Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

another stuck faceplate

Posts

another stuck faceplate

#1

another stuck faceplate

Steven Kubien

>Evening everybody,

Many of us are familiar with the tales of Ruth, the General and the former pipe wrench. Well, I'm in a similar situation and wanted to get some clearance before I go neanderthal on it.....

My lathe is a Nova 1624 and I cannot access the spindle quite as easily as Ruth did (pictures looked like the top cover was simply removed). I should also point out that the faceplate is not all of the way on the spindle. It went about halfway on, jammed and now I can't get it off.

Do I go with Ruth's techinque of icing the spindle (remember, I can't get at it), heating the faceplate and then using a monster wrench or is there something someone can recommend specific to a Nova 1624? Obviously I don't want to damage the lathe but I would really like to turn some stuff before Christmas.

Thanks in advance.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: another stuck faceplate

#2

Re: another stuck faceplate

Ruth Niles

>Steve, since I had tried it all, I'm not totally convinced it was the heat that did the trick. It's like trying 10 times to open a jar of pickles, hand it to someone and pop it open, well if you had tried one more time, it just might have popped open for you, too.

I'm thinking that since the face plate isn't all the way on, before you do the heat thing, try some liquid wrench, lock the spindle and keep trying the pipe wrench, wait, spray, wrench a few times. Remember to only do a little, light-weight cussing because the lathe will only grab tighter the louder you yell at the face plate. Trust me on this.

My heating method now has The General in the midst of open-heart surgery. Had to take him apart and have to replace the front bearing. Not a Fun job!

Re: another stuck faceplate

#3

Re: another stuck faceplate

Don Evans

>Any chance of posting a picture of the offending faceplate and the spindle. Close up would be nice.

Your wording "half on" has me greatly concerned that damage is going to be the final result if wrong method is used.

Important: has this faceplate been used on this lathe before? If yes, did it work well the last time?

Is this a faceplate that is both left and right hand threaded?

Anymore you can tell us about it may be helpful, what size spindle and thread does the lathe spindle have?

Don

Re: another stuck faceplate

#4

Re: another stuck faceplate

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>A sharp, sudden force is best for releasing stuck parts. Think of a mechanic's impact wrench. Hit the end of the handle of the wrench. The mass of the spindle will resist the sudden force, and more of the force will be concentrated in the stuck threads.

Re: another stuck faceplate

#5

Re: another stuck faceplate

Bob Macgregor

>I agree with Don on this. Usually this problem is from overtightening, like turning the lathe on when the chuck or faceplate isn't all the way seated. The "stuck half-way on" comment sets off alarm bells for me, so I'd want to figure out what would cause the threads to seize up like that before trying something too desperate.

Re: another stuck faceplate

#6

Re: another stuck faceplate

Paul Waddle

>Steve,the face plate should have holes in it,if not drill a couple accross the diamenter. screw a larger pc of metal or birch ply as a handle making a "wrench". Lock the spindle,use a good size mallet on the wrench.. it WILL come loose or your lathe will jump off the floor. ha ha. Say,never did get that faceplate you were going to send me. I was waiting to get it,see how much the postage ....... pw

Re: another stuck faceplate

#7

Re: another stuck faceplate

jeff myroup

>Steve,

Like others have mentioned, the fact that it only went half way is a great concern. It sounds to me that it got cross threaded. If this is the case there is a good chance that the spindle threads are going to be damaged. If it is just some crud that fouled the threads you can use a large wrench. since you don't have the access that Ruth had, it is going to be hard. You need to find a way to provide a counter torque. I would use some type of channel lock with some rubber to prevent damaging the shaft, and put a wrench on the face plate. What type of face plate do you have aluminum or steel? If aluminum chances are you wont damage the steel spindle.

jeff

Re: another stuck faceplate

#8

Re: another stuck faceplate

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Heat almost always helps, since it expands the metal. Mechanics refer to a torch as a "heat wrench".

JKJ

Re: another stuck faceplate

#9

What Jeff, Don and Bob asked

Ruth Niles

>Is important, does the face plate have left and right threading? I've gotten mine about 1/2 on and when it got tight, knew I was cross threading and took it off immediately.

Do NOT bang on it or do anything with a pipe wrench and pressure until you see if the above is the problem.

Re: another stuck faceplate

#10

Re: another stuck faceplate

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>It has been mentioned before but a sharp blow with the spindle held in place will do it. Chances are a chip or something is on the thread.

Now if your only on two threads the faceplate might have started to cross thread but if you didn't force it your OK. When you do get the faceplate off spray the threads with some WD-40.

Let us know.

Re: another stuck faceplate

#11

Re: another stuck faceplate

Carole Valentine

>I agree. Sounds like cross threading to me and that can be a very bad thing. I have almost been there but fortunately I realized it before it got tight and was able to gently wiggle it free. If it is cross threaded and you have to use force to remove it, you will very likely damage your spindle unless the threads on the faceplate are much harder than the ones on the spindle, which I doubt.

Re: another stuck faceplate

#12

Re: another stuck faceplate

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>I agree it sounds like a cross thread. Ruth said she damaged the front bearing using heat. When you heat all you want heated is the face plate and not the shaft.

Bolt on a bar to the plate, heat the plate fast and only just beyond very hot to the touch. Now lock the spindle and hit the bar with a heavy hammer. Hit it fast and hard.

You may need to redress the spindle thread.

Good luch and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: another stuck faceplate

#13

Got it off. Long

Steven Kubien

>Thanks for all the help, all of you. I love the way turners rally when a tool is sick and the turner is in trouble. Kinda like when a baby bird falls out of a tree and the neighbourhood kids try to save it by making little nests out of shoe boxes and tissure paper. Very touching.

Half a can of WD-40 and some steady pressure got it done. Ruth, you're right. Soft gentle cursing seemed more effective and the angry-drill-sergent approach I began with. Who knew lathes were so sensitive?

I am still not exactly what happened but I think there must be some crud in the threads of the faceplate. The spindle looks fine, only a bit older if you get my meaning. To answer a number of things which were asked.....

This is the faceplate which came with the Nova and yes I have used it many times with no problems. It is not a left and right threaded plate. It doesn't look like the plate got cross threaded but I could be mistaken.

I am pretty sure that the spindle is ok because my chuck still threads on with no problem. Just as smooth as ever. I tried putting the faceplate back on but it seized up at the same point. I'll break out the toothbrush and give a good cleaning and see what happens.

Paul, I am sooooo sorry about the 5/8" faceplate. I totally forgot about it. I have found your mailing address on my email and will send it today. I would really like to make up some excuse but, well, I would just be making up an excuse.

Again, my thanks to each of you.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: another stuck faceplate

#14

Re: Got it off. Long

jeff myroup

>Glad you got it off Steve.

Jeff

Re: another stuck faceplate

#15

Re: another stuck faceplate

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>If I remember correctly, the spindle is hardened,but the chucks, faceplates etc are not.

Re: another stuck faceplate

#16

Re: Got it off. Long

paul waddle

>Thats ok Steve,we all forget. Glad you solved your problem. Try a chuck or another faceplate to see if alles ist in ordung. I kinda got an education on faceplates a while back,the threads on most are sloppy,the faceplate trues up when its snugged against the spindle collar. I'm sure the slop caused a cross thread. I would take a file and remove any burr and then hold up on that rascal as you screw it on and see if it won't thread. You didn't damage the spindle as it is hardened. jmo pw

Re: another stuck faceplate

#17

Re: Got it off. Long

Don Evans

>This is a great example on why I like the information I asked for before answering such questions.

If this is the Nova ALUMINUM faceplate then there are several possibilities, also over heating could be a very great mess.

Ever hear the term, dry welded? I know anyone with a background like Doug has, knows.

With the flimsy faceplates Nova made there are several possibilities of what happened, some of them are: dented threads in faceplate also if you have wood screwed to it that warped after, it may have warped the faceplate causing the threads to distort.

I had a Nova 3000 and like the lathe a lot and Nova's super chucks but that faceplate wasn't even a good paper weight.

Glad you got it off but if it doesn't screw on smoothly and easy and you cannot see what is causing it, toss it!

If it dry welds on you may have a very expensive repair ahead.

Don

Re: another stuck faceplate

#18

Re: Got it off. Long

Steven Kubien

>Hey Don,

I haven't been in the shop since I got the thing off and I am pretty sure that it is a steel faceplate, not aluminum. Too heavy for aluminum but i will do a magnet check to be sure. It's a pretty sturdy piece of work.

Nope, never heard of dry-weld. I am guessing that an aluminum plate isn't susceptable to this? Maybe I should look into one of the Don Pencil faceplates since he is one of our sponsors on WC.

Thanks for the info.

Steve Kubien

Re: another stuck faceplate

#19

Brain lock

Carole Valentine

>Jorge, I just read what I wrote. I re-wrote the post before I hit send and did not proof read (as usual!) "unless" was supposed to be "if".

I'd sell my brother for an edit button on this forum. Come to think of it, I would sell my brother for anything! LOL