Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Posts

Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#1

Reversing VS lathe without stopping

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I use a Jet 1642 variable speed lathe. I always let the lathe stop completely before throwing the reversing switch, but the other day I accidentally hit the switch (don't ask how) and instead of a disaster the lathe gently slowed down then reversed.

I got to wondering if that was an acceptable procedure. It's obvious that instead of simply coasting down when switched off, the speed controller obviously decelerates the lathe to gradually slow it under power (just try to stop it with your hand while it's slowing down) and gently ramps up the speed when switched on.

If I were writing software the for the controller, that's certainly the way I would do it to minimize stress on components and help keep chucks from locking up or loosening on the spindle threads. It only makes sense then that the same algorithms would provide for a gentle speed reversal.

Does anyone know for sure if switching direction under power is a safe procedure for these lathes? It would sure save some of time.

JKJ

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#2

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

john lucas

>Don't know if it's safe but I've done it accidentally on my 2035 and it does the same thing. Another thing it does. When you turn it on with the spindle locked (yea I know sometimes I'm an idiot) nothing happens. It knows your stupid and doesn't aggravate the situation.

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#3

2035 ?

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>John,

I have read this several times when you post about your lathe.

Did you get a special Powermatic, or is it the 3520 that everyone else buys ? :)

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#4

Re: 2035 ?

john lucas

>Dave I never could keep the numbers straight. In my mind most lathes are sized by how big you can turn, not how long. Thus I tend to put the swing first. I just looked it up and Jet puts the swing first on all their models and Powermatic does length first. I have a very simple brain. I still get dates with a club so I have to name my lathes with swing first Of course I don't run as fast as I used to and the younger women run a lot faster so I guess I'll have to find another way to get a date.

Gosh I just looked at the date on this piece. I turned this in 97. I still remember cutting the slate on the table saw. I used a cut off blade for concrete. I knew it would create a lot of dust so I put shop vac right beside the blade. I was so proud of myself as I was cutting you could see all that black dust go right up the dust hose. Then I stopped and realized that my whole shop was covered with black dust. Apparently it didn't collect all the dust.


img

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#5

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

George Van

>It is an acceptable procedure on my Oneway pre Kevin. It seems to be programmed into the 3520 also. It would be interesting to check with tech support at Jet and hear their opinion on the subject.

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#6

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Chuck Engstrom

>I did this by accident once myself and have wondered ever since, so thanks for raising the question here. I have a Oneway 1018 and a PM3520, and both gently reverse and start turning in the opposite direction without apparent distress. It makes sense to me that thoughtful programmers would allow for the possibility that human users will eventually hit the wrong switch.

One responder here reports that Oneway says that doing this is no problem, so I guess I'll start using this trick regularly.

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#7

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Tim GC

>I have always wondered, but was too *%$"@#$ to ask ... My Hegner does not appear to object in the slightest ... and it happens often as well, the switches are identical and 1 1/2" apart. When the lathe is running in the forwards direction both switches are in the up position.

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#8

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I've hit the reverse switch at full speed for years on the Poolewood with no ill effects. In fact, I used to demonstrate it for every student who used it, to show them that they could not hurt the lathe by pressing the wrong switch.

I accidentally found out it works on the Robust as well. I say accidental because it was not my machine! But I have done it a number o times since then. The Vega has a stop position between forward and reverse, and it usually stops fast enough on its own that I have not felt the inclination to try it out, although a few students have with trouble.

Bill

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#9

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Barry Irby

>I have a Nova DVR and I don't think it will reverse while it is on. (I may try again) But, If you turn it off, press reverse while it is coasting and turn it back on, it just waits until it stops and then starts in the other direction. Does not seem to distress the machine at all. Sometimes I do this and stop it with my hand and give it a spin in the other direction to speed things up. Would recommend that, but I am a wild and crazy guy. (My lathe occasionally says BEEP which I have come to accept as New Zealand for either Thank You or FU, not sure which.)

Also, like John I have turned it on with the Indexing Pin engaged. it just beeps at me and does nothing. And, If you get three giant catches in a quick sequence and stop the shaft, it turns it self off. You have to restart it manually. This is New Zealand for "Serious Up! Start Paying ATTENTION"

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#10

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Carole Valentine

>Barry, I have accidentally tried to turn my DVR on with the spindle locked and it just tries to run. No Beep. Wonder how much damage this causes, if any?

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#11

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Bob Macgregor

>In my lathe shopping/research over the past few months I ran across mention of automatic slowdown and reverse. The problem is that I can't remember whether this was in a description of a specific lathe or from a review article or what. I hate it when I get so overloaded with info that I get scrambled-- getting older just makes things worse!

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#12

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Rick Davenport

>I checked with an electrical engineer friend of mine and he said it shouldn't be a problem.

So I have been doing it on my 3520b for the past couple of years.

I find it especally helpful when sanding.

Just remember to tighten the set screw on your chuck or that thing will unscrew itself! And if it does, don't try to catch it, just get the heck out of the way!!!!

Rick

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#13

Not on my lathe

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I have a Nova 3000 not a DVR. It has a 1 HP Dc Leason motor. I accidentally hit the reverse switch instead of the off switch. There was no real slow down. It just went into reverse a quickly as it could. It happened fast enough to make the chuck unscrew itself from the spindle. I guess each model of lathe needs to be checked before trying forward to reverse under operating conditions. There is a safety shield and spring pin on my lathe that keeps the reverse switch from being thrown. I keep the pin in place now except when I am sanding in reverse.

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#14

Almost all VFD are programmed this way.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>This slow, come to a stop, then reverse, and start up is hard coded into just about all VFD's on the market. It's a safety precaution, prevents mechanical damage to anything they are controlling, electrical damage from a big EMF from the motor coils, and....idiot proof for some of us tht hit the fwd/rev switch by mistake.

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#15

Re: Almost all VFD are programmed this way.

Tim GC

>That explains it!! Count this idiot as one who has hit the reverse switch not the Start ...

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#16

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Barry Irby

>Carol, I do it more often that I am willing to admit. Often I grab the knob on the Indexing pin in the nick of time and snatch it up and out of the way. My experience is that the lathe "soft" starts and you can withdraw the pin even if it is trying to start. Not sure, but if you leave it in place I think it will try three times and cut itself off. Never paid enough attention but I think you get an error message about the shaft being locked. And I don't think it hurts anything.

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#17

Ric Taylor

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

Ric Taylor

>When I run mine backwards, I hear the Beatles singing, "Paul is Dead."

Ric

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#18

That is a classic John :)

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>

Re: Reversing VS lathe without stopping

#19

Good one!

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>