Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Thompson & Roly Munro

Posts

Thompson & Roly Munro

#1

Thompson & Roly Munro

Ruth Harding

>Looking at th Thompson tool many of you discuss it seems to look like the Roly Munro cutter, but without the protective housing the Roly has.

Since I have only seen the Thompson in pictures I don't know but would be interested to find out.

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

#2

Do you mean Mike Hunter's?

GaryG in MD

>

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

#3

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

john lucas

>Ruth I'd say that it is similar but I'm not sure what kind of steel is in the Monroe cutters. Some people really like them and some people have problems with the cutters clogging due to the space between the cover and the cutter. Since I have never owned one I can only spit back what I've read. It does elimanate catches by limiting the cut. It would be good to hear from users.

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

#4

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

Bob Jensen

>Some months back Jimmy Clewes was doing a hands-on class for our club and he had a covered tool that he swore by, I am not sure if that was the Munro or not for sure but he really spoke highly of it. Well we were using some freshly cut blanks and his hollower simply would not cut the wood at all no matter what he tried. So Mike Hunter handed him one of his cutters and Jimmy soon thereafter put his away back into its case and has promoted Mike's ever since.

bob

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

#5

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

Allen Neighbors

>John, I have a tool that is exactly a copy of the Munro tool that was made by a friend in Australia. It does clog up quite easily on really wet wood, but is awesome on not-so-wet green wood. Without the guard on it, it becomes an articulating Hunter tool. :)

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

#6

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

Mike Nelson

>I purchased the Monro Hollower and wish I hadn't. The 'hood on the tool is difficult to adjust in order to keep it from clogging. The hood is supposed to stop catches, which it does, it also causes the tool to 'dig in to one particular spot while you are trying to smooth the inside of a HF. I finally removed the 'hood and find with a little practice you don't need it, which means a much lower cost if you get the Thompson. A small bend on the end of a 1/2 shaft creates a pretty decent articulation. JMO, Mike

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

#7

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

Ruth Harding

>Thanks guys. maybe it's a Hunter I'm talking about.....I get confused with all the tools discussed here...hard to remember names.

I have adjusted the Munroe so that more of the cutter is exposed, since then I have no clogging. When I read some of the older turning books and see the tools they used I am often embarrassed to have a collection of turning stuff that costs way over $1,000 all told - not including my Stubby. So, if I have what is the same as another tool it's one less to lust after!

thanks again.

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

#8

Re: Thompson & Roly Munro

Pascal Oudet

>from what I've read (IIRC), the Hunter tool has a carbide cutter. the Munro one is HSS (though very long lasting).

I use the Munro all the time during hollowing (when I have an opening of at least 1"). Depending on adjustement, you can really remove a lot of wood quickly, or very fine shavings. It's definitely my tool of choice for hollowing and I recommend it. I have no problems with clogging, but for those who have, try inserting a very thin washer under the guard to increase the vertical distance between cutter and guard (it's especially valid when the cutter is new)

Pascal