Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Which grit for gouges?

Posts

Which grit for gouges?

#1

Which grit for gouges?

Jack Savona

>I need to replace the original 120 grit white wheel that came with my slow speed grinder, but I'm confused as to what grit size to order. I currently have a 60 and the 120. I've sharpened gouges mostly on the 120, since I thought 'the finer the grit, the sharper the edge'. However, it seems to me that many turners use a lower grit for gouges. If so, is that to avoid the buildup I get on my 120 grit? Or does it produce a better edge? Does a lower grit also wind up taking off more steel than necessary?

I'm sure many of you have your own grit preferences, but does anyone have any scientific info on this question? Thanks in advance.

Jack

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#2

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Buy a Tormec. Once set it only takes a few seconds to re edge a tool. Runs cool and removes very little metal. Tools last longer.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#3

Not scientific and....

Steven Kubien

>...not 100% compatible but here's my set up. I have a 1" x 42" belt sander with a 120 grit blue zirconia belt on it (belt came from Lee Valley I think). That's all I use. Ok, my skews get a bit more attention and honing but that's it for gouges. Works for me and in your situation I would also use the 120 grit wheel, reserving the 60 grit for major re-shaping.

My 2 cents and probably worth less.

Steve Kubien

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#4

Re: Which grit for gouges?

robert davis

>120 was once the preferred grit,, now it seems thst 80 is preferred. i have 80 and 120 use the 80 for gouges. the 80 is a norton sg which is great

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#5

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I too have a 1 inch belt sander which I use with a zircon belt for reshaping tools. With a 40 or 60 grit belt it removes metal faster and cooler than a 60 grit wheel does.For regular sharpening I think that the 120 grit is too fine. 80 or 100 would be my choice. If I was replacing both wheels I would go for 46 and 80 grit. Jerry Glaser used to sharpen the Glaser tools with a 46 grit wheel.

Wally

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#6

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Ron McKinley

>John Jordan, on the AAW Sharpening DVD, uses two 60 grit wheels....Ron

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#7

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I should add to what I've said. When Jerry Glaser sharpened new tools with 46 grit, I'm quite certain that he was using the grit that would get the job done quickly. I doubt that Jerry would have recommended a 46 grit for regular grinding. 46 grit on your own grinder would be good for reshaping tools and to get an aggressive burr when needed, on scrapers. A 60 or 80 grit is better for regular grinding. However, I'm sure that if you ask a dozen experienced turners what grit they use you'll get a lot of different answers.

Wally

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#8

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Allen Neighbors

>Jack, I could be wrong on this, so take a little salt with it.

What is the object of honing an edge? To make it sharper.

If you use an 80 grit stone, and then hone, you have to hone away the crevasses left by the 80 grit. If you use a 120 grit stone, you don't have as much honing to do. That all makes sense to me.

They tell me that the burr left by the grindstone is what does the cutting, and I can see that, because I used a cabinet scraper for years. But if one is honing the edges of their gouges - John Lucas honed the Doug Thompson gouges when he tested them - why wouldn't you want the finer grit stone to deal with? Sometimes I hone, sometimes I don't.

All that said... I use a 120 grit stone to sharpen all my bowl gouges, and I don't use much pressure on my tools, so I don't get much heat, or very much buildup on my grindstone. I have an 80 grit wheel that I do pre-shaping with, and I sharpen all my scrapers and Oland-tool-cutters on this 80 grit. It works for me. I sharpen all my spindle gouges and skews on a 120 grit sanding belt that I modified so the belt goes away from the tool edge, which leaves a small burr on the edge, which I hone away.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#9

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I use a 60 grit wheel for gouges, especially when I hone. When it is time to return to the grinder, a 60 grit wheel restores the grind a lot faster than the finer grit wheels and doesn't create as much heat. The edge from a 60 grit wheel also is a good cutting edge straight off the wheel, although I'll hone the edge for the final finishing passes and for delicate details.

I like an 80 grit wheel for scrapers because it produces a finer burr.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#10

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Jack Savona

>Allen, that's what is baffling me. I would expect a higher grit to give a sharper edge, similar to what honing would do. Moreover, I always thought that any burrs on the inside of the flute would be gone with the first cut.

David Lancaster advocates re-sharpening just before the 'final cut'. So I assume the tool for that cut should be as sharp as my grinder could produce.

Wally, I realize Jerry Glaser uses 46 grit. I just don't get the science behind it.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#11

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Jack, Jerry used a 46 grit to with a jig to shape the grind on a new tool. I doubt that Jerry would use the 46 grit when he sharpened his own tools for use.

Wally

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#12

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Rick Allen

>The edge off a coarse wheel is more aggressive than the edge off a fine wheel. The saw toothed edge off a coarse wheel is more durable than a finner edge.

For 3/8' bowl gouges and larger (European measure) I like the edge I get from a 60 grit wheel.

For small bowl gouges and spindle work I like the edge I get from a 100 grit wheel.

I would sharpen before the finial pass because I want a predictable cutting action for the last cut.

I would use the 60 grit wheel you already have for sharpening most of my bowl gouges. I wold get a 100 (or 120) grit wheel to replace the 120 grit wheel to sharpen my other turning tools.

If you like to hone then go ahead and do that. The last pass on a bowl should be done with a tool that has a very predictable action (a cutting action that you are used to).

BTW there are wheels which are better suited to slow speed grinders than full speed grinders. Has to do with the friable nature of the wheel. If the 120 is clogging up to quickly then you likely are using a 120 grit wheel which would work better on a full speed.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#13

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Clay Foster

>I use a coarse wheel for shaping and a fine wheel for sharpening. A coarse wheel cuts faster when you need to remove a lot of metal. A fine wheel leaves a finer serrated cutting edge, so it leaves a little better surface. A 121 grit wheel would be best, but I settle for 120.

Using it often is more important than the grit and composition.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#14

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Bill Neddow

>Just to add to the confusion, there is another factor to take into consideration -- the speed of the grinder. Some manufacturers want you to use the next highest grit if you have a slow speed grinder. It seems that the finish you get off a slow-speed 120 grit wheel is somewhat comparable to the finish off an 80 grit wheel on a high-speed grinder.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#15

Re: Which grit for gouges?

Fog Tanner

>Jack,

You know this is like Ford vs Chevy when you ask about grits. You will find the same passion for the same reasons - only going to drive/use the best. Everybody has their own valid reason for using what they do...

Basicly what Allen said. I use a 220 and 1000 grit wet grinder for 90% of my sharpening. I have a Delta slow speed grinder with a 100 and 60 grit on it. The 60 is for removing metal and scrapers, the 100 grit is for sharpening two gouges with my Ellsworth jig. I have two 120 grit white wheels to replace the 100 grit when I can remember to.

All my spindle tools are done on the Tormek. The skews typically at 1000 grit. I hone all the skews (and some of the gouges) after sharpening and then alternate going to the stone and honing wheel every other time. They pretty much have a polished edge which lasts longer in my use. I started using some skews I got from Doug Thompson about 8 months ago and have to sharpen those even less. They appear to like the finer grits better than the course ones.

Basicly this follows along with Allen's observations above. You have smaller grooves in the steel and a finer edge. The course the edge, the sooner it will get clogged with fibers and stall out cutting. The tool isn't really dull, just filled with fibers. I think this is another reason the finer the surface the longer it lasts.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#16

Ford/Chevy

Jack Savona

>Fog, and everyone else, thanks for your responses. Somehow I knew, when I asked the question, I'd get some Ford/Chevy preferences. That's the chance in asking for any "scientific" info. I think I'll order a 100 as a compromise and balance to the 60 on the other wheel.

Re: Which grit for gouges?

#17

Thank you all!!!

Jack Savona

>