>Bruce, I agree with you, the lid is a little too tall. That is also easy to do. I often have trouble with the translation from the horizontal turned object to the standing vertical object and it is easy to make the lid too tall. I actually try to measure using a rule of thirds where approximately 1/3 is the lid and 2/3 is the body. However even that will not always work depending on the shape of your box and lid. Each design you try will have its own "correct" proportions.
All that said, this box still looks pretty nice and as long as it is functional and you learned something from turning it then it is an unmitigated success. I am glad that you saw improvement from box #1 to box #2 on the fit of your lid. Congratulations!
>Bruce, I like both of them, and agree with you about the tall lid, too. Still like them both.
Making lids that 'pop' when they come off, is good when other turners are checking your work. And it's also good when the box is small enough to be a pill box for a lady's purse.
When you have trouble with the fit, you can sand the lid or the tenon a little to make them slip on and off easily enough that it won't lift the bottom... that way they can be opened with just one hand. Think about it; when you start to put something in a small container, most of the time you already have the item in one hand, and if the container is hard to open, you have to put the item down to open the box. It's much easier if the lid will come right off.
Keep at it. You're doing well. Until about 2 months ago, I had only made 2 or 3 boxes total. Seeing Mike's boxes gave me the inspiration to turn some.
Just as an aside: I took 18 little boxes to my Son's for Thanksgiving. I gave each female in the family her choice of box, as a little gift, beginning with the oldest down to the youngest. I also asked them to tell me what they liked in particular about the one they chose. I took note of which ones went first, and now I know which shapes were preferred. (The oldest was 30, the youngest 6.)
Maybe I'll be able to sell more at the next craft show! :)
>I think if you turn a tenon to accept the lid, then you can remount the lid and easily turn another bead , or line, on the lid above the joint. That that line will shift the balance upward. It's a nice box.