Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Damping and Vibration Help!!

Posts

Damping and Vibration Help!!

#1

Damping and Vibration Help!!

Tim GC

>My Lathe has box section ways approx 6" X 3" I have read elsewhere that drilling one end of each section and filling them with fine sand will add mass (obvious fact) This will dampen vibration caused by any out of balance loads. I have no problem understanding that bit.

The next bit is what I am puzzling over.

When the ways are almost full, pour in clean oil over a period of time until the ways are full to the brim with a sand/oil mix. Advantages??? or am I being particularly stupid and not seeing the wood for the trees.

Oh don't forget to seal the ways before returning to the horizontal.

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#2

JL

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

JL

>First - which lathe? You may be able to do some of this by incorporating a ballast box of some sort.

Second you asked - "When the ways are almost full, pour in clean oil over a period of time until the ways are full to the brim with a sand/oil mix. Advantages??? or am I being particularly stupid and not seeing the wood for the trees."

Sand has lots of spaces. If you fill these spaces with oil, you can get a "dampening" effect as you will have a more uniform mass (without air) so the vibrations would have a tendency to be absorbed better.

My $0.02.

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#3

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>My take is that the oil is to lubricate the sand and "float" it or keep it more fluid. This lets the sand move more freely when the lathe is vibrating and makes it more effective in absorbing the vibration. This is similar to the way dead-blow hammers work, or oil and shot filled tool handles.

Personally, I would use bone-dry lake, river or ocean sand because it the grains are rounded. This keeps it from packing down as tightly and from hanging up on other grains of sand. Moisture also makes the sand clump up or pack down, which is why I would use bone-dry sand. I would be very tempted to omit the oil simply because of the potential mess.

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#4

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

john lucas

>Sand is a big enough mess around the lathe. I personally would never put oil in there also. None of my lathes even have a place where I could do that. Is this for a metal lathe? I might put oil on a metal lathe.

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#5

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

russ Fairfield

>If anyone is interested in damping vibration, they can experiment with this. The best location is on the center-line of the spindle, but that is not aways east to do. Attaching it to the lathe bed next the the headstock is easier, and it is effective; but it will take heavier weights to do not quite as good a job as the center-line mounting.

I made one with a 2x4 clamped to the lathe bed with 2 C-clamps, a length of 1" all-thread rod, and a couple 10-pound diving weights.


img

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#6

Mike Hunter

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

Mike Hunter

>I am not an expert on this topic, but what about using lead shot vs sand?

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#7

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

russ Fairfield

>Lead is best, but sand is cheap.

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#8

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

Tim GC

>In Response ... Hegner HDB200XL The Bed/Ways are 60 x 6 x 3 Hollow Box Section 5/16 steel. The Legs are an option with the owner building a box between the Metal ends and the Bed bolting to the top. The Box is a pair of 60 x 6 x 2 Prepared Douglas Fir, the base and top 1" MDF the hollow area is filled with kiln dried sand, approx 100lbs I think ... The Oil/Sand mix is poured into holes drilled and tapped into the ends of the bed which is then sealed.

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#9

Another implementation 1

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>This is a small loaf pan filled with lead, bolted and epoxied to the top of the headstock.


img

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#10

Another implementation 2

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Another chunk of lead epoxied to the tailstock.


img

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#11

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

Fog Tanner

>I bought a couple of hundred pounds of lead shot to add to the bse on one of my lathes. The stands are hollow and can be filled and emptied fairly easily. I like the density of the lead better than the sand and its softer too which helps again.

My other lathe weighs 1000lbs without any additional weight. I now do a lot of off center turning and even a small piece of wood can cause vibration. I was thinking about a better way to balance the piece rather than using weight. The lathe is a Vic 300 longbed, the Aussie version, and I check their site periodicly. I noticed that they make a balancing system now. It mounts on the outboard side of the spindle and has two weights. The weights have holes which are offcenter and mount on a shaft, resembeling a cam lobe in a car engine. After seeing one live, it was a have too item. As soon as the boat lands I will have it on my lathe. Rather than add weight, this lets you balance the rotating mass to reduce the vibration. As you reduce the rotating mass, it is fairly easy to adjust the weights. This also means I don't have to add lead to my lathe, which means it will not cause cancer in Kalifornia...

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#12

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

Tim GC

>Many thanks to all who posted for me. I shall investigate further and report back ... the counter weight will be interesting and I shall try that first. Watch this space ...

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

#13

Re: Damping and Vibration Help!!

Pete in Holland, MI

>Higher frequency vibration (more described as a "hum") is better absorbed by dry sand than wet sand. I've seen and whitnessed this on vibration welding machines that operate around 150 Hz. Wet sand will tend to kling to gether and act more like a rock. If the oil is pressurized and flowing thru the sand bed, then the sand may float. Besides, if you ever have to move the lathe, wet sand won't pour or drain out of your lathe.

If your lathe is bouncing around due to an out of balance load, you need mass on the lathe, within the structure or stand, or be bolted to something that has more mass. At that point, solid or fluid won't make much difference.