Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Dust management with a fan

Posts

Dust management with a fan

#1

Dust management with a fan

wilbur

>I thought I'd share an idea I've been using in my workshop to help with the dust issue while turning. This came to me when I was at work. I'm a pediatric hematologist/oncologist, and in our hospital we have positive pressure isolation rooms for patients who are immunocompromised. These rooms are designed to keep airborne microbes out by maintaining a positive pressure inside the room compared to the hallway. The way this works is that with enough pressure, when the door to the room is opened, air will flow outward into the hall, and any airborne microbes won't be able to "swim upstream" into the room. There's a lot more than this that's involved, of course, but this is the general idea.

So at my lathe I was busy getting sprayed with dust and chips, and it occurred to me that I could use the same sort of mechanism while turning. I set up a floorstanding fan so that it blew across the piece I was turning so that dust and chips were blown away from me. It worked really well. I could see that the majority of dust were turned back by the air blown by the fan. The "Blow your nose and look at the tissue" dust assay (if you know what I mean) was much lower, and my clothes were much cleaner afterwards.

Now, this isn't meant to take the place of a good dust collector, hood, and air cleaner, or a Trend Airshield type of device (which I don't have), but it does significantly cut down on the amount of dust that winds up in your face. Certainly, there is still dust in the air, but it will have to travel around for a bit before it winds back at your face.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#2

Re: Dust management with a fan

Stuart Johnson

>I guess I do about the same thing. My dust collection is a box fan set behind the lathe blowing away with a furnace filter held in place by air movement. Being cheap I save the barely used furnace filter from the house. It doesn't take much sanding to see how effective it is. I still wear a 3M half face mask under my face shield.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#3

Darth Vader Replies

Barry Irby

>I set up the hose from my DC near my piece on the lathe when I am sanding. I clip the hose into the tool rest and bring it up close.

I am thinking of a box with filter hooked to a five inch hose behind the lathe. (I already have the hose)

If I sand walnut I find it goes through my shirt and my tee shirt is dark in front with a white stripe. Took a while to realize the stripe is because my button up shirt has the strip up the front that is for the buttons.

My son says "lets go blow some black", when he is turning walnut.

I wear a North 7700 half mask (black) under my face shield, which has a black frame and I had on black shooters muffs. Turned to my son and said, "I'm your father, Luke". He didn't get it. I have a "Headlight" I am trying to add to the rig. (A great little tool)

I have found that without the personal protective mask, my face is the best dust collector in the shop. The fact that my face and tee shirt collect so much dust tells me that I am not doing a good enough job of collecting dust, even with a DC and Ambient Air Cleaner. Scheming on a down Draft table for sanding.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#4

Re: Dust management with a fan

john lucas

>Wilbur My best friends dad was a production turner for over 50 years. He rigged a cardboard propeller on the outboard side of his old Delta so it blew toward the inboard side. It blew all the dust away from him. He turned and sanded more wood than most of us will ever see and he's still alive at 80 so it must have done some good.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#5

Re: Dust management with a fan

Carole Valentine

>Yep. I use the box fan rig for right now. Works well when you put it close to the lathe. I ordered a JDS 760-ER air Cleaner and it arrived today. I was just going to leave it in the box and install it in the new shop, but I couldn't stand it, so I unpacked it and set it on a rolling cart for the time being. It pulls a lot of air through and is much quieter than I thought it would be. I won't order the DC until the room is finished for it in the new shop. I have some research to do on those.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#6

Re: Me, too, Wilbur...

Allen Neighbors

>I have two exhaust fans in one of my shop windows. One is slow, one is fast. One of them is on, year round, sometimes both. I have a home-built air cleaner that hangs over my lathe, that draws air through 4 air conditioner filters. And I also use a floor-stand fan that blows across (the piece that I'm turning) and toward the window.

Well-diggers in Montana don't get any colder than I do in the winter.

But I don't get dusty shorts :) and I don't worry about the color of what comes out of my nose. I have more trouble with smoke from fighting range fires than I do with the dust in my shop.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#7

Re: Dust management with a fan

JohnKJordan in East TN

>My good turner friend started using a different fan method 20 years ago - when the weather cooperates, he used a large fan mounted just behind the lathe which tended to suck all the dust and shavings out into the yard. I'll bet it "cleaned up" small pieces of sandpaper, steel wool, paper towels, ...

JKJ

Re: Dust management with a fan

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Dust management with a fan

Mike Stafford

>Wilbur, great minds think alike. I use a very similar arrangement in my shop. My lathe is parallel to the wall. At the tailstock end I have a window into which I have mounted a 14" high velocity fan exhausting out of the shop. It pulls the air away from me very noticeably. In the Summer I will have a box fan behind me and to the left of my headstock so it is directed toward the window. It helps me keep cool and further channels the dust toward the fan in the window. I ,too, use the kleenex test and it seems to work for me. Before I had this arrangement the shop would be layered in a fine dust each morning from all the sanding dust that settled out of the air. Now this does not happen.

In the old lathe studio at John C. Campbell there was a very large fan mounted in the end wall exhausting from the shop. There were windows along the side walls. If you opened the windows and turned on that fan it would pull not only the dust but small bits of sandpaper out the opening.....Of course these options for dust control don't work as well during cold weather...

Re: Dust management with a fan

#9

Small clarification

wilbur

>Just a small clarification: the physics of directing dust particle movement are much different from a fan PUSHING dust away, as when I set up my fan on my side of the lathe, compared to a fan PULLING dust to it, like a box fan +/- filter set up on the opposite side of the lathe. PUSHING dust is actually more effective than trying to PULL dust towards you.

Here's a thought experiment: Imagine a balloon floating in a room. Blow at it. You can move the balloon pretty easily from a fair distance. Now try to suck air in to draw the balloon towards you. Almost impossible.

That's why in our isolation rooms in the hospital are set up to blow air out of the room instead of trying to set up a vacuum in the hallway to draw the air out of the room.

I've seen a number of setups with a fan and filter or some other sort of vacuum/dust collecting apparatus on the side of the lathe opposite from where you stand, but I don't recall seeing a fan placed on the operator side of the lathe, which is why I thought of posting this tip.

Again, this isn't to be in place of a good dust collector and hood. But I've found that keeping a fan on your side of the lathe is really good for preventing that first spray of dust and chips from getting on you, even the stuff the dust collector can't pick up.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#10

Forgot to add

wilbur

>I see the fan on the operator side as being very good at preventing dust and chips from getting to the turner, and being terrible at dust collection, whereas a fan on the other side of the lathe is very good at trapping and collecting dust, but being not as effective at controlling the initial spray of dust and chips that hit the turner.

Re: Dust management with a fan

#11

Re: Forgot to add

Stuart Johnson

>One more thing in favor of the fan behind the turner is without AC in the shop fans are a must in this part of the country. I had never thought about it as dust avoidance but from mid spring to late fall I usually have one going.