>First, let me welcome you to the more conviences side of turning!
I have the Talon for my General, thought about just getting an insert for the Jet Mini, it was annoying changing jaws, knew darn well changing adapters was not going to work, bought a second Talon with just the #2 jaws, then got annoyed if the spigot jaws were on The General and I wanted them for a job on the mini, bought another set of jaws, had a piece in one Talon, didn't want to take it out to do a rush job because I'd never get it seated perfect again, bought a naked Talon because.................. where will it end?!?!
To answer your question, stick with the Talon, you know the jaws fit perfect and it's well worth the price. Just try not to get on my merry-go-round! : )
>>bought a naked Talon because..... where will it end?!?!
>Just try not to get on my merry-go-round! : )
Hey, us kids love to play on the merry-go-round! I'm up to eight chucks now which nearly eliminates changing jaws for me. This makes limited turning time far more efficient.
I don't see any ethical or moral delemma with too many chucks as long as it doesn't take food away from the family. And a chuck addiction seems cheaper than cigarette smoking, womanizing, or playing the slots.
>I would recommend a second chuck. Welcome to spinny slippery slope. Go on and get two or three. And six or eight sets of jaws.
I have three chucks. 2 Nova's that work with that goofy key and one that works with the Tommy bars, but the jaws are all interchangeable, that's important. The keys are interchangeable and so are all the screws and tools. So, now that you have a Talon, stick with chucks that give you interchangeability. The talon is a good chuck, go with that or one that is completely compatible.
(It seems that everything comes with its own screws and parts and after a while you are looking at some little thing and wondering what was that for or worse, where did I put the.....) Keep it simple.
Buy a set of spare screws from Oneway. Whatever screws they have on the chucks. You will lose a screw for the jaws and try to figure out if its OK to run one jaw with one screw. Have spares or you will be down in the shavings with a magnet. (You do have a magnet don't you?) Get Oneway screws so they will match, or you will have 1 slotted screw from the local Borg and 7 Allen screws from Oneway. Don't make me explain how hateful that is.
One thing I did not like about Nova was they apparently sell all their chucks with the same jaws on them. I have three standard sets. I don't even know if they think those are the most useful or if they just have an excess of that size. Its great if Oneway will sell the chuck naked or with the jaws you want.
>I'm going to take this from a slightly different angle. I have 2 chucks, an SN2 and a Nova midi (I turn on a Nova 1624). My Oneway Jumbo jaws are virtually always mounted on my Nova Midi. Sure, it's not as powerful as the SN2 (or the Talon) but bowls and plates are mostly light in weight and you will be taking light cuts to finish up the bottom. The Nova midi is not expensive and might be an alternative for you. Truth be told, if money was no object, I would have one company's chucks so everything (screws, wrenches) matches but the Nova is a good alternative in my opinion.
>Count me in on the how many chucks can a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck could own chucks. I remember that awful decision to finally buy a chuck. I spend $139 on the original Nova (which I still have) That was an awful lot of money back then and I agonized over it for a long time. After all I had been turning everything with faceplates quite successfully.
I got tired of the tommy bars(which I actually like on days when my arthritic wrist acts up) so I bought a Vicmarc. Now I have 2 Vicmarcs and one Grizzly and still have 2 sets of jaws that have to be changed everynow and then. I'm rationalizing this by convincing myself that it will bring more money at the tool auction when I go backrupt from buying too many tools.
A problem with changing jaws all the time is illustrated by a problem I had last week with the workpiece getting off register with only a slight bit of aggressive pressure. Then I discovered that I had mixed up the jaws and had two different sets mixed, and that is a no - no. I think I will order another Grizzly knock-off.
>I bought a G8784 and it is a piece of junk. I has wobbled from day one. This is the cheaper of there wood chucks. I should have contacted Grizzly immediately, but didn't. Instead, I bought a new Talon, of which I know have 2.
>I have the jumbo jaws for my Talon. It doesn't take more than 2 minutes to change the jaws, but having said that I'm considering a second chuck just so I don't need to change jaws. It is a small annoyance. I do like the large capacity and I use it in both compression and expansion modes. On some bowls I don't have a large enough piece of scrap for a jam chuck.
>The most 4-jaw chucks I have ever owned at one time is 4. When I bought a new lathe that none of the old chukcs fit (nova doesn't make an adapter for M33) I bought two chucks with the new lathe. Not nearly enough. I just bought two more Talons. I figure when I get to the number that JKJ has, I'll have enough, maybe.
>Mine is the copy of the Vicmarc and is quite fine. Several other friends have one and it's been good. It's not as good as the Vicmarc but is a decent chuck. Since there have been quality problems with some of the Grizzly chucks I would definitely check them out when I receive it and call the if there are any problems.
>I am not sure you can have to many chucks. I am up to four and am thinking of buying another. I had more jaws than chucks and so got tired of changing jaws and looking for screws in the chip pile.