noticeable grain pattern (not unlike magnolia) and after I bandsawed it last week and sealed it with Anchorseal it turned yellowish (it's not mulberry).

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#6

Probably not a major problem

Rick Urban

>I quickly scanned the responses and would like to add a couple of points that I didn't notice. I, too, use the Technatool chucks. I've been happy with them, but their move to China for production caused me to order a oneway stronghold from hartville tools (they're having a sale) today.

1. If you rechuck you can introduce an out of round condition. If this might be an issue you can mark the tennon or recess (I mark between the #1 and #4 jaw.) so you can put it back the same way.

2. Dry wood will relax when you remove some of the mass that has been resisting the movement forces. I generally get close to the shape I want for the outside, then hollow the inside, then return to the outside for a final pass, then return to the inside for cleanup.

Hope this helps.

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#7

Forgot to mention

Rick Urban

>3. You might also consider cleaning up the tenon or recess to be more nearly round on your rough turned bowls. Besides aleviating some of the issue the chuck will hold better and more safely.

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#8

Re: Poplar a guess

Bill Howatt

>Sounds like what we call poplar but is really Aspen. It is very white when cut and Anchorseal does turn it yellow. It does indeed warp when drying.

Bill

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#9

Re: Poplar a guess

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Anchorseal also turned box elder yellow for me. Quite a contrast to holly, which turned brown with a slight green cast.

Interesting, the differnt effects on different wood. Maybe some enterprising smart person will develop a Wood ID Test Kit some day using a combo of density/optical/chemical methods.

JKJ

Re: PM 3520B: How to check for out of round

#10

Re: Forgot to mention

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>On soft wood, after I cut the tennon I put thin CA around the bottom and sides of the tennon. After a few minutes I go back and re clean the tennon to eliminate any rough spots created by the CA.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.