Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Turning Tools for a Newbie

Posts

Turning Tools for a Newbie

#1

Turning Tools for a Newbie

Justin Fields

>Hi. I posted this over in the tool area, but it was suggested that I post it here in the turning-specific section...

Hello.

I'm just getting started with turning and I'd love some advice on turning tools. This is a hobby for me, not anything like a professional aspiration. So, I'd like to get some basic tools, but I don't want them to be so cheap and junky that I end up sort-changing myself on quality over the long term.

Do you have any advice on a way to proceed with this purchase in a sensible way? For example, I've looked at kits at WoodCraft (the club where I work is one of their locations), Rockler, etc. Are those pre-packaged selections from one manufacturer (Crown Pro-PM, Sorby, etc.) worthwhile?

Any thoughts or recommendations would be greatly appreciated!

Justin

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#2

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

RevDoug

>Justin, it sounds like a cop-out answer, but it really depends on what you want to turn. If you're turning spindles, you'll want a spindle gouge,a parting tool, and a skew. If you're going to turn bowls you'll want the parting tool and a good bowl gouge. These can be added too as needed or wanted with a straight scraper, a half round scraper, hollowing tools of various descriptions. Of course you'll have to have a grinder and some kind of sharpening jig. The list goes on and on. Not trying to discourage, but you really do need to get together with a turner in your area and get some hands on and advice.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#3

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie *LINK*

Cyril Griesbach

>Justin, this is the very best advise I can give you because if someone had given it to me when I started I'd have saved several years of frustration and lots of money.

Find your nearest AAW chapter and get connected with them. There will be many people there that will be very willing to help you in more ways than you can now imagine. Here is a link to locating a chapter.


AAW Chapter List

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#4

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Like Cyril said get connected to help.

Don't buy a set of tools ! You end up with stuff you may never use.

Remember that I am primarily a bowl turner and do some spindle type work.

My primary 90% usage tools are

Bowl gouge 1/4, 3/8, and 1/2 v shaped flutes

I also use a parting tool and a bedan. Then after that are all of the other tools I have gathered that I seldom use but on ocasion are nice to have.

GET A MENTOR TO HELP YOU. YOU WILL BE FAR AHEAD.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#5

JL

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

JL

>To sort of echo what RevDoug (and others) have to say...

It depends on what you are turning.

I do mostly spindle work for furniture. The tools I mostly use are:

Roughing gouge (small 1" and larger 1 1/2")

Parting tool - "diamond" cross-section and smaller "flat" cross-section

Spindle gouges (3/8" and 1/2")

Bedan

Skew (I love my large oval)

I've got a few bowl turning tools, but I don't turn many bowls.

I've got a couple of bowl gouges (3/8" and 5/8") and several scrapers.

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#6

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

wilbur

>If you don't mind a response from a newbie:

I started with cheap tools that came with the used lathe that I bought. After playing around for a while, I just ordered and received some tools from Doug Thompson. I wound up getting:

3/8" spindle gouge

1/2" bowl gouge (often referred to as a 3/8" bowl gouge -- for some reason bowl gouges are usually sized by the size of the flute, not the tool)

1/2" skew chisel

1 1/4" skew chisel

1" scraper (comes as a square, but I plan to grind it down to a half-round shape, and will be used for bowls)

This should take care of my needs for the foreseeable future. I don't think I'll need a roughing gouge, as I've been able to do roughing with a skew chisel (check out Alan Lacer's DVDs). I might find that the small skew might be superfluous, so if there is anything I might drop from my list it would be that. If I get into turning boxes I might want some different shaped scrapers as well, but that's not on my list for now.

Hope this helps!

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#7

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

Rick Allen

>Hands on training is a terrific was to start.

The answer to turning tools is Benjamen's Best turning tools. These are Chinese made HSS turning tools which are good turning tools.

These are prices from PSI. There are other vendors who sell these tools. If you shop around you may find slightly better prices.

3/4" oval skew $13.45

3/8" spindle gouge $10.95

1" spindle roughing gouge $17.95

3/4" x 3/16" Parting tool 13.50

5/8" (US measure) bowl gouge $20.95

1 1/2" round nose scraper $23.95

Total $100.75 plus shipping

These are good woodturning tools. If you go with Sorby the price for similar tools is: $440

Are the Sorby tools better than Benjamen's best? Yes. The fit and finish is better and the usable length of the tool is up to 25% longer. They will each need to be sharpened just as often. They are both well suited to the task of woodturning.

When I started woodturning the only turning tools available from China were junk with poor profiles. Now the tools from China are good and the profiles are the tool profiles we use.

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#8

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

Justin Fields

>Thanks for the input, everyone. I have a lot to ponder.

I know I'll end up doing both bowls and spindle stuff, so I need to figure out what is more urgent. Also, the club has some group/communal tools I can use. So I might start buying only the things they don't have. Then as money allows, maybe I'll start getting the things I use most often from their selection, so I can have my own to keep (and keep sharp).

Justin

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

#9

Re: Turning Tools for a Newbie

eliot d

>I believe how you sharpen is more important than the tool itself, certainly at the beginning. If I were you , I would invest in a good sharpening system and buy cheap or moderately priced tools to start. I have just about every tool made, but , believe it or not, for small spindle work, turning at very high speed on a Jet Mini lathe, I always reach for a small incredibly cheap Chinese HSS skew chisel that I picked up as part of a whole set for something like $12(!) at HF. I mean the whole set was $12. The thing is -- I sharpen it starting with a Volverine system on a 120 grit white wheel and end up with a five micron "Ninja" disk on a JoolTool, and then power hone it on a hard felt wheel charged with stainless steel polishing compound. But it's a really cheap tool.