Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

The new Wood Central

Posts

The new Wood Central

#1

The new Wood Central

russ Fairfield

>There are a lot of complaints about the new Wood Central format. It seems to me that we have to remember that Wood Central is supported by advertisers. Yes, there are individual donations, but the advertisers still carry the biggest load. With the old format, it was possible to visit the site and read all of the messages without ever seeing any of the banner advertisements. Unless I started at the top of the thread, I never saw the banner ad. If I wanted to see an ad, I had to go looking for it.

I had an ad for awhile and I dropped it because it was all but invisible. If I never saw the ad, I had to assume that neither could anyone else. The new format makes the advertisers more visible without being intrusive.

The other thing about the new format is that the side-bar menu is there whether we want to see it or not. I don't know how many had previously used the option to not see it, but one of the most often asked question was where to find something because they weren't seeing the menu. Now there is no doubt about what features are here and where to find them.

Re: The new Wood Central

#2

Re: The new Wood Central

Stuart Johnson

>I am not finding any drawback with the new format. Like any change it did take a bit to get use to it but now no problem. There might be some issues that need to be worked out but in my mind seeing the ads isn't one of them. In any event I don't really mind them and from time to time do see something that interests me. I might be the exception but I don't even see them for the most part. They are there and like ads in the newspaper I don't have to read them if I don't want. FWIW,I also don't find most billboards along the interstate all that bad. I don't see or pay attention to them until I want specific information and then they are very helpful.

Re: The new Wood Central

#3

Re: The new Wood Central

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA

>I tend to like the old and tried, but I also believe that not to change and evolve is to wither and die. There have been many negative comments about the new format, and my first reaction was not positive, but I figured I'd give it a chance before passing judgment. I find myself adapting quite quickly to the new format. As to the adds, as in published media they keep the prices down, and in the case of Wood Central keep it free to those who choose not to support it: I'll put up with all of them, read some of them, and even make purchases now and again. Coming to think of it, I should probably mention that I'm purchasing based on adds seen on Wood Central when I do place orders; couldn't hurt and might help support this excellent site. All I can say is a great big THANK YOU to Ellis and crew for all the work they put into maintaining and, dare I say it, improving this site.

Cheers!

Jim

Re: The new Wood Central

#4

Steven Antonucci

I don't mind the ads at all-

steve antonucci

>But I miss the "frames" to read a thread and the back and forth to read is a bit disruptive. Other than that, I think its a pretty nice overhaul.

Ad revenue is a must for a site like WC. We can't fault Ellis for paying the bills, but I think that all of the change at one time scared a bunch of people. It also came without warning, so it's been a "figure it out" rollout. Imagine waking up one morning in England and not knowing how to drive on the wrong side of the road, on the wrong side of the car and with the metric speed limits. Then print the road signs in German just for giggles.

A short message saying "Hey, there's a new look and feel coming with ads and no frames..." would have probably cut the rumbling down by half or better.

Steven

Re: The new Wood Central

#5

Re: The new Wood Central

TomCollins

>I usually use Opera and was having all kinds of problems with the new format. Now I've started using IE to view WC and I like the new format. No speed issues. I think it is especially handy to set the preferences to Guestbook. That way you can read all the responses to a thread without having to open new windows or flip back and forth.

I'm as old as most of the wood I turn and don't care for change too much but I must admit the new format is growing on me. As for the ads, I find them unobrusive and ignore them.

The only problem I have now is that some of the pictures don't fit my screen.

FWIW,

TomC

Re: The new Wood Central

#6

Ric Taylor

Re: The new Wood Central

Ric Taylor

>Now that I've used the new format for a few days, I really like it. There are fewer mouse clicks involved, which means easier navigating. I have found that Mixed Threaded Guestbook preferences make everything very easy for me.

I'm confused about all of the discussion regarding ads. I don't see any more that I ever saw in the past, in fact I think I'm seeing fewer than before. I suspect that viewers with newer, larger screens with higher resolution might find the ads less noticeable, since they would appear smaller on the screen.

I'm just greatful to Ellis and his helpers who provide this great site, and I'll take it in any format.

Ric

Re: The new Wood Central

#7

Re: The new Wood Central

Denis Putland from Saskatchewan

>I have no real problems with the new format. Works good for me.

I like it even better now that the red boxes are gone:::)))

Denis

Re: The new Wood Central

#8

Thank you Ellis... the red boxes are gone :)

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The red boxes were a bit to bright. Everyone hates change, well I do anyhow but this will be fine.

Re: The new Wood Central

#9

Re: The new Wood Central

Cyril Griesbach

>Ditto on the red boxes. They certainly weren't necessary and I, too, am glad they're gone. I'm having no problem with the new format now that I'm used to it but when I first encountered it my reaction was less kind than "Now What?" The adds don't bother me a bit and when I do make online purchases from these advertisers I try to do it linking through WC.

Re: The new Wood Central

#10

Re: The new Wood Central

Ruth Harding

>I had no problem changing to the new format immediately. I too don't know what the issue is with the ads, I really don't see them. Based on the majority of the negative comments it seems that a lot of people are not that comfortable with software, as opposed to computers. It appears as if they only know one way to do something and when they can't do it that way, they see it as a problem with the software and not with their lack of ability to play with software and explore other ways of doing things.

Re: The new Wood Central

#11

Thanks, Russ...and here is a further update...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>...that I posted on the main board this morning. It explains some of what we've been up to in the past couple days since we uploaded the new messageboard scripts. By the time we're done tweaking, I have the feeling everyone will be glad for the changes. I hope. :-)

Good morning, folks. I appreciate your patience as we try to address all the issues that you have brought to our attention in the past three days regarding the changes to our messageboard format. Your feedback has been very helpful and I thank you for it. I am sorry that some of you have had such strong reactions. Rest assured, we're only doing this in the interests of improving the existing board system. I admit that some of these changes could have been tested more thoroughly in advance, but many of them simply needed to be put out there for you to critique, and you have done that.

We did a detailed survey of all the comments that were offered on the Messages and Turning boards (the Hand Tools comments were in a similar vein) and found some interesting things:

- Of 149 comments, 56 were negative, 42 positive and 51 neutral (primarily advice, without a judgement one way or the other)

- Of the negative comments, 31 were about the speed of the new setup. Interestingly, we made numerous changes on Thursday that improved the speed of loading, primarily of the index page, and after Thursday there were only 2 negative comments about the loading speed. The speed issue is primarily a result of setting the sort-order default to UBB order instead of Mixed order. This change forces our server to go through an additional process each time you reload your message index. We are now planning to revert the default to the Mixed order, and those of you who really like the UBB order (and are willing to wait a little longer for the index page to refresh each time) can choose the UBB order in your preferences page. The google ads and the major sponsor ads in the left column only marginally increase the loading time, but we're continuing to work on them as well.

- There were 11 negative comments about navigating back and forth between messages and the index page. Those of you who didn't use the horizontal frames option before found very little difference. Those who did prefer the frames view before found yourselves having to explore new ways to navigate. The best suggestions offered so far are to open messages in either a new window or a new tab, and then to close that tab or window when you have finished reading a particular thread. I hope that those of you who complained have now had a chance to try one of these methods. (Hold either the SHIFT or CTRL key when clicking a message title.)

- Six negative comments were about the guestbook format, which really had nothing to do with the major changes, but we have removed the red boxes as requested.

- Nine negative comments were in regard to the Google ads overlapping the pictures and/or text in the message view. This only occurs when a picture larger than the available space is included in a message. Since the photo cannot be resized on the fly by our server, it simply dives under the Google text. When this happens, any accompanying text also dives under there. To fix this situation, we are about to introduce another innovation: thumbnailed photos. When you click on a thumbnail, the message frame will dim and the photo will open in a large dedicated window that you can close when you are done viewing the photo. I think you will like this innovation, but, asl ever, your feedback is appreciated.

Among other changes that have been going on largely unannounced here (I am on the road and unable to be in here 24/7 again until next Tuesday), we have "floated" the navigation box so that it stays visible as you scroll down the screen. We will be making a few more minor changes to this feature in coming days.

Later today, you will notice still more changes, including the thumbnail photos that I mentioned above. We have also shortened the long URLs that some of you mentioned, although it will cause all your messages titles to revert to blue (unread) the first time you visit the boards after we upload this change. We have also reformatted the Google ads to make them less obtrusive. Next week, we will address another of your concerns by substituting static "major sponsor" ads for the ones that are currently animated. We have also removed all the browser errors you reported, none of which had to do with tracking cookies.

So, as you can see, your comments are not being taken lightly. My concern is to come up with a new board format that fixes a lot of the problems we used to have with the old framed approach, notably unreadable pages, poor search engine visibility, clumsy navigation, and a host of other drawbacks inherent in this 15 year old software. Sooner or later, as soon as we can find the right package, we will consider moving yet another notch into the 21st century by adopting a PHP-based messageboard system, similar to those used by other forums you might visit. No promises on this, as I still have a lot of problems with those systems.

Meanwhile, I think we have now incorporated solutions to most (if not quite all) the issues you have raised. We couldn't have done it without you. I hope you will continue getting accustomed to the new setup. I think it will grow on you.

Thanks again for your indulgence.

Best,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: The new Wood Central

#12

Re: The new Wood Central

eaglesc

>Without content there would be no reason to advertise here.

The overly large immoveable navigation bar is a waste of viewing space.

If I enlarge the text everything gets superimposed over advertisements.

I downloaded Firefox only to find that IE7 was easier to use.

I can remove the ads with firefox but that also removes posted pictures.

I can set my preferences the same as I used to have them and had no problem navigating the site the way it was.

Having the ads scroll through a menu looks like the site was designed by a 5 year old who was not computer literate.

If I want to visit advertisers sites I know how to find them,that's why God invented Google.

Russ you know I respect you immensly, but I have problems navigating your site(unless it has been changed recently)

But hey what do I know? I'm not a turner, I only make pens.

This site is geared for bowl turners.

Pen crafters are regarded as redheaded step children here, (newbies)

Re: The new Wood Central

#13

Ellis...

Steven Kubien

>...the fact that you asked for feedback and implemented a great deal is part of what makes this the best board around, in my not so humble opinion. Thanks for caring about what we think and keep up the great work.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: The new Wood Central

#14

Re: The new Wood Central

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Admittedly, I haven't looked at every post you've made with your pens, but the ones I have seen have consistently gotten good response from everyone who chooses to respond because you do more than just "turn pens." I can understand your frustration with the new format for the site, but I don't think the red-haired stepchild comment is being fair to the rest of us.

As far as your problems are concerned, I guarantee that Ellis will do everything he can to address them. Honestly, he didn't do this just to upset you.

Gary

Re: The new Wood Central

#15

Re: Hey, Redhead... :)

Allen Neighbors

>I love your pens :)... and if you ain't a turner, there ain't no such!

As far as the new format is concerned, Ellis, I cheer you. I have opted for the guestbook option, and all the posts to each thread is shown at the same time... all I have to do is scroll down to read them.

One click, and the thumbnails pop up faster, and one more click and they're gone and you're back reading comments. It's much faster for me!

Re: The new Wood Central

#16

Re: Ellis... Just tried the guest book

Ron in Drums PA

>Pretty good, I like it

I noticed though the only the original thread that you click on shows as read, even if there are multiple responses.

Also, any chance on adding an "Edit Post" feature?

Re: The new Wood Central

#17

Re: The new Wood Central

don central illinois

>Anyone that can turn what you do is, not only a turner, but a turner

'par excellence'. Sorry you feel this way, but don't quit yet, I still want to see your pens. Even if you claim you are not a turner.

I only dream of being able to do what you do.

Re: The new Wood Central

#18

No and no

Ellis Walentine, Host

>The guestbook style only displays the parent thread as read. I guess they assumed that if you called up the parent thread you would read all the sub threads.

Editing posts is simply not possible, at least not as far as I have been able to determine.. I have ragged on the developers of our software for years but they have no good way to allow editing. There is a feature that allows posters to delete their posts. I have never activated this feature. Maybe sometime I should give it a try.

Ellis

Re: The new Wood Central

#19

Tricky Question

Ron in Drums PA

>The ability to delete posts is a great tool for trolls to fuel an argument

Re: The new Wood Central

#20

Posts don't turn green as being read, but

Charlie Anderson

>the next time you come back and the new cookie is used, new posts will have the red cherry in front and you can click on the the first unread message. That said, unless there's been a change, the first message to be shown is not always the one you would expect. It would be nice if that was fixed.

Re: The new Wood Central

#21

Re: Posts don't turn green as being read, but

Dan Donaldson

>The first messge shown depends on your preferences settings. Check out the preferences page for explanations. Hopefully, one of the options will be what you want.

Re: The new Wood Central

#22

Re: No and no

eaglesc

>"Editing posts is simply not possible, at least not as far as I have been able to determine.. I have ragged on the developers of our software for years but they have no good way to allow editing. There is a feature that allows posters to delete their posts. I have never activated this feature. Maybe sometime I should give it a try."

If these are the same developers that designed the new changes not only did you get screwed on the changes but they don't seem to be service oriented.

What's their name?

Lousy websites r-us?

Re: The new Wood Central

#23

Re: No and no

Carole Valentine

>There are plenty of other turning web sites that may have the features that you are looking for. Although WC is for ALL turning, including pens, there are some sites out there that specialize in pencrafting only. I just don't understand why you keep complaining about WC if you think you are a "red-headed stepchild" here. You have been saying "But what do I know? I am only a pen turner." for so long that you are going to force everyone to believe it.

The tweaks Ellis has made have solved most of the initial problems. BTW, I am using enlarged text in Firefox and have no problem at all. I also tried the ad blocker extension and it does not block pictures in Firefox. I am not using it because it doesn't seem to affect speed that much and the ad overlapping problem has apparently been fixed. I also know that without ads, WC may cease to exist. It's his site and Ellis could say the heck with this - it's just not worth it, but he hasn't. Give him a break. If I have adjusted to it, anyone can!

Re: The new Wood Central

#24

Re: The new Wood Central

Jim King

>It all looks nice to me and I personally like the advertising and consider it as informative as reading the posts and seeing peoples work..

Re: The new Wood Central

#25

Thanks Carole

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Even I was able to figure it out. So simple a monkey could do it!

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

You know every time something on line changes I learn something new, and for that I also enjoy the challenge.

Again Thanks Ellis and the team working this, something new to learn is fine with me....

Take care,

Jim