Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Mass Emails using members addresses

Posts

Mass Emails using members addresses

#1

Mass Emails using members addresses

Jerry Hall

>Should there be an explicit policy prohibiting mass emails by a member to members for any reason?

Recently I have received many emails triggered by a member "mining" email addresses from this forum. They were non-commercial so that rule does not apply. I think there is no good reason for mining email addresses and mass emails of any kind. All communication should be out in the open on the forum. We all have enough unsolicited emails.

If this type of rule is not established then we should have some sort of "no call" list. I doubt this is feasible or desirable however.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#2

apparently you can't get off of it either

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>I've asked for my name to be removed from the email thread you're speaking of twice, yet I keep getting them, as I want no part of what it has become. Yes, I agree with you, mining of the users' emails in such fashion should be a punishable offense.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#3

Re: apparently you can't get off of it either

adrien

>Every last email I've received on this issue, I've labeled "Spam".

I resent not having the choice of whether I wish to receive such email. Unfortunately, that means that some of the senders with whom I might later wish to correspond will not be able to get through to me.

This has been a royal pain!

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#4

No Good Deed Goes Unpunished

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#5

Re: apparently you can't get off of it either

Ralph

>The first message I could almost understand... then it turned into a "reply to all" discussion!!

NOT WHY I POST TO THIS FORUM

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#6

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>So what's going on? I haven't been a recepient of these mass e-mails. It might be useful for us to know the story.

Gary

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#7

I hope the member who authored

Jerry Hall

>the original email will step up and give us his/her thoughts on this. I believe it was innocent, but very ill advised and intrusive. But he/she could help us all avoid this in the future by participating in this thread.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#8

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I prefer NOT to get mass emails from the Woodcentral list, and I'm not sure how I got on the one in question. I understand how Mr. Schwing feels, all of a sudden we're getting a bunch of emails from a big group of people, and they're replying to each other using the "reply to all" thing. I've only gotten about 16 emails so far, but who knows how many more there will be??

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#9

Q: is it possible to take your email off

Ruth Niles

>the forum when you respond? Maybe try it and if you can still post and read and just your name shows up, that's what you want.

Please don't try to make a ruling for the whole forum membership, many don't feel as strongly as you do. Personally, I may get 5 to 8 spam emails a day and they don't even get in my "inbox" they go right to "trash". Some email servers allow you to set up so you put a list of people who are allowed to send your emails. I've sent emails and get a message saying I have to ask permission to be allowed to send that person an email. It doesn't offend me, it's just something that person does to eliminate a lot of SPAM.

As to the mass emailing in question, that was done out of a desire to do something good and fun. When a question was asked, a few decided that was immoral and there was back and forth just like any discussion. When there's 89 people on an email list, it ain't easy to find one guy to take him out, that's what your "delete" button is for, do not open anything, just throw it away. I do that a lot, too.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#10

We all operate on trust here

Jerry Hall

>and part of that trust is how Woodcentral acts as a custodian of personal data, such as our email address. I understand that this mailing was well intentioned. One persons good intentions can be another's intrusive action. I will bet most felt these messages were intrusive, especially after the 10th one.

The larger issue is why should it be so easy for someone to join, and harvest a bunch of our email addresses for whatever purpose they desire, and send out emails under any address at all? I don't think that is being a good custodian of this personal data. One to one emails can be handled securely and are in other forums, without disclosure of email addresses. "Opt Out" is not an answer. Deleting, filters, all of that is "Opt out" complexity that puts undue burden on the consumer. If anything people should be required to "Opt In" if they really want to be on a list to receive mass mailings. Does Wood Central really want to be an agent for mass mailing? Doesn't the trust under which this forum operates deserve more care in the use of personal data?

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#11

Yes, Ruth

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I assume you are replying at least as much to Jerry's post as mine? I don't feel too awfully strong about this and I have nothing against the intention of that mailing, but I do take some pains to keep my email addresses inaccessable to spammers.

Actually, the email I use here (a munged gmail address) isn't the same one as on the mass mailing that went out. That's why I am wondering how that other email of mine was gotten. I know it is on file with Ellis, but didn't know it was on a public list.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#12

Re: Q: is it possible to take your email off

Steven Kubien

>Ruth said, "that was done out of a desire to do something good and fun" and I agree with that. A lot of people are getting upset about this when I think we should remember what the intent was...to do something nice! Good grief, why are we so bent on making this into something big?

Respectfully,

Steve Kubien

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#13

Now would be a good time...

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>...to see opportunity for growth, improvements, and/or understandings of WC policy. A good time to think about going forward from here and making positive suggestions to your moderator(s). Now is probably a good time to allow this thread to fall away quietly and get solidly into the season's cheer.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#14

Re: apparently you can't get off of it either

Juergen

>Mike, The reason your getting all the Emails is that every time someone responds to the Email everyone on the list gets a copy. If you look at the Email's header (usually by selecting show all in View). I got 15 or so this afternoon. The only thing you can do is to ignore them or create a filter in your browser.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#15

Re: We all operate on trust here

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Jerry, Wood Central is NOT the custodian of your personal data. You are. You put your email up for all to see. If you don't want to get emails, don't publish an address. Or put up one that can be ignored by you if you so desire.

I don't care for lots of unsolicited email, but it is a fact of life.

Bill

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#16

There Must Be a Magnetic Interference

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>with our brain cells. People are going ballistic over on the AAW site over dumb stuff and now this thread.

This whole issue could have been handled quietly and efficiently with several exchanges of e-mails without causing a scene. Bill G. said it best. We are responsible for our own data. If you don't want you address available, just adjust it or don't put it up here for everyone to see.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#17

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

Cyril Griesbach

>At issue here is one WC'er, that many of us know, wanting to do something nice for another WC'er and see if anyone wanted to get involved. To explain this further in this forum would spoil the surprise...thus...an email was sent out. To quote from that origional email...

"If I have offended anybody I am sorry and delete this now, I will not use the list of email that I mined for any other use."

I believe this man.

This morning I got a number of email responses to the origional email and the responses were started by Ruth who aparently used the "reply to all" instead of "reply to sender" which might have set off this firestorm. Ruth could have deleted the message but was contemplating the intent of the origional message and likely formulating her personal position on the request.

Ruth, I don't mean to have singled you out here and if I have offended I'm sorry.

That's all there is to it, folks. I suggest we lighten up and get on with finishing our Christmas turnings.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#18

That is not the point

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I have the ability to use filters and the delete button as well as everyone else.

I did not like what I saw in the message thread. To me, it appeared that people were talking about other people in a manner that would suggest questioning their character, and/or talking behind their backs.

Knowing how email trails can be captured for posterity, I did not want my name/email address on any such thread of messages, as it might appear to mean that I was condoning such behavior. I do not. I had not participated in the exchange up till then, I did indeed intend to just filter it all out, but the one message I read that sparked my concern changed my mind, and I asked to be removed from the list.

If it was a simple annoyance, well I get them all day long..

I am content to let this die, and I know that the originator had good intentions.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#19

Re: Q: is it possible to take your email off

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I have the ability to use filters and the delete button as well as everyone else.

I did not like what I saw in the message thread. To me, it appeared that people were talking about other people in a manner that would suggest questioning their character, and/or talking behind their backs.

Knowing how email trails can be captured for posterity, I did not want my name/email address on any such thread of messages, as it might appear to mean that I was condoning such behavior. I do not. I had not participated in the exchange up till then, I did indeed intend to just filter it all out, but the one message I read that sparked my concern changed my mind, and I asked to be removed from the list.

If it was a simple annoyance, well I get them all day long..

I am content to let this die, and I know that the originator had good intentions.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#20

Re: We all operate on trust here

Barry Elder

>Thanks, Barbara and Cyril, for making comments that make sense. It is still a mole hill.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#21

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

Bruce Lane

>First I have to change the way I look at this site. Then I have to click an extra time or two;and not even in the same place. Now I have to click the delete button or ignore an email. Ellis, I want a REFUND for what you are charging me to visit this site.

Geesh

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#22

Good Grief!

Ron in Drums PA

>One Said "

I am most concerned about the appropriateness of singling out any one person for such gifting. There are many newbies who could feel a little left out by this.

- Is he upset that he isn't getting any free wood?

Another Said

Please keep my email address out of this. I do not wish to be included in a message thread that talks about other WCrs behind their backs, regardless of who they used to be


- I don't think this one owns a lathe or maybe he is afraid of being associated with doing something nice?

If my memory serves me, this is the forth time such a collection of emails where sent. The first three times everybody was happy to receive the message and the person on the other end was pleased. Ruth brought up some valid points that where answered by others and then we get this fire storm.

Because of this Ellis said

(hiding e-mails)... it is a feature of WoodCentral that has been debated several times in our 9+ years on the air. I don't condone this type of mining, but I haven't prevented it either. I have the ability, in no time flat, to make everyone's e-mail addresses invisible to forumgoers and robots. Maybe I should have done that somewhere along the line, but we've always had a very trusting, open-door kind of policy with regard to registrations and e-mails.

The email I use on this site is only used on this site, no others. I get maybe 2-3 spam emails a month and most of them are filtered out. There is very little if any problem with spammers mining our emails!

I like the ability to send and receive emails from my friends on WoodCentral. I would sure hate to lose that on WC because of two people.

Can you tell I'm in a cranky mood this morning!

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#23

I agree I should be responsible for my email

Jerry Hall

>address. Tried to change it using the edit profile. Wonder if it works in this message. Anyway, thanks for the discussion and good comments. Happy Holidays to all.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#24

Re: Good Grief!

Cyril Griesbach

>"I don't think this one owns a lathe or maybe he is afraid of being associated with doing something nice."

Ron, I can assure you that this one does, in fact, own a lathe and produces some spectacular pieces.

Re: Mass Emails using members addresses

#25

PARDON ME RON

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Excuse me Ron, are you actually stating that because I don't own a lathe at present that my contributions are somehow less valuable than those that do? Are you seriously stating, as in the quote below, that because I don't own a lathe, my contribution or participation is diminished? I hope you never encounter a time frame where for one reason or another you wind up without a lathe. If we are comparing, I would happily stack my contributions WITH and WITHOUT A LATHE and woodturning accomplishments against yours. You have a lot of nerve, and I am sure have made it easier for those not involved in this email exchange to see exactly why it went bad.

For the record, I have been involved in every gift exchange we've had here. In fact, I wound up giving gifts to two turners in the exchange last year due to a mix up, rather than ask for the first one to be redirected.

You have really frosted me, and done nothing to put this to bed. I believe you owe me an apology.

..................................

"Another Said

Please keep my email address out of this. I do not wish to be included in a message thread that talks about other WCrs behind their backs, regardless of who they used to be

- I don't think this one owns a lathe or maybe he is afraid of being associated with doing something nice?"