>There was a huge thread on the AAW forum due to the article in the Journal regarding the deforestation of the Rain Forest and endangered exotic woods. ***please note: this is NOT a request for a repeat of everything said on the AAW forum! :~/
Gary Evans tells us the Dogwood are suffering a mold infection, cause unknown, could be some bug got a free ride on an imported piece of wood. Yes, he is just guess there is NO fact there.
We have the invasion and complete devastion of trees by the Gypsy moths here in the northeastern shores of the USA. YES, this is a bug some scientist brought to this country for some research or experiment. He should be hung at high noon!
The Chestnut had a blight, what 50 years ago?, which virtually wiped them out.
Are there enough trees on this planet that this need not concern me? Are enough trees being replanted so we don't have to worry? I'm not concerned that we'll run out of wood to turn, I guess I'm just thinking out loud.
My opionion: someone concerned with maintaining a wood supply for turning need only be concerned if their heart is set on just one kind of wood. American chestnut tuners are having a rough time about now! If it gets so bad that all species of trees die off, I suspect all the turners will be gone as well.
>Ruth, I posted a question about this in the main message board.
To keep this short, I don't think I was able to make my point?question very well. Mush of the tropical hardwood is being cut for local use as fuel and other timber uses and about an equal amount is being slashed and burned to clear the land for subsistence farming. They are cutting and burning he timebar not because we are using it or even that we want it, but to get rid of it so they can use the land. The land is only suitable for agriculture for a few years because the soil is poor. My question is, since they are going to cut and burn the timber anyway, wouldn't it make more sense to harvest the timber first and let us make bowls and bottle stoppers and furniture out of it that people could enjoy for generations rather than turn it into ashes?
I know that the question is simplistic. There are logistics problems. No one has the equipment to harvest the trees locally. No one has the trucks to transport it to the mills and markets. Perhaps the trees being burned are not the ones we want to buy. But it makes no sense to lay a guilt trip on me when I am way down the list of the forces involved.
The problem with the Dogwoods is Anthracnose. There are treatments for it if its a yard tree. Difficult and expensive to apply in the wild. It is also temperature related. The disease does not thrive in the entire range of the dogwoods and has less effect in the cooler ranges. Also, the Chinese or Japanese dogwoods such as the Kousas are unaffected and there are cross breeds that are not affected.
The Chestnuts may make a come back. The blight was brought over here on the Chinese Chestnuts which are unaffected. Perhaps they developed a resistance over the years. There is a group here in VA that are cross breeding Chinese Chestnuts with American Chestnuts. They are looking for one that is perhaps 15/16 American, retains the resistance, but the other characteristics of the American trees. They may be getting close and hopefully will start planting them back in the wild soon. This was truly and ecological disaster. They were the Redwoods of the East and maybe they will come back.
The Gypsy Moth has an enemy. Some sort of disease or pest that attacks them. As the Gypsy Moths move throught he woods the pest begins to flourish and gets the upper hand and the moths die off. So there is an ebb and flow.
And then there is the Emerald Ash Borer. They are cutting Ash trees in the mid west in swarths miles wide trying to limit the movement of the insects. Lets hope they get it right.
We should be careful. Don't ship infested wood. Lets take the long view.
>Some Turner's prize the oddest wood. I personally like Burls. It is my understanding that no one truly knows what causes burls or exactly what they are. Just had a conversation with my son (the one with a horticulture Degree) and there are theories that they are related to soil culture and microclimate. They might be a virus or even some other diseases. You and I have had the conversation about how to cause them. So here we are concerned the world may running out of wood and some of us would consider causing some sort of disease to trees because we want the pretty wood.
>You and I agree regarding the exotics; Wilford B. posted the best response to that issue over on the AAW board.
Thank you for all the information regarding the disease and bug issues, that's what I was looking for, along with what was being done to help.
Whatever it is that attacks the gypsy moths should do it faster! I remember a few years ago "they" imported big black flies that were supposed to eat the gypsy moth eggs and all we had was an epidemic of huge black, slow flies.
>That was an interesting thread and few tree huggers really keep up with what industry has been doing for years. Case in point, Twenty-five years ago Weyerhaeuser saw the depletion of oak
at some point in the future and also the rapid harvesting of the Brazilin forests. Hence put their scientists to work and came up with a fast growing tree they call Lyptus which matures in about 15 years. They created large plantations in Brazil that were clear cut years ago to grow this species. It is an excellent replacement for the much slower growing oak and at some point in time we will no longer be able to afford oak cabinets or flooring but will indeed be using Lyptus. Go to any flooring retailer now and you can see the different products made using Lyptus. There are many other new trees in the works by this industry. Leave it to capitalism not governments or groups and the future is not as dismal as we are led to believe.
>Bill, interesting about the Oak. There is some sort of disease her in VA that is killing Oaks pretty fast. I have two oaks in my front yard that I think are not too long for this world. Seems like the limbs die from the bottom up.
>Is that disease oak wilt? Oak wilt is a common disease hitting trees in the red oak family hardest and will kill a tree within months. White oaks also get it, but it may take them several years to die. The disease can be spread by pruning during the growing season. I suspect that woodpeckers or other wild critters also spread it because I have periodically have patches in my woods where all of the red oak family trees die.
>I spoke to my son (the one with the horticulture degree, not the soldier)and he tells me that the long term "fix" for the dogwoods lies in the breeding program. Breeding in the disease resistance. He also tells me that the program for the Chestnuts is concentrating on selecting trees that are disease resistant and then interbreeding them to create genetic diversity, and then selecting them for other desirable traits. Some may be selected for being fruitless and tall and slender....good street trees. Others may be selected for producing good timber and still other for the nuts. The good news is that America is so large and diverse that there are still native trees that were not affected in the chestnuts and elms, so there is breeding stock available.
Another success story may be the Paulownia. (Princess Tree) A favorite in Japan, it escaped into the wild here. They shipped China dishes here packed in crates filled with paulownia seeds as packing. The seeds sifted out and paulownia trees sprang up along the rail roads. These are the trees you hear about people stealing them out of someone's yard and selling it to the Japanese for thousands of dollars. There are a group of devoted people growing them for commerce. Now comes the word that plantation grown trees will not sell for thousands each, but OTOH they grow very fast and may be a replacement for the pines grown on plantations. We may see plywood made of paulownia in a few years.
I did a bit more research on the Dogwood Anthracnose. Turns out it was first discovered in New York state and Pennsylvania back in the '70's. Just another case of the Yankees moving South and ruining things for the local folks. 8^]
But in my not so humble opinion at the rate that mankind deforests, we are actively increasing desertification, we all should be out there planting trees, as many as we can possibly can, did you people heard about Indonesia will be planting 70 million trees? All in one day!
That kind of concerted effort is what is needed, remember that trees are the ones that create food and shelter for about every thing else, and yes money and jobs grow in trees too.
Let's!
Jorge
who planted over a cool million and wants to go out and plant some more...
>Jim King has posted some interesting links about forests. One showed the amount of forests in North America since the pilgrims arrived and now. There is a great increase since the early 1900's. I'm sorry but I don't have a link but a search on his name might come up with it. If remember right he also posted links about trees in Peru.
>I Planted some pines on some land I own, but if was about 150,000. Unless you count that I planted them twice. My father and I planted them when I was a kid, then I inherited them and harvested them and planted them again. So maybe I can claim 300,000. Did you actually plant a million trees? How did you manage that?
When I turned a mere 48, I decided it was time to do something on the lines of "paying rent to the planet", so after some research I found some reforestation companies and joined one, yes I went over the million and over the years I think I managed to plant at least another 100,000 on my own, both by planting acorns or seeds and seedlings I start.
I was not fortunate to plant those trees in my own land, you are lucky you did, and now my pipe dream is to go and start reforesting Spain, the ancestral land that needs them badly...
>Way to go Jorge. I also have planted way over a million. I have a small 20x20' nursery in the back yard now and collect local seed and produce about 7000 trees per year. I spent my career in Africa working with farmers to increase their yields using nitrogen fixing trees in their cropping systems. This enabled them to stop using the shifting cultivation system. The shifting system clears an area, burning the trees for a potassium kick then using the soil fertility to crop for maybe two years before the fertility drops and the weeds take over.
Some tropicals work well in plantations while others don't. I have experience with African mahogany which get an insect that destroys the growning point in a monoculture. Isoberlinia (zebra wood) works quite well in plantations.
We should all be carefull when sending our wood all around, we could be spreading insects or disease.
>Forests in this country are not the problem. Some species are in trouble but as long as it is a marketable tree economic pressures will see that it survives, in most cases. It might be a hybrid form but it will survive. The trees that have a disease and no market value are doomed.
The rain forest is where the battle is being lost. There the trees are a hindrance to farming so slash and burn is the MO. The problem (as another poster stated) is that all the nutrients are in the trees. The soil is very poor so after the trees are slashed and burned the nutrients are released but that only lasts for 2 or 3 years of crops and then the soil is depleted which leads to more slash and burn. The cycle continues. I can't blame the people, they are just trying to survive.
IMO, the only way to save the rain forest is to make the trees valuable to the people that live on the land. That only happens if they reaped the benefits of being good stewards of the forest. Basically a good portion of the money made off of responsible timber harvesting needs to go to the "little" people. Then and only then will the rain forest stop disappearing.
It is in the best interest of the ENTIRE planet that deforestation is slowed and eventually reversed.
>To answer the question directly, I think we're ok with the number of trees we have for a while...
However, the little things add up.
Someone tosses a cigarette starting a wildfire and we lose acres of old growth forest.
Someone sees a burl on a tree and cuts the tree to take it.
Someone imports an exotic from Asia, and we get a bug or disease.
Someone cuts a field to build a house, but doesn't replace the forest elsewhere on the property.
These are all acts that can be carried out by an individual with the thought that it's "just me, so it's no big deal." The problem is when many of us adopt the attitude that our actions are small and do not matter. I'm a long standing tree hugger and avid hiker, and I can tell you that attitudes towards our natural resources vary from preservationists (no one can use it) to the outright destructive.
Within our own community, there is a reverence for the providers- the trees- of the materials we all use, but how many of you have seen names carved into the bark, nails pounded to hand signs, or trees removed because they were "in the way"? I have three maple saplings that are about 20' tall that are growing too close to the house. I could handle the job in 5 minutes with my Stihl, but I'll be digging up the roots and transplanting them in the early spring...
>I am impressed. A million! And not on your land, other than all the land is yours and ours. Thanks.
And Ed, There are nitrogen fixing trees? I knew there were legumes that did that, but not trees. Can you farm among them or do you burn them and till them in. (We tilled legumes and other "green manure" plants in on the farm I grew up on.)
sure is nice to find a kindred soul, and you went over and beyond by promoting sustainable agriculture, which I have not done although I practice it. What nitrogen fixing trees did you use besides isoberlinia?, around here I plant black locust, plus vetch and clover, and peas and beans of course.
>What we do exchanging woods may be a little bad, the great problem is pallets, in this day and age of "globalization", the main culprit are the big business that harvest all the hardwoods everywhere, convert them into pallets and send them in a one way trip to somewhere, absolutely no precautions are taken and all manners of insects, fungus and God knows what, gets a free ride to every corner of the planet, so that added to stress from the global warming is one of the reasons many trees are sick all over, here in our neck of the woods, the firs and hackmatacks (tamaracks or larches ellswhere)are dying an masse, both love the cold and wet and it is getting to hot and dry for them.
Maybe all this wide spread of pests and diseases may have a beneficial effect in the long run, some trees will disapear but others will develop tolerance or resistance and very hardy species will emerge, but lets not just wait to see what happens, let's get actively involved and plant more and more trees,some will die, some will prosper.
The equation is very simple, no trees = no humans.
>Jorge and Ed and Steve, goodness you guys really do care. Thank you. I moved into my home last year, decided I had way too much lawn to mow, my neighbor plowed up the back 40' x 50' yard, I am going to plant trees. A LOT of trees. Probably not a million, but a lot.
I must say, you gentlemen have given some wonderful information and have the experience to back it up. Sure do wish there were a lot more like you.
>Easy on the lumber industry folks, my uncle worked for one and they spend a fortune combating imported and domestic diseases and bugs. It seems obvious to me these corporations would be cutting off their noses to spite their faces to do otherwise. From what I have read we have more trees now than we did when we got here. That said, we have cut down a ton of Mesquites on our property but planted Pecans, Oaks and uh.. Crapemertles, haven't turned a CrapeMertle yet but one of them is getting pretty big!
>Jeorge, Imported vegatables etc. used to be treated before they could be imported further into the US. The Florida departement of agriculture used to stop all trucks before they left the state. But I doubt they bothered with non-food pallets. These days people are more concerned with pesticides than they are with diseases. It's a tough debate.