Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

New platter

Posts

New platter

#1

New platter

john lucas

>I finally had a couple of minutes between jobs to shoot my latest platter. This is part of a board a guy gave me a year ago. It was quite wet so I covered it with Endgrain sealer and let it sit for 3 months or so and then Resawed it and let it sit for about 9 more months. I finally decided it was dry enough to turn for a christmas gift for him. I should have used the Cheek test to decide if it was dry enough but I didn't.

Looking at it closely I decided I wish I had left it as a smooth bottom platter. That would have made the flame pattern stand out better. I don't get to turn a lot of crotch pieces so I have to learn these things as I go. Let me know what you would do differently. I still have the other half to turn.


img

Re: New platter

#2

Curt Brock's glass

john lucas

>This is what I was shooting before I shot my Platter. Curt is the glass instructor for the Appalachian Center for Crafts. I had to shoot about a dozen of his pieces.


img

Re: New platter

#3

Steven Antonucci

Looks like he "turned it wet"

steve antonucci

>I've always wanted to get a kiln (or a blacksmiths forge), but I know that I'm already over extended on free time and cashflow...

Part of my love of glass is color. The other thing is spontaneity. You can have a plan, which is more like a guideline than a blueprint.

Steve

Re: New platter

#4

Curious about photo setup

James McClure

>John, you have shot this on what appears to be a somewhat reflective black surface and you see that hard line in front of the graident backdrop. I think it is very effective for the glass piece because of the translucence of the glass. Is this a setup that you use often or was it requested by the artist?

Re: New platter

#5

Platter

Ruth Harding

>John, I love the figure in the wood and really like the turning. I think though I would like them more if they were on another piece. The wood can stand for itself and a plain turning would have allowed the wood to shine.

The turning would have allowed a somewhat plain piece of wood to stand out.

so, they are both great, but I would prefer them if they were not together.

Re: New platter

#6

Re: Platter

Tim GC

>Could not have put it better myself, but I am pretty new to this turning hobby/obsession so my views are not worth the phosphor you are reading this on (or led/plasma)

Re: New platter

#7

Re: New platter

Cyril Griesbach

>Well done, John, but I think it would have been better to leave out the "bump" in the interior. That would have shown off the wood more.

Re: New platter

#8

Re: Curious about photo setup

john lucas

>James The Glass artists saw this style in a magazine and liked it so I'm using for some shots if that's what they want. It is a piece of black formica. It allows me to control the light coming through the piece better for some pieces. I would prefer a softer horizon line but that's what they like so that's what I do.

Re: New platter

#9

Re: Platter

john lucas

>Ruth That was my opinion also.

Re: New platter

#10

Re: Platter

john lucas

>Your opinion is worth as much as anyone elses. We all have a background in something, maybe it's turning, maybe it's art or maybe it's just putting wheels on a car on a production line. You still know what you like and I'm willing to listen. Only by listening do we learn.

Re: New platter

#11

Re: New platter

john lucas

>My custodian friend came in and looked at the platter and suggested that I put some grooves in the sides so it would make a good ashtray. That really puts you in your place. I ain't gettin $10,000 for an ashtray.

Re: New platter

#12

JL

Re: I vote with Cyril...

JL

>the figure would show up without the central "bump". I really like the rim detail, so I think that is a winner.

Re: New platter

#13

Re: New platter

Rick Allen

>There are a few things I would consider. Ray Key says that flamboyant wood doesn't need fancy turning details. He say to save those details for more plane timber.

Another curious thing is that features done in odd numbers are better than even numbers. So instead of 2 beads 3 beads or 1 bead would work better. I don't know why this is but I know I have "tested" this rule of thumb and have found odd to work better than even.

You have 4 features on that platter.

1. The outer rim bead

2. The rim to body interface of 2 beads

3. The raised portion of the middle

4. The flame figure of the wood

If you have a lot of features I have found that they should complement each other. All the beads the same size or the beads getting progressively smaller or larger. Mostly I like to leave it at just one turned feature and one wood feature. To many disparate features tend to confuse the viewer.

On this particular piece of wood I would consider a simple curve from the rim to 1/5 to 1/4 of the way in with the remainder flat across the bottom. That would really show off the flame figure. There are some options for the rim edge to show off some detail. You could also show off detail on the back side of the platter.

Walnut bleaches really well. So burning a design in the rim area that is then bleached and colored could make quite an artistic statement. Perhaps some hot rod flames around the rim to complement the flame figure in the wood.

The best thing about all of this is that you get to make whatever you make of the hunk of wood. And whatever you make is going to have an impact on the viewer.

Re: New platter

#14

Re: New platter

Julie

>Beautiful looking platter Sir.

what type of wood is it ?

thanks for sharing

Re: New platter

#15

Re: New platter

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>Soooo, you were expecting $10,000 for the platter? :>)

Re: New platter

#16

Steven Antonucci

Not a big fan of the bump, John

steve antonucci

>Like others have said, the wood was "good enough" on it's own and didn't need it. Originally I thought it was the bottom where the dovetail for the chuck was.

Can you mount it and turn out the bump?

Steven

Re: New platter

#17

Re: New platter

john lucas

>Great post Rick. That's what we want to hear.

Re: New platter

#18

Mike Stafford

One word for that.....

Mike Stafford

>Gorgeous!

Re: New platter

#19

Walnut

john lucas

>

Re: New platter

#20

Re: Not a big fan of the bump, John

john lucas

>Steve My main reason for the bump was to make it seem less functional. I think that was a mistake on 2 parts. One was it doesn't show the flame figure and the other is the center divot. I think if I left it in I should have just made a big bump. Not sure why I did that at the time. I have considered remounting it but I turned away the dovetails on the back so I would have the job of recentering it using the vacuum chuck which would probably be very difficult.

Re: New platter

#21

Re: New platter

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I'll weigh in with the others:

-- fancy wood with a simple design;

-- plain wood with a fancy design.

I like turning crotch pieces. I have 9 walnut pieces in progress right now. Two are going to be very shallow bowls, the others are very flat and plain platters.

I like to have the crotch flame running through the center of the piece to keep it balanced.

The nice thing about crotch pieces is that every tree has them. Lumber mills don't like them, so the loggers trim them off and leave them laying in the woods. The firewood people don't like them because they are hard to split. That leaves plenty for me!!

Re: New platter

#22

Steven Antonucci

Recenter wouldn't be so hard

steve antonucci

>Mark the center of the platter with a compass by swinging an arc from the edge with the compas set at the radius. Take a couple of points, put some tape in the middle so so can see it, and then use the tailstock to recenter. When it set, turn on the vacuum.

Steve

Re: New platter

#23

Re: Recenter wouldn't be so hard

john lucas

>Steve That's what I had considered. Since I might remove the center anyway leaving divot from the compass won't be a problem. I'm concerned about the depth in the very center. I think If I continue the arc of the bowl portion It might get awful thin right in the center.

Re: New platter

#24

Re: New platter

john lucas

>Thanks brian. I like having the crotch either in the middle or near. Unfortunatly this is how my friend cut the wood so my choice was either to make the piece much smaller or use as much wood as I could.

If I was making this piece to the best of my ability I would have sacrificed the size and worked on balancing the figure within the shape. I think too often we try to use the maximum size of the wood and consequently we end up with a piece that is less than it really could have been.

In this case I thought I should keep the wood nearly full size because I thought my friend would like it better.

On the next piece I which is now my piece of wood I will look at it much harder and see what i can come up with.

Re: New platter

#25

I 3rd, Re-mount and de- bump

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>