Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

end-grain finishing

Posts

end-grain finishing

#1

end-grain finishing

GaryG in MD

>This question is probably as much about time/quality/price as it is about technique, but technique is the part I'm most interested in right now.

I haven't done a lot of small end-grain turning (read bottle stoppers, mushrooms, etc.), but I've just turned a few Rosand-style ring holders out of canary wood for the ladies in my life. Canary is fine grained but has lots and lots of tiny pores. My normal finish is Watco Abraloned to 4000. On side grain, that gives a nice soft luster. These ring holders have a lot of end grain in them, and the pores tend to be visible, on casual viewing, as a dulling of the sheen. Upon closer inspection, with good eyes, each pore is visible.

My initial reaction is that I don't like this. I usually avoid filling pores the old-fashioned way (wet sanding and forcing the resulting slurry into the pores) because I have felt that reduces the brilliance of the underlying wood, but does it really?

So my questions for all you bottle stopper makers are:

1) Should I just live with it, or 2) should I go for a smooth finish by filling the pores with a) slurry or b) a surface finish product like a varnish?

Clearly, there are questions of time/effort/salary/cost here, but since I'm just a hobbyist making gifts for family members, those don't interest me as much as the final result.

Is it just me as a turner being picky, or do the customers see those pores as a negative in the finish?

TIA for all your thoughts, Gary

Re: end-grain finishing

#2

Re: end-grain finishing

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>You might like the Ray Key method. Briwax (or similar) applied with steel wool then burnished. A little twist that I add is burnishing with a pop-sicle stick. I shape the stick with a few strokes across coarse sandpaper to thin the end. I like the skew profile for cleaning up lines that are difficult to sand, and just follow the contour...burnishing and shining. Final burnish is with toweling.

You can try this on top of your Watco without hurting anything.

Re: end-grain finishing

#3

Re: end-grain finishing

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>People who like plastic will probably see the pores as flaws.

People who like wood will see the pores as natural and normal.

Generally, pores are a problem only if they collect dirt. Forcing a sanding slurry in will fill the pores but they will still be visible. I've never noticed a reduced luster from filling the pores, but I don't leave any traces of the sanding slurry on the surface of the wood.

Re: end-grain finishing

#4

Re: end-grain finishing

Ed Moore

>Gary,

Have you tried using Shellawax? It is an excellent finish for small end-grain objects.

Ed

Re: end-grain finishing

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: end-grain finishing

Brad Vietje

>Gary,

I'd say this has more to do with expectations -- see Brian's comment above. If you want to avoid pores, you could select a fine grained wood like Sugar Maple or Beech, etc...

Sanding sealers can be used to fill pores, but that can dull a finish somewhat; Russ has posted many comments about that.

Another method is to use a porous wood, say Ash or Oak, and hi-lite the pores as a feature with patinating wax or shoe polish for light woods, or liming wax for dark woods, then wiped off everywhere except the filled pores, and followed by a few applications of your favorite finish. These effects can look really cool, and on larger, curved surfaces, can really take a piece to a whole new level.

Clear skies and safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: end-grain finishing

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: end-grain finishing

Mike Stafford

>Gary, I turn a lot of work with end grain as I primarily turn boxes. It has been my experience you have to apply multiple coats to some woods and even then you can expect some pores to remain.

It is interesting that you are having this problem with canary wood as I just turned a box from some last month and I did not have any problems with visible pores. Are you sure you have sanded the wood to a fine enough grit? I found the canary wood I have to be easy to sand and finish. It was sort of soft as hardwoods go.

Re: end-grain finishing

#7

Re: end-grain finishing

GaryG in MD

>Mike,

Thanks for the ideas -- I'll look into the process.

I love your 3-piece "canteen" vase -- the shape and finish are truly outstanding. Highly innovative. Congrats on a well-deserved 'cover' on WoW! You made a heck of a splash on entry!

Cheers, Gary

Re: end-grain finishing

#8

Re: end-grain finishing

GaryG in MD

>Brian,

Thanks for your thoughts. I'm definitely not going for the "plastic" look, and I expect I may be being overly critical, but since this is my first work with a shape that provides a view predominantly of end grain, I want to come up with a standard procedure that will reliably give me a look that I like and can be proud of -- hopefully without excessive work and time.

You're right about the slurry -- if properly done, it should do the job. I may have to revisit that if some of these other techniques don't work.

Cheers, Gary

Re: end-grain finishing

#9

Re: end-grain finishing

GaryG in MD

>Ed,

Good idea -- thanks -- I'll give it a try.

Cheers, Gary

Re: end-grain finishing

#10

Re: end-grain finishing

GaryG in MD

>Brad,

Welcome back. Thanks for your reply.

I like the idea of contrasting fillers on some pieces, but that's not the look I'm going for here. I know what you mean though, and I'll keep it in mind for future pieces.

Cheers, Gary

Re: end-grain finishing

#11

here's what I'm talking about...

GaryG in MD

>Mike,

Thanks for your reply. I like your boxes a lot and always look at your pix. Yes, I like canary wood because it's very easy to work with and has nice colors.

Here's a photo of what I'm talking about. Maybe I'm wiping the Watco off too quickly. This has a couple thin coats of Watco and a couple light coats of a matte acrylic sealer that I was experimenting with -- after sanding to 400 (so as not to prevent the Watco from soaking in). (Sorry about the poor photo, but I don't have a macro lens on my digital camera, so this is an 'inset' from a larger photo.)

Do you think I should be able to get rid of these pores by just putting on more or thicker coats of Watco? I'd prefer to just use the Watco and skip the acrylic. I'm trying to avoid wax because of some earlier negative comments about that on WC.

Cheers, Gary


img

Re: end-grain finishing

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: here's what I'm talking about...

Mike Stafford

>Gary, was this finish applied on the lathe or off? I apply my finishes on the lathe. I give the wood some time to absorb the finish and wipe off the excess. Then I turn on the lathe and with sections of paper towel I friction polish the finish until it is dry. Before applying the next coat I will use 7/0 steel wool or a white 3M pad or both to level the finish. Tack off the piece. I then apply the next coat and repeat the friction polish, steel wool/3M pad/tack off steps. I repeat this for as many cycles as it takes to get the piece looking like I want usually 5 or 6. After the last coat I use a piece of fine felt to really buff up the piece and polish it. Let the finish fully cure for a day or so then apply a smidgen of wax and you are good to go. I think you just need to do the friction polish step to even out the finish or run your piece through the Beall wheels.

Re: end-grain finishing

#13

Me too, Mike

Carole Valentine

>I also turned a canary wood box. Actually the end grain portion looked better than the side grain as I recall! I can't go back and look at it because it's sold, but Barb turned one in my shop this week and it was beautiful. Of course every piece of wood is different. I found the wood I had to be almost oily. It turned beautifully.

Re: end-grain finishing

#14

Re: here's what I'm talking about...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Do you think I should be able to get rid

>of these pores by just putting on more

>or thicker coats of Watco?

I haven't had good luck filling excessive porosity with oil (and your's does look excessive). The sanding slurry method fills the pores with fine opaque particles but I think clear usually looks better. I ususlly wipe on coats of shellac-based friction polish (Mylands) which drys fast and will work under any other finish. I sometimes use a coat or two of lacquer-based sander sealer. A few times I've used a method I read somewhere than involves wiping on thick CA.

JKJ

Re: end-grain finishing

#15

Re: end-grain finishing *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>I use a seal coat of Deft lacquer under oil finishes to solve this problem. It also seals the end grain to keep it from absorbing more of the oil and becoming darker than the flat-grain areas.

Be aware that there will be differences in the answers you get, and sometimes an argument, because not everyone is talking about the same species. This is because "Canary Wood" has become a generic term for any tropical harswood species that is yellow, and the color is often the only property they share.


Deft lacquer under an oil finish

Re: end-grain finishing

#16

Re: At first glance...

Allen Neighbors

>it looked like 'orange peel' when a sprayed finish is applied with too much pressure, and too little finish.

I don't know what to tell you about it, other than to sand, and finish, and sand and finish, etc..

Re: end-grain finishing

#17

Thanks Mike, John, Allen, Carole, & Russ

GaryG in MD

>I was pleased to go back and see this thread open up again.

I appreciate all the good info.

I've been doing the finishing off the lathe, but I see the advantages of doing it on the lathe -- next time!

I'll attack the problem in the three I have made to date and figure out what it takes to get it done based on your comments. I'll post the results when I can.

Thanks for the great help, Gary