Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

what color is dogwood, really?

Posts

what color is dogwood, really?

#1

what color is dogwood, really?

GaryG in MD

>I have various pieces of what I believe to be dogwood. I'm pretty careful about labeling and use "unknown" if I'm not sure. Most, if not all, of the dogwood I have stashed comes from my own yard! Having said all that, I'm now confused.

I have turned three things from my "dogwood", and each piece is a different color!

*I made a tool handle from a branch, and it's very light and sort of like maple, except it's a little bit on the pink side.

*I turned a small "double-bullseye" bowl/cup from a section of a larger branch, and both the heart wood and sap wood look more like unfinished cherry in color (I'm just trying to give a quick, rough indication of the color, it's not cherry!).

* I turned a shallow "Y" bowl from a small crotch, and it's a lovely, rich brown color.

What's going on here? Can dogwood be different colors depending on...? Can it get some kind of rot or fungus that makes it get dark?

Dogwood is very tight grained and turns like a dream. I have more, but I'd like to have an expectation of what color it's going to be.

Gary

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#2

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

russ Fairfield

>While usually more of a whiteish color when green, Dogwood can dry into any solid color or combination of colors from an Ivory White to a Dod Dung Brown, and I have no idea why there is a difference. Sometines wood from the same tree turns different colors.

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#3

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

Bill McWhirter

>Roots can be different from the above ground wood. I had one big root from a dead dogwood that was a beautiful pink.

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#4

Dick Hines

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

Dick Hines

>A tree trimmer brought me a couple of dog wood logs abs they were all kind of pink. The grain pattern was beautiful.

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#5

Same Here- Pink

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#6

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

Don Evans

>Bradford pear can do the same thing. I'm curious if this is an ornamental dogwood or one's that have grown in the wild? Also what state are you in, I forgot to check when I had your message up if that info was available there.

I've seen similiar you describe in NC with wild trees (dogwood).

Don

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#7

Re: what color is sad?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Gary,

I have found dogwood ranging from pale pink to the dark pink you might see in a rose. I've never seen it brown, though.

Here's a pic from last week. This is the result of the fungus that is wiping out the wild dogwood trees in these East Tennessee hills. Most of it is the lighter pinks. I'm afraid it won't be too many years before the wild dogwoods will be gone the way of the chestnut.

Gary


img

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#8

Re: what color is sad?

Terry Fox

>Same thing here in SE Pennsylvania. Probably less than half the wild dogwoods that were here 10 years ago - and the cultivated trees are in peril, too.

The wood here is mostly light pink and beautiful, except that it cracks and splits as easily as any wood I know.

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#9

Re: Some years ago I had........

Jamie Donaldson

>...an arborist for a student, and he brought me pink dogwood that was pink inside, and white dogwood that was white. I had never before had the 2 varieties side by side, so maybe the wood determines the color of the blossoms.

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#10

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>GaryG,

I've harvested and turned a fair amount of (flowering) dogwood which grows wild and abundently around here. Nearly all of it in the wild in this area has white flowers.

It's one of my favorite woods. I turned an ornament yesterday from dogwood nearly as white as holly. Some has beautiful rich brown heartwood. I had one piece with such rich and varied color it almost looked like some exotic tropical wood. I've had some with a little pink cast to the sapwood. Some looks kind of dull grey - I think that came from a standing dead tree. Some looks almost like cherry if I don't look too close. I have one piece with spalting and worm holes that looks nothing like any other.

Much of my current stock of dogwood came from a tree that was large enough that I cut a 1x12 from the center on my sawmill! I usually don't take the effort unless the tree is fairly large, and since large dogwood trees are somewhat rare, my experience may be different from those used to smaller pieces. (I find larger trees in yards and along the edges of fields - I think the shade must kill those in the forest before they get big.)

Also, remember that by nature wood varies widely, even in the same tree! I've read that the color of the wood can vary not only by genetics but largely from the nature and minerals in the soil. I even read about a company adding color to wood by feeding dye to the roots while it is growing, so what the tree finds to eat has to make a difference.

JKJ

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#11

Ditto

Carole Valentine

>The dogwood I have turned ranged from a creamy white to a streaked brown. Most of it has pink somewhere in it.

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#12

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

GaryG in MD

>Don,

It was a large (for a dogwood), probably 40-year old, white ornamental in my yard in suburban (of DC) Maryland. I was thinking of nominating it for possible County Champion.

One minute it was beautiful, and the next it was dead -- it was laced with borers. I was very unhappy to lose it.

Gary

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#13

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

GaryG in MD

>John,

Thanks for your detailed comments.

Wow, a 1x12 is amazing. I don't think even my 40-year old would have produced that.

It's great turning wood, but I hope I don't lose the two I have left in my front yard!

Gary

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#14

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

GaryG in MD

>Russ,

Well I guess that takes care of that! I'm glad to know I'm not crazy -- well, at least that I'm not misidentifying the wood. I'm pretty sure all these differently-colored pieces come from the same tree -- trimmed in different years. Strange.

I actually like the brown I got. This photo is a pretty good representation of the color on my monitor. I hope this isn't your doggie doo -- I like to think of it as "light walnut". ;-) (The piece is about 6"x6" at the wide end.)

Thanks for your comments, Gary


img

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#15

Thanks, all, for your comments

GaryG in MD

>

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#16

What's the reason or cause, Gary?

Ruth Niles

>

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#17

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

Don Evans

>Thanks, that is what I was suspecting you to say. I don't know why the color, but man has messed with hybrids and I think it makes a big difference in what you asked about. Most people when you say dogwood, I believe think wild only.

Maybe someone with expert training like Andi Wolfe can shed lite.

Don

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#18

Re: What's the reason or cause, Gary?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I haven't really studied the issue, Ruth, but my understanding is that it is caused by a fungus that attacks mature trees. "Imported" from some other country, I'm sure.

All I know from observation is that a tree will look healthy one year, the next it won't leaf out, or if it does the leaves will shrivel and turn brown well before the fall, and the following year, or the year after, the bark will start coming off because it's completely dead.

Having said that, we do still have some mature trees that look healthy, so maybe there is some natural resistance going on. I sure hope so. We've probably lost 60% to 70% of the dogwoods on our 45 acres over the past 7 or 8 years.

Hopefully, someone with more scientific knowledge will chime in about the problem.

Gary

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#19

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>It's great turning wood, but I hope I don't

>lose the two I have left in my front yard!

Dogwood yard trees (out in the light) seem to be much longer lived.

Another thing if you haven't done it: every few years drive two or tree fertilizer stakes into the ground out near the drip line. This will especially help yard trees if the soil is poor. I did that once for a dogwood and the next year it was covered with flowers where it hadn't flowered at all for several years. The leaves looked healthier as well.

BTW, the large dogwood I mentioned came from a neighbor's yard. I think he got tired of raking the leaves and cut it down. Another neighbor knew I liked wood so they gave me a call. Most of the trees I get for my sawmill come this way.

JKJ

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

#20

Re: what color is dogwood, really?

GaryG in MD

>John,

Thanks a lot for the tip about fertilizing. I do need to do that, and you have given me the impetus. Our soil here is very poor -- just a tad of humus on top of lots of hard red clay. I'm concerned about the borers, and the Feds have (rightly) outlawed virtually every chemical that will kill larval borers, and I've used up all my stash of lindane (which I used only very carefully, sparingly, and grudgingly). I'd hate to lose the other two -- one white and one pink. (I know about the Bayer stuff, but it's extremely expensive and only marginally effective.)

I'm a tree hugger at heart, and I'd much rather enjoy them living than turn the wood. Unfortunately, far too many people these days have no respect for mature trees and wipe them out thoughtlessly or out of misguided fear (oh no, it'll fall on my house!). It upsets me greatly. It can quickly change the whole character of a neighborhood. We lost about 5 big ones in our neighborhood this spring -- mostly for really ignorant, short-sighted "reasons". At this rate, in a few years our 40-year old neighborhood, now shaded, cooled, and beautified by attractive mature oaks, maples, cherries, dogwoods, etc., will look like something bulldozed by a developer. ...sigh...

Gary